|
Interesting, the too funny/not funny enough split reaction over TMNT.
My observation: There's quite a lot of attempted humor, but about 85% of it falls flat. So you really only laugh a few times, though they're constantly trying. It is surprisingly dark when compared to the OT, mainly because you have Raph and Leo seriously fight each other. And that family tension, while really the only "dark" thing happening, does pervade the whole tone even while Mike is ridiculous all over the place. That's where the OT fans get that "dour" complaint, I bet. The Turtles aren't mindless cartoons that are ready to group hug at any given moment - they have some problems they're working through and Leo returning isn't going to hunky-dorify everything.
Andrew's earlier assessment of TMNT is one I actually agree with on all points... I think the reason I'm still able to have fun watching it is I shrug off the bits I don't like and immerse myself in the parts I do. But the thing that still kills me every time I watch are those flopped one-liners. A few are chuckle-worthy, but most... blech.
That's what we need for any sequel... if there are gonna be jokes (and even in a Mirage-loyal film there should be a decent amount), they have to be good.
|