Thread: Rate the game!
View Single Post
Old 12-07-2006, 07:18 PM   #175
Peanut
Second Gear
 
Peanut's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: The New World
Posts: 15,422
I do now! There won't be any spoilers in this BTW, so feel free to read it without worrying. Here it goes...

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
Nintendo
Wii

Graphics: Twilight Princess is a mixed bag. When you've been steadily playing high-end Xbox 360 games for months, it gets kinda hard to move back down to last-gen graphics. This is Zelda though, and that really doesn't make a difference. Is it kind of sad to see bland textures and flat environments? Yeah, but the game has some great design that really offsets the ugly. I'm still of the belief that as time goes on, Twilight Princess will become an ugly game, just as OoT has become, as opposed to something like the Wind Waker, which has a timeless quality to it. As much as it was talked about that the Wii version of TP would be doing some stuff that just wasn't possible on a Cube, those things were either cut, or make so little difference that it hardly even matters. There are parts of the game that look beautiful, but there are also parts where you'll want to cringe. The game also has a pretty dull colour palette. Lots of browns and greens, it does lend itself well to the atmosphere of the game though, which is generally pretty dark, so it's fitting.

I don't think anyone was really going into this game hoping for a huge graphical boost, and I certainly hope that's true, because those people will be disappointed. It's a good thing the character and environment designs are so good, because when stacked up to the games of today, TP just doesn't cut it.
Score: 7.5

Sound: This is probably one of the things I'm most disappointed about, and I know that I'm not alone. Maybe I am on this forum, but not in general. Twilight Princess sounds like it was made way back in 1998. The music, while it has it's high points, is generally un-impressive, especially for a Zelda game. Why the game wasn't orchestrated is a mystery to me. People will argue all about it not needing to be, but those people are wrong. This isn't the mid-90's. It's also fairly disappointing that there's so much re-used in TP. I know some of the familiar tunes gives it a nice link to OoT, but it still seems more lazy than anything else. Of particular note, the Twilight Realm has some of the worst music and sound effects I've heard since PoP:Warrior Within. Everything is a loud, annoying, high-pitched squeal and the music just sounds like someone on acid pounding on a synth machine. I would find myself turning my sound all the way down, so as not to endure it. Utterly horrific and not befitting of the Zelda franchise at all.

Once again, Nintendo decided to not have voice-overs. It's getting old now. It used to make sense, it even used to be charming, but enough is enough. There's no excuse anymore. I never thought this way until PM:TTYD came out, but now I firmly believe it. I know Link will never speak, and that's fine, but the other characters need to. Reading scrolling text is a thing of the past. Even more perplexing is that they even put some elaborate lip-synch in on a majority of the characters. Completely baffling.

Another problem comes from the use of the Wii-mote speaker. The thing is bad. It's just not a good speaker. The quality is awful, it sounds super tiny, and sometimes you'll even get static and weird pops coming from it for no reason. That really sucks considering all of Link's weapon sounds come directly from that little speaker. It's a really cool concept, but poorly executed. The fact that you can't even turn it off and allow the sounds to come from your TV is even more confusing. Another bad move that just makes the game feel more dated that it needs to be.
Score: 5.0

Story: One of the things vastly improved in Twilight Princess is the story. There are actually some interesting characters in this game, and some of the friendships you make actually work this time around. There are actually secondary characters with active roles in TP, something the Zelda series always needed. A lot of the cut-scenes are really terrific too, they're not overly long, boring or chatty, and the animations and expressions used by the characters are top notch. There are some twists here in there, all of which are obvious, but it's still more fleshed out than previous Zelda games.
Score: 8.0
Peanut is offline   Reply With Quote