View Single Post
Old 04-15-2007, 10:44 PM   #4
Fledermaus
Mad Scientist
 
Fledermaus's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: SoCal
Posts: 1,115
They call me -- LONG POST.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Masked Ninja View Post
The acting issues I have in TMNT are the occasional overdone bits. There's a bit between Raph and Don where Raph goes "Yeah... you got me all figured out!" and he moves way more than I would think Raph would, tilts his head, and even points for effect. Though there are some times where the animation acting is understated and it does read better.
Hm.... Hm.... I'll have to watch that particular Raph-Don scene again. (The head tilting I agree with, but I attribute that more to the fact that the animators are Chinese people trying to make their characters seem American. Overall... I really think it lacked time. See, if there had been a Pixar-level investment in polishing, someone could have pointed out some of the more awkward bits. I keep thinking again of the budget and the time and the experience of those in charge... eh. Remember, I ranted about how crappy the movie looked when I saw the first trailer. I ranted about how it looked like a video game (which it certainly does in some sequences). I believed that there was little to no hope for this movie and that I could only be utterly disappointed. If I remember correctly, you were a lot more hopeful despite the fact that TMNT had a supa low budget with a first-time film director whose only background has been in... just look up Kevin on IMDB ... compared to Pixar. (correct me if I'm wrong, I apologize).

You know what? I'm done comparing TMNT to Pixar. TMNT's always been this underground thing to begin with whereas Pixar is more about creating art and great cinema. Just compare TMNT to itself. We know sure as hell what could have been improved.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Masked Ninja
This topic makes me feel like a pessimist who hates the movie. I don't... in fact, I loved it a lot. There are plenty of subtle things that just make it work. But I'm also an animation major and one of the best ways I can learn is by picking apart what others have done.
You don't need a degree to be an animator or to study animation compulsively. Some people just take the side-entrance.

But I don't think you look like a pessimist. Just look at all those people in the several "things I found annoying about the movie" thread. They're picking TMNT apart despite the fact (perhaps because of the fact) that they loved it.

My frustration as far as looks go had to do, I think, with the budget of this film; I got the impression that there wasn't enough experienced, professional direction (for movies, that is; I realize that a lot of these guys were professionals, but I remember reading that their backgrounds were mostly in TV and video game animation), not to mention any cultural barriers despite best attempts at communication. Those are much bigger roadblocks than I think most people realize.

So you see, that is why I get so bent out of shape about how much money there is for a sequel. I'll be genuinely pissed if they are unable to improve on the "cleanup" or spotting repetitiveness and awkward moments in the animation. It would be a major shame if money or the need to cater to a rating or time limit got in the way of things.

I think that, with the current leadership and the animation staff, it is unrealistic to expect that the animators will settle for anything better than generic acting. It only got awkward when the generic acting (like Raph's wild head tilting, the excessive pointing -- which I thin only worked really well in the rain scene -- or Mikey's exuberant expressions in front of the TV... ) lost sight of staying understated.

The same principle applies in real-life acting. Damn how do i say this?... I remember how my director would get on our case about being over the top when our main idea wasn't that special or creative. That's when generic acting crosses the line from looking natural (not very theatrical, but at least dignified) to looking forced (trying to hard to be bigger than it is).

BTW, another instance of repetitive animation...

A lot of people praised the "subtle" action of Don holding Mikey back so that Raph and Leo could have some down time at the battle. I thought it was appropriate. Maybe it was. However, when Splinter does the exact same thing to Raph only five minutes later, I started wondering. Did Raph have some special bond with Max? Did he have some particular tendency that needed to be addressed by this action?... My guess is probably no and that that was thrown that in for the hell of it. Though stuff like this did not outweigh the many strong scenes, thank God. But it was still noticeable *grimaces* ... The look and animation in TMNT felt like, at worst, an unfinished project, overall well done, but certainly not lacking in its sloppy moments.

Now over the hedge did not have standout sloppy moments. But ultimately, I care more about whether the CG movie has ANYthing that makes me go -- woooooww.... TMNT had this. Over the Hedge, for all its cleverness and professional finished quality, did not.

Sorry for the long Fledermaus post.
__________________
We're calling it a freeway. Eight lanes of shimmering cement running from here to Pasadena. Smooth, safe, fast. Traffic jams will be a thing of the past. I see a place where people get on and off the freeway. On and off, off and on all day, all night! Soon there will be a string of gas stations, inexpensive motels, restaurants that serve rapidly prepared food! Tire salons, automobile dealerships and wonderful, wonderful billboards reaching as far as the eye can see! My God... It'll be beautiful.

Last edited by Fledermaus; 04-16-2007 at 01:48 AM.
Fledermaus is offline   Reply With Quote