View Single Post
Old 04-26-2007, 09:52 PM   #310
Courk
Hench Mutant
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Posts: 321
My take on the "No" scene:

If you watch Splinter, he lights up when Mikey offers dessert, and before anyone says "No." Splinter wants cake, his body language is saying that, so he'd be the one to say "Yes."

There is definitely one disgusted "No!" from Donnie or Leo (I don't have a grip on their voices, so I can't guess).

The other voice sounds more bored or depressed. I can't remember what's happening right before this in the movie, but were either Donnie or Leo a bit down?

I think what we're hearing is one quick, disgusted "NO!" on top of a "Yes!" from Splinter and another drawn-out sigh-like "No" -- but whoever said the drawn-out "No" started speaking first.

So:

Noooooo
...NO!
.......Yes!

We start out hearing enough of the "Noooooo" to recognize the word, then "NO!" begins. Once the "NO!" is done, we're still catching the tail-end of the "Noooooo". Since we already recognized it as a word, then heard someone else say "NO!", I think we're interpreting it as a new word, when it's really a continuation of the one we first heard. And Splinter wants cake.

Edit: The reason the "Yes" is more delayed is because Splinter is excited. If someone asked you if you wanted to eat spiders, most likely you'd be saying "No" before they finish the question. If someone asked you to go to a concert of your favorite band that you thought was sold out with a backstage pass, there's a pause of shock between the question and your "Yes!" Those are extreme examples, but the other two turtles really don't want cake, while Splinter really does.

What were Donnie's and Leo's temperaments just before this scene?
Courk is offline   Reply With Quote