I'M going to be one of those "guilty" of double-dipping, too. Mainly because I, like a lot of folks, like the spine-art on the original DVDs and VHS tapes (and yes, I've been collecting those, too. They were CHEAPER than the DVDs when I started getting them. Plus which, at the time, I didn't have a DVD-player.;p), the extras on the DVDs; etc. Admittedly, I'm missing a few of the original DVDs and tapes, but I'm going to get them so my collection will be complete.
(And yes, I'm an obsessive completist. So sue me.

;p )