View Single Post
Old 05-17-2007, 03:30 PM   #38
The Shelf
Mad Scientist
 
The Shelf's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 1,031
Quote:
Originally Posted by Janus Prospero View Post
No, that's a good example. I think you make some good points, but it also raises some other related moral issues such as premarital sex and choosing not to get married altogether. We won't get into that, but if those two issues were ok with someone than the issues you mention can occur from cohabitation are kind of moot. I also think that the issues you describe arise from the individual's own lack of willpower as opposed to the situation itself.
Morals and religion aren't the only reason why it's bad. If you don't end up sticking with that person for the rest of your life, then you've just spoiled something that's supposed to be especially for the person you do stick with. And, yes, I agree that lack of willpower is the primary cause that can be attributed to these sorts of issues, but unfortunately, most people don't have that strength of willpower. So why put yourself under that kind of temptation, unless as you said, you're willing to take the risks.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Janus Prospero View Post
In my mind I would only want to live with someone that I intended to marry anyway, and I have. I did not take moving in with someone lightly and therefore the person I live with is someone that I have a strong emotional and spiritual connection with. So, if times became tough and enmity grew between us, this isn't someone I would just consider running out on because it was easier.
Unfortunately, not everyone shares that kind of commitment to someone that they're not legally bound to.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Janus Prospero View Post
I think it's a much wiser idea to make sure you can handle each other under the same roof before 100% committing. Things may not work out, but if you do get married to that person, aren't you that much more secure in the marriage because you know what living with the person will be like?

Besides, would you really want to stay with someone whose only reason for not leaving you is because you're married? That's terrible. I want someone to be with me because they love me, not because they feel they have some obligation to.
I agree, but I don't think it's necessary to live with each other in order to determine whether you can handle each other. Besides, if you marry someone after knowing them for years and later you want to leave them just because you can't bear their little bad habits (which is the only knowledge you stand to gain from living with them) then perhaps you were loving them for the wrong reasons to begin with? I guess that's ultimately my point: the only thing you gain out of living with someone that you can't gain without living with them is discovering what their living habits are. So I don't think your argument about knowing whether or not someone loves you before you get married has anything to do with living with them beforehand. And if you really do love someone, then you're not going to care what their living habits are like. So what do you stand to gain by living together before you get married? No matter which way I look at it, the costs outweigh the benefits, even excluding my own moral and religious beliefs.
The Shelf is offline   Reply With Quote