View Single Post
Old 12-07-2007, 10:36 PM   #107
Warhorse
Emperor
 
Warhorse's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Florida
Posts: 5,544
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sage Ninja View Post
You know I'm starting to wonder if we are maybe being a bit too hard on Mikey's portrayal and nitpicking his goofy moments and calling them stupid just because its Mikey.

Take the scene where Raphael is getting beat up by the Jersey Devil for example. This scene is considered one of the funninst scenes in the whole movie, and it could be argued that it was both goofy and silly and made Raph look at little stupid. But most people thought it was comedic gold and no one was complaining that the writters where screwing up his character to make him look goofy. Now if this scene had been done with mikey instead of Raph would be rolling our eyes at this scene as stupid slap stick humour to entertain the kiddies with Mikey being the victim of more "dumbing down" or would we have thought it was as funny if any other turtle was in the this scene. Some how I don't think we'd appriciate this scene as much if it had been Mikey and probably feel that Mikey's character was getting exploited again for the all mighty laugh.

But why is that? Is it because of Raph's tough guy persona that made the scene of him getting his ass kicked seem genuanly hillarious in this scene instead of silly. Was that what made it work?
Don't know about you, but Mikey's humor seemed forced, while the moment with the Jersey Devil vs Raphael came across as something that would really happen to Raph. Mikey had a few moments, but he wasn't nearly as charming, funny and smart as he was in the first two movies. Remember, he got to have a really good nunchuck duel in the first movie, he quoted really seriously funny lines such as "Wise man says forgiveness is divine, but never pay full price for a late pizza", and he got down right clever with his jokes and fighting, while being funny. In the sequel, he even got a chance to show his creativeness by contributing on figuring out how to feed tokar and razor the solution cubes. And the third movie, he even had moments where they showed him in a serious light. The 2k3 toon has even shown him to be smart and witty on numerous occasions. IDK, I liked Mikey's design in here, them showcasing his athletism and love for kids, but other than that, I found his character development in this movie to be the weakest of the Turtles.
Warhorse is offline   Reply With Quote