My grade: B
I have to say I really enjoyed the movie, best comicbook movie of the
year so far(better then any comicbook movie released last year for that
matter).
The animation was very impressive, espicially given the time and financial
constraints, not to mention this was Imagi's first theatrical release.
The subplot with Leo and Raph was well done, their fight scene was
easily the best setpiece of the movie.
I personally have no problem with the monster plot in itself other then it felt
underdeveloped, but I was kinda expecting that after I heard the runtime
for this movie was only around eighty minutes.
Some of the problems I felt that the movie had was of course not
enough Donatello and Mikey, especially when you already have a
built in plot device in the monsters. While Leo and Raph are off pounding
each other into mush, Donny and Mikey could have been dealing the monsters,
giving them more face time and adding more depth to the main plot.
While I agree with the decision not to go with Shredder as the main
villain, I would have liked it if they had started the movie off with
a "final battle" between the turtles and Shredder(forgetting the lame
death from the second movie).
As for the Villains in this movie, Karai needed much more development
then what she got, perhaps more then other character outside of the
four turtles. Max Winters was nicely done, but since he was not really
a villain, more attention should have been given to the generals,at least
General Aguila.
And I too will have to join others in saying that I was not a big fan of
the human designs by Jeff Matsuda.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB
True, which is why it's sad this opportunity was thblown. The best thing that could happen to TMNT before this movie was made was a good, long lull period. Say, 10 years. No cartoons, no toys, no TMNT socks or backpacks, nothing but maybe the Mirage comics anywhere in the media. Let a good generation or two pass, and let folks and the media forget about that stuff. Then BOOM, come out of left field with a proper, edgy PG-13 comic book adaption.
|
If not for the cartoon and toys there would not have been a new TMNT
movie(at least not anytime soon), since one of the big reasons for green lighting the new movie was the success of the toyline for the 2003 cartoon.
And no matter how many generations pass, people and the media will
always associate the turtles with merchandising(unfairly) and the 80's cartoon, especially those who prefer the 80's cartoon over the mirage comic.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB
Now, with this movie sort of bottoming out, even if in 10 years Laird and co. really get serious about making a grassroots, actual comic book adaption film, studios and financiers will laugh and go, "Again? You guys tried that in 2007 and barely broke even!"
|
I definately can say that the movie performed better then what the WB
execs thought it would do, they basically gave the movie up for dead.
Also, if Warner Bros' keeps pumping out flops like the "The Reaping",
those TMNT numbers start looking better and better.