1. Promotion for TMNT sucked "eggs"...
2. Plot was not tied in enough to the story -- we were not reminded enough of its imminence or importance... PLUS.... come on guys. 13 monsters? Immortal warlords?? Stone generals??? Every 3000 years????? etc....
To be fair though, it helps if you've seen Ghostbusters, I think. I enjoyed this movie because it felt a lot like a good hybrid of TMNT and ghostbusters...
To me, this movie really felt like it was lifted out of some theoretical classic TMNT comic -- from the characters's story, to the outrageously 'out there' plot... the comics were parodying things, but it was hard to tell because it took itself 'seriously' as a parody. I think this movie did that as well -- I saw all these references to previous major movies -- Ghostbusters, Gremlins, LOTR, Shrek/Beauty and the Beast... Unlike an actual pure comedy, however, TMNT does not spell out to the audience what it's parodying. To me, I was just all the more amused by the seriousness of it all. For many people, though -- I think they like to have their genres spelled out.
TMNT 2007 (even the first film) reminds me a lot of movies like Ghostbusters, Gremlins, LXG, Hellboy -- movies that are sort of dark, and are meant to be fun, though not pure goofball comedies. They can even have an appropriate amount of weight to them, which I felt the new TMNT movie had. I'm surprised there's no legitimate name for these kinds of films. It's definitely an unnamed genre. They aren't just action films. They are "things-that-go-bump-in-the-night" films. Slightly dark and sinister, crazy for sure, serious if it chooses to be, but always tons of fun.
3. They really need to re-edit this movie without pandering to the censors or concern for time. What matters most is that the movie be tightly strung together -- the slightly loose feel of the movie probably turned off some people with little patience for the outlandishness of the genre -- like snooty film critics or those who didn't grow up really embracing the TMNT.
4. We needed some more, very genuine, very strong humor. We had great action. It would have been better to have great humor to balance it -- the humor would have to be smart and well timed. Some stupid humor is a given, but not the majority of it, and certainly not the highlight scenes featured in trailers (Mikey's burp was disgusting, and while it did show us how immature he is, it wasn't inherently funny.) Jersey devil is a pretty good example of action humor, and I think that scene was actually more popular than people here realize. We needed to move a little more into the direction of "injured turtles at breakfast" because the humor there was grounded in their character interactions.
__________________
We're calling it a freeway. Eight lanes of shimmering cement running from here to Pasadena. Smooth, safe, fast. Traffic jams will be a thing of the past. I see a place where people get on and off the freeway. On and off, off and on all day, all night! Soon there will be a string of gas stations, inexpensive motels, restaurants that serve rapidly prepared food! Tire salons, automobile dealerships and wonderful, wonderful billboards reaching as far as the eye can see! My God... It'll be beautiful.