I think you have very valid opinions here. I certainly don't agree with a lot of what you're saying. I for one, welcome our CGI overlords with open arms. Additionally I didn't find SMG or Stewart distracting (which, just AMAZES me because Stewart's voice is very distinct.)
However, I'm totally feeling you on the "fleshing out the brother's relationships" sort of thing. I would have loved to have seen some Raph/Mike interaction. Although I can sorta understand them wanting Raph and Leo to interact most with each other in order to draw attention to that conflict. But still, we should have had some Don and Mike interaction, perhaps with each other showing some scene where they're dealing with the Raph/Leo thing. In my head I kind of imagine Raph arguing that they need to back him up when he rushes to fight and Leo on the other side arguing that they need to follow his orders, and they're both stuck in the middle.
I really wanted to comment on this though:
Quote:
Originally Posted by raphroehler2003
The plot....plainly it sucked. I'm sorry...to me it did remind me of Ghostbusters and "The 13 Ghosts of Scooby Doo." That was a cartoon that had Scooby, Shaggy, Scrappy, and Daphne team up with a man voiced by Vincent Price to get 13 ghosts back into a treasure chest. Only in this case it's turtles getting monsters into the portal. It's just....there were many better stories, at least to me. City at War. Baxter Stockman/mouser storyline. Many people on the board have said other, better examples of storylines than the one used in this movie. And with it's short running time, it took up quiet a bit of room for something I didn't care about. I wanted to see more of the TMNT....not Winters.
|
I will admit that of the two main conflicts of the movie, the monster part is certainly the less interesting one. I love Raphael and Leonardo and their whole dynamic, so I was eating that stuff up!
I wouldn't say that the monster plot sucked. It carried a theme of brotherhood, that connected it to the turtles plot (although I feel they could have done more with this if the movie was a bit longer.) And mostly, I feel like the plot followed in the spirit of the comics. The turtles have always endured insane sci-fi/fantasy stories. There is no reason to deny that in the movies. That's sort of the reason why I don't mind the time travel aspect of
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III [that movie bothers me for many other reasons].
I can see the City of War suggestion because that story rocked the house. What's more, I feel it would have made perfect sense to use the City of War idea in the new movie. With Leo away training and the turtles forbade from fighting, of course crime was going to get out of control. This would have been an even greater motivation for Raph to go all vigilante, and for April to urge Leo to come back. ::closes eyes:: That would have been freakin' sweet.
But I am really perplexed at your suggestion to use the Baxter/Mouser sub plot. Aren't you just removing your rose colored glasses only to find that you're wearing an extra pair, blinded by your attachment to the story? I mean, as it's from the original comics, I'm attached to that story too, but I don't think it is any better or worse than the monster plot.