View Single Post
Old 04-15-2007, 06:48 PM   #545
Masked Ninja
Doodles TMNT for fun
 
Masked Ninja's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: sploshin' through some sewer...
Posts: 2,137
Quote:
Originally Posted by Warhorse View Post
We all have our differences and opinions. I jsut think the fact that detail to the breathing of the Turtles alone, was ages away from Pixar.

As for the lip sync, i found no problem with this movie. Did you see the same movie I did? Did you see the reaction and tension built during the Raph vs Leo part? When they were arguing, with Raph shouting out that he is calling his own shots, and Leo blasting on him for what was he thinking, endangering the lives of the family. What about Leo spitting like a real fighter would when getting the wind knocked out of him by Raph. I have seen nothing from Pixar that comes even close to this.
Well, the Leo vs. Raph sequence was nearly perfect. And yes, I like that scene more than most of what Pixar has done, I will admit... they don't tend to go for the raw arguments (and when they do something close, you still never really get the sense that the two characters may never make up, much less one might come within a hair of killing the other). Plus most of the acting in that part was great. THAT part was top notch.

But I stand by my assertion that while it was acceptable most of the time, there were parts where I cringed at the awful lipsync. There are a few moments like that in the Leo/April talk inthe beginning. One of the worst cases is when Mikey say "Oho! Someone's cranky!" that makes me wonder if they changed the voice clip at the last minute and left the animation as it was.

I'm not bashing TMNT as a whole; it will go down in history as being severely underrated. It did quite a few things Pixar hasn't touched (I'll have to watch again for the breathing - of course Pixar characters will do it when called for, but having it go on all the time? Maybe a rewatch of both TMNT and my favorite Pixars will be in order. ), but Pixar's still got it beat in some ways.

Ahh, and enter the Fled. You know, I do agree that CG animation can't be treated quite the same as 2D, especially since some of the zanier stuff looks way better as a collection of lines than a solid virtual shape. (That was part of my beef with Madagascar, along with many other things... while I appreciated the use of intense squash and stretch, it was overdone and the 'tooniness got annoying after a while) And yeah, overacting is not necessarily the best way. Why I like how Pixar does their stuff are the little acting subtlties that a lot of other companies don't take to that level. There's some overacting, sure, but it reads a lot better in animation than live action.

The acting issues I have in TMNT are the occasional overdone bits. There's a bit between Raph and Don where Raph goes "Yeah... you got me all figured out!" and he moves way more than I would think Raph would, tilts his head, and even points for effect. Though there are some times where the animation acting is understated and it does read better.

Again, I'm not trying to say that Pixar is still leagues ahead. TMNT is dang close. I'm just noting that there was still room for improvement, which could probably have been aided by a bigger budget and more time to check over animation in some scenes. (the lipsync issues are the most annoying - acting problems are only here and there)

This topic makes me feel like a pessimist who hates the movie. I don't... in fact, I loved it a lot. There are plenty of subtle things that just make it work. But I'm also an animation major and one of the best ways I can learn is by picking apart what others have done.
Masked Ninja is offline   Reply With Quote