View Single Post
Old 02-27-2008, 12:00 AM   #9
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,623
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle View Post
There is no shame in cashing in on nostalgia, all those kids that grew up on the old cartoon are anywhere between their late teens to early thirties, a prime target audience, it was those same nostalgic Transformer fans that went to go watch that movie 5-6 times,
I'm not entirely convinced those people don't represent maybe, at best, 5-10% (and I think I'm being extremely optomistic, even assuming the active membership of this board only represents 5% of the fans out there) of the overall box office take. The other 90-95%? Young teens oblivious to Transformers that saw transforming robot action, the guy from Even Stevens, and slick trailers and went, "Whoa, awesome!" Hell, if I was like 15ish, I might just go see it because of Megan Fox's ass in the trailers.

But yeah, anytime you put the names "Spielburg" and "Bay" on the table at the same time, you're not exactly examining your garden variety movie.

Quote:
there are plenty of old ninja turtle fans to take advantage of (we are talking about 5-6 billion dollar franchise).
OK, but can you quantify that dollar amount into how much longtime TMNT fans like you and I actually brought to the table in that? I suspect only a fraction. A small fraction.

Quote:
As for the casual fan who could care less about the ninja turtles, you need hype and spectacle to get those people to even remotely care about a TMNT based movie, and the current movie had neither of these.
You're absolutely right, but in the case of this movie, you might have seen a significant boost in the opening weekend before word-of-mouth spread around about, "You guys fooled me! It was just a toddler affair!" (by this, I mean the regular movie-going public, not toddlers, tweens, or existing TMNT fans)... but that's about it.

Quote:
I guess it makes perfect sense that evil impulses would cause one to have the urge to boogie down.
No strong feelings on the Spidey dance either way. It could go or it could stay, but it seemed somewhat in line with Spidey II's "Raindrops Keep Fallin' on My Head." But whatever.

Quote:
You're right, the Mirage comics never had mainstream appeal, only the cartoon.
Won't argue that. But neither did material like the Sin City comics, the 300 comics, Hellboy comics, Crow comics, etc., etc..

Quote:
So you are saying kids don't know that Superman is based on a comicbook character,
Kids about 10-15ish, sure.

Quote:
un-huh, well try asking any adult on the street who characthers like Spider-Man, Batman, Superman are, I qurantee you they will tell you they are comicbook characters,
I wasn't talking about adults.

Quote:
ask the average adult on the street who the ninja turtles are they will tell you they are cartoon/videogame characters.
Probably right. The name of the game is opening eyes... but again, TMNT Part 4 set the clock back on that one a good long while, so forget about it.

Quote:
You asked what the difference was between Spider-Man making the jump from campy cartoons to relatively mature movies, asked and answered.
Oh, you're right. Sorry.

Quote:
It's not about awareness, comics like the Crow and Hellboy have it easy, since they are not competing against more popular alternate versions of themselves, they just had the comics.
True.

Quote:
I have no problem with seeing a more faithful adaption of the old comics brought to big screen, and I would hope it would succeed, but just don't act surprise if gets ripped apart by the older cartoon fans
All 30 of the fanatical ones that congregate here? I can live with that. I think you can, too.

Quote:
and flops because it's not what most people are accustomed to when comes to the ninja turtles.
I think we're doing a bit of a dance here. When I'm envisioning a successful TMNT comic book adaptation of the comics on the big screen... I'm not factoring in any of the people that are "accustomed" to one mass media kid-fluff incarnation or another -- it will live or die by the hype it generates in being entirely its own beast.

And again (and again), this can only happen in a vacuum. TMNT -- at least in the mass media -- needs to go into a kind of ice age for a while, let memories of "Cowabungas" and camp and all that fade into a generation that isn't going to be filling the majority of seats anyway. TMNT Part 4 retarded that back a bit... but we can always hope for another 10, 12 years down the road again.

*sigh*

Quote:
umm, I believe you misread me, I said "never".
Then I apologize again. Just running down the line here.

Quote:
Heh, I'm pretty sure there are old cartoon fans saying the same thing about comic readers, "F***'em, let them reread their old comics, the 80's cartoon is the only version that matters".
Oh, those 30 again? They ought to sit down.

Quote:
Just using HP to illustrate the difference between the more kid friendly first book with the last one where everyone is getting killed off, as the books progressively got darker, imagine if they went from one extreme to another.
Thus the need for an ice age. Well, a second ice age... the first one just ended up producing kiddy crap again.

Quote:
Yes, there are those within Imagi/Warner Bros who believe TMNT was too dark and serious and it had a negative effect on the boxoffice, and that the sequel should be more lighter and silly, I'm glad we can agree on this.
When you phrase it like that, yes. The box office numbers came in weekend #2, I absolutely believe they played a bit of "OK, whodunnit?!?" before committees start piping, "It wasn't comedic enough. Look at Ratatouie and Over the Hedge... why can't TMNT be more like that?"

Quote:
You would be surprise how little it would take to please fans of the old cartoon
I don't think I would be -- the ones I think we're talking about already are more than willing to settle for so little.

Though I lump myself in as a fan of the old cartoon. I'm just able to seperate my nostalgia from it enough to go, "That was fun when I was a kid, it's fun now in small doses as nostalgia and when I want to pop a DVD in and go, 'Haha, I remember that episode! That was the sh*t when I was 9 years old!'" but when it comes to actual material that does anything for me on an adult level... yeah, we're really just talking about the comics here.

A bit of a love-hate affair at the moment with the current state of Vol. 4 and Tales Vol. 2, but what can you do. Post-Eastman & Laird breakup things are a bit topsy-turvy.

Quote:
I don't see the harm in acknowledging the fans who, like it or not, help to keep the ninja turtles alive today.
Can't agree with you there -- if something called "TMNT" with four brothers named Leonardo, Raphael, Michelangelo, and Donatello on screen kicking butt isn't enough for fans of the old cartoon... that they just need another dose of cowabunga, Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady like some kind of recovering alcoholic craving one more drink... I don't know, it just doesn't seem healthy, not when none of that had anything to do with Eastman & Laird's TMNT at its inception.

Quote:
Loosened? how, because they were off the radar?
Exactly! That's what it takes, the extent of which the "TMNT is for Kids" motif has permeated things.

Quote:
I can tell you alot of the buzz surrounding the movie was from fans expecting TMNT to be closer to old cartoon and they were happy because of it, "they have to have Krang!!", "No Bebop or Rocksteady, this movie sucks!!"
There's no accounting for the truly rabid fans of something. I don't think the answer is to cater to them.

Quote:
And the 4Kids cartoon re-established TMNT as a kids property before the movie.
Yeah, pretty much. It did a little bit of damage control on the material vs. the Fred Wolf stuff... but essentially yeah, just, "Oh, look. A new TMNT children's cartoon."

Quote:
Originally Posted by Coola Yagami View Post
Yo Andrew, you kinda forgot all the weird 'what were they smokin' stories Eastman and Laird did.
Like what?

Quote:
All the stories about Nobody, Leatherhead, Rennet, the Passing, the Kirby cyrstal Don Special, Justice Force and such were all extremely weird and wacky, especially yhe Rennet ones. And c'mon... in Return to New York did you ever expect the TMNT to side with a Triceraton to take down the Foot.. and to run into 3 weird-as-all-hell Shredder clones?
Nevertheless, all of the stories you mention were handled in a straight enough manner with real, tangible consequences, TMNT that don't jump into each other's arms and scream in fright, spend and focus time on slapstick, goofball dialogue.

It's all in the "take." Right now, I can write a story about a clown on a space station with a talking cow... but I can write it to drum up the laughs, goof-factor, aim it to toddlers, or I can play it straight, keep it within a serious, Twilight Zone/Outer Limits feel.

I know you can appreciate the difference.

Quote:
I agree that the 13 monsters story was out of left field, and in my opnion didn't really have any business in the movies, but yeah... the turtles in the comics was full of crazy stuff too. We've seen the TMNT in New York as is, maybe in a new movie we should see some Triceraton invasion stuff...
Crazy stuff in the comics isn't the issue. The goof, Looney Tunes crap... yeah, that's the stuff that wasn't there.

Unless you count those rubbish Hedden-McWeeny stuff... but even when it was published it bore no bones about it being Elseworlds.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jo Dawn View Post
I wish the actual TMNT would have a chance to shine. In the right hands, and done in the right way, it would be HUGE. TMNT doesn't have to be silly. It can be a cool movie.
That it can. Of its own right.

Last edited by Andrew NDB; 02-27-2008 at 12:44 AM.
Andrew NDB is online now   Reply With Quote