View Single Post
Old 08-08-2007, 12:26 PM   #20
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,608
Quote:
Originally Posted by tilallr1 View Post
Well watched it last night and this is the best quality home movie I have ever seen. The clarity was awesome, the details were stunning. Saw so much more of the movie then I did in theaters.

P.S. Blu-ray will win out over HD-DVD, just look at the 50GB disc quality over the HD 15GB-30GB quality. 20GB is alot more more space for video quality and sound. Blu-ray can also potential store in the future much more than that up to 500GB from what I have read. HD is stuck with a max of 30GB. Its obvious from this point alone that HD technology is done before it starts.

But now lets look at the cost of the media. Blu-ray is $4-$5 cheaper. Why, because HD has decided to have a flip feature to support old DVD technology on one side and the new HD version on the other. They thought this would help them win the war, but it hasn't. Why, because people are cheap and if they are buying a HD version of the film they don't care about the old DVD format on there. Its a waste of money.

Finally, DUAL Hi-def players (Which play both blu-ray and HD have entered the market - LG already has a player out and more are coming). They are expensive but will come down over time.

Also, they have anounced that in Japan the creation of a double sided disc with the HD format on one side and blu-ray on the other. So studios can release a high-def version of the film for both formats on one disc. But you can bet those will be expensive.
All valid points. And as more and more of these dual players -- meaning, players that play both HD-DVD and Blu-Ray -- become prevalent, people will simply have to ask the question, "Do I want the HD-DVD, or Blu-Ray version of this movie?" The answer, of course, should be Blu-Ray, with its larger capacity.

Truth is, though, I'm not entirely certain there's a huge demand for either. At least not yet.
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote