Precisely (EDIT: That's a precisely to what triplexxx said. It seems I took too long to post my message). The personalities of the four turtles is so perfectly balanced that if you remove any one of them, the other three would soon split up. An excellent example is that one episode of the 2k3 series where Donny goes to a future where he's been missing for around 30 years. The same would very easily happen if any of the other turtles died, left, or disappeared.
Back to topic... How on earth can you possibly force us to choose just one turtle?! I love them all so much, and I have something in common with every single one of them. I'm the oldest child so I have the same responsibilities that Leo has. I've always been very book-smart like Donny. I can be a really grumpy punk like Raph. I can be really goofy like Mikey as my friends can attest, though I seldom let that monster out anymore (my Mikey side can be dangerous, I say!). So for me it's really hard to choose a favorite.
Overall, though, I think I have the most in common with Leo and Donny (hmm, is it coincidence that I relate to the turtles that are typically considered the eldest?). I love Raph as well. Mikey is probably my least favorite but only because he's rarely portrayed the way I think he should be. The cartoons and movies always portray Mikey as being the incredibly carefree, innocent, and childish turtle, but I've always seen him as being just as serious as the others and he just uses his humor to break the mood and keep the peace. I think Mikey is the only turtle that truly
needs the other three. They all need each other, but I think Mikey would be the most devastated if anything happened to any of the others. In any case, Mikey's not really my least favorite turtle, but he hasn't been portrayed very well in most media which is why he's not my favorite.
Someone said it before, but I think it bares repeating -- Leo and Raph are very, very similar in personality. The difference is that Leo is a little more rational and responsible while Raph is more fierce and passionate. Leo controls his passion by holding strictly to a moral code while Raph does whatever's necessary to protect his family or himself at the expense of any grief it may cause him later on. This is why their personalities clash so much. They're not opposite to each other by any means, but they do balance each other out when they work together. Leo controls Raph, and Raph pushes Leo to go the extra mile. Right now, I'm going to let loose my Donny side. Imagine Leo and Raph as being two vectors (line segments with arrows on the end). Rather than being antiparallel (pointing in opposite directions) think of them as being perpendicular. They still go in different directions, but they both strive toward a particular goal. When you add the two together you get a single vector that points straight forward and is nearly twice as long as the two vectors were individually. In this way, Leo and Raph balance each other out and push each other further than they could normally go on their own rather than canceling each other out (as they would if they were antiparallel).
I hope that wasn't too terribly confusing... But now you can see why I favor Donny as well. I love to use my smarts to understand, solve, and explain things. And not just technical things either. The thing I love about Donny is that he's smart in all areas. His expertise may be in technology and invention, but he stays relatively balanced by learning and understanding other things as well. Also, many people see Raph as being the "loner" of the group, but in reality Leo, Raph, and Donny are all loners. They just choose to handle it and express themselves in different ways. Raph expresses it the most obvious way by getting angry at people and using that as an excuse to get away from them. Leo expresses it by going off and training and meditating on his own all the time and becoming engrossed in Bushido or whatever it's called. Donny expresses it by becoming engrossed in his work and studies. They each use these things to escape the concerns of life. Mikey is the only one who's not really a loner because he desperately needs other people in his life. The others could probably handle themselves fine if they all split up, but I don't think Mikey would take it very well. I honestly don't think Raph would be able to handle it either, so you might argue that he's less of a loner than Leo or Donny is. If a disaster happened (such as
in the comics) Leo would go off on his own to meditate or what not, Donny would engross himself in work, and Raph would either get angry at the world or drown out his troubles with beer, but Mikey would surround himself with other people. All of this more or less happened in the comics.
Ugh, this is getting long. In short, Donny is probably my favorite turtle. Though I don't like how he's always able to miraculously invent almost anything that the turtles need, I do like his personality and how he handles things. Leo is also a close second. He has a great sense of loyalty just like Raph, but his sense of honor keeps that loyalty from allowing him to be consumed with righteous rage when something happens to a loved one. As for Raph and Mikey, well, you can't help but just love those two.
How's that for a first post?!
I realize most of what I've said in this post has probably been said before, but I like to spell things out and squish them all together so they're easy to understand and digest.
A couple last quick notes that I didn't get to, but wanted to:
- Donny seems to be even more of a loner to me because none of the other turtles really understand him. Leo seems to appreciate him the most, but it's more of a "high respect and regard" for Donny than an "understanding" kind of thing.
- I think Raph is closer to Mikey than any of the other turtles (though the movies made it seem like Mike and Donny were closer). He almost seems like a "big brother" to Mikey while Leo is almost a "big brother" or "twin" to Donny. I
love those pairings, but I'm disappointed that we don't see more interaction between Raph & Donny and Leo & Mikey. (though I hear Raph & Donny have some good scenes in later issues of Volume 4)