The original cartoon made Shredder THE TMNT villain. Everyone grew up with the old show, which is why we always think about him.
That's why the 2k3 series featured Shredder so heavily as well, (outside of Season 4 and FF), he's THE #1 villain everyone thinks about for TMNT. 4kids kept him much longer in the series than the original comics did, and for good reason.
Hell, Playmates is making a Movie figure of Shredder despite the fact that he's not even in the movie, and they're doing it because they know Shredder sells.
In any case, I find it amusing that so many interviews has Munroe suggesting Shredder may turn up in a possible sequal. If they stick with Movie 2's continuity...wonder how he'll come back this time...since several years passed, didn't they? I'm sure he's still not under all those boards.