Heard back from John (he's so fast!) and he says that they only printed the Raphael bookplate. My wallet is rejoicing (although I still think it's an odd choice).
And it sounds like they might be polling customers on which artists and characters to feature on upcoming bookplates. I suggested art by Dan ('cause he's awesome, duh) and art featuring Michaelangelo (also awesome, but also the only Turtle not yet on a bookplate).
Of course, the next collected book is Leo-heavy - Poor Mikey gets so little love.