Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Aska_Badoura
Okay. The animator in me protests to all this negativity about the animation. The animation is on par with anything else they've ever done. The opening scene with them doing their acrobatics in the sitting room is beautiful. Just the right amount of anticipation, motion, and follow-through, nothing less than what I'd expect of this team after four seasons. The whole scene when Cody was falling, with Mikey diving to catch him, and missing, the Gunjin shoving him aside and leaping off the roof, as well as Raph riding the hover-thing, was all wonderful. Leo coming at Cody with his katana to slice the ropes was also beautiful. There is nothing here that I would call sub-par. If you don't like the style, than say the style, not the animation. If you have an issue with any of the actual motion, that's fine, but it's no worse than anything else we've seen in this show, and much better than several other episodes I could name. It may just be semantics to you guys, but it's driving me crazy to see people fussing about the animation when it hasn't changed. You may not like the more simplified style of the individual drawings, but that's NOT the fault of the animators. Your issue is with the production side. Give the people a break!
|
As one of the people still not-quite-impressed with the animation, allow me to explain.
You do have to agree that the first episode was sub-par as far as animation is concerned. As in the actual movements, yes. Even the worse 2k3 episodes tend to look better than that.
This second installment... much better. The opening "training" scene (which makes me angry because I
know Splinter raised them better than that, and there he is egging them on...?!) had some decent stuff going on.
But I think that the very designs we don't like are making the animation look bad. They look like they were created more "to look cool" than "to look good animated." Therefore, even if the movements are right, it looks wrong. They don't seem to work well in 3D, which is why things like head turns look so bad.
Splinter looked better in this episode (IMO) because his design changed (on purpose or not) so it looks more like it did before. And I think it looks better in motion.
Again... this is only what
I think. It looks bad not because the animators suddenly suck, but because nobody has figured out how to rescue those designs yet. (And the envirosuit thingies must be murder to keep drawing over and over... those poor people...)