Raph as leader = chaos
Everything is just do or die without thinking. For example in the movie, when they confronted Big Foot, he's the one suggesting "I say we stop talking!" and charge at the beast.
I think if Shredder has a laser gun machine ready, raph will still charge through and got himself and everybody killed in an instant. To me as a leader it's all not about rage. That doesn't show might or smart at all. A leader is someone who makes good decision(watched the apprentice and that's very true) and weight every alternatives heavily and not blinded by their own emotions and passion.
So Don is the perfect choice. Sorry raph. Mikey...not yet I guess, but I bet it'll be hillarious if he's being a leader.:p