Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB
Everything you say in your post is 100% true, but here is just a terrible, terrible example.
Dark Knight Strikes Again #1 was a comic book event, not just some random #1. Even non comic book fans were chomping at the bit to see Frank Miller's sequel to the legendary "Dark Knight Returns" some twenty years before. Of course... a lot of people didn't like what they got...
And 11,501 is a pretty respectable number of copies sold in today's market, if you keep track of things month-by-month over at http://www.cbgxtra.com ... but Vol. 4 and Tales V2 quickly fell far below that as the months passed.
Just for fun, you know how many copies Tales of the TMNT #43 sold? 2,549. That book deserves another 0 behind it, if you ask me.
|
Yeah, going up against dark knight made for a poor example, but thats what was out that month. Again, I must admit, most of my money goes into producing my own stuff, paying my bills, and doing something fun from time to time, so I rarely buy comics (or anything else) anymore. I miss those days of comics costing a buck or so...so I have not read much of the newer stuff. I have no doubt that there has been some really high quality stuff. I need to find the time to view the freebie versions online and catch up on the stories.
For those who don't know this business stuff...it tends to be, on the average month, the top seller is in the 100,000 range. For "MAJOR EVENTS", books can push closer to that 200,000 range. It breaks down something like this:
If you're a nobody, you're praying for 1,000 to get distributed for your first issue, but you can't keep going long if you plan to do a series...If you're at that level, you're going to have a hard time making it to an issue 3 without funding the venture through an alternative source. For a lot of fans who want to put out their own book, making ONE book is a major accomplishment...diamond also won't want to consider soliciting number 1 if they don't expect that you're be doing numbers 2, and 3...you need to show them your stuff, ready to print before getting distribution is even an option!
If you're selling 2500, you're on the fence and can probably keep going so long as you don't NEED to make money in order to publish the book. If you're doing all of the art yourself, and its a labor of love, you're doing ok and can keep going. If you have to pay other people to do work on the book, you're going to run out of money quickly.
5000 and you're doing good and you can keep putting issues out...you're making a couple of bucks. At this point you're paying yourself for the art you created or you can hire a team...hire in the sense that there is some money for people. Its not much, but its something...
10,000 and you're a big success in the indy world. Its sad that a number like that is success, but thats where the industry is at this point. Its like being the smartest highschool drop out...Best selling indy comic today means something in comics, but to the rest of the world, people ask "they still make comic books!?"
getting into marvel and dc, I am not sure on the numbers, but someone told me they want to see at least 15,000 on regular titles they're trying to push...If a title falls below that level, it could be cancelled.
You're going to see the 50,000's, 60'000s 70,000's for your average issues in your major players...your spider-mans, supermans, batman, x-men, etc...
For one reason or another something sells more than everything else and something gets up there to the 100,000 level...some popular title has a good arc that people get hooked on...or there is a special event released.
then you get those major "events" where
everyone who buys comics is buying something...and there we're talking about 150,000-200,000.
Those event numbers may sound big, but in the early 90s x-men number 1 sold 8 million copies (albeit with five different covers) and superman 75 had people lining up...like average joe people...literally forming lines outside of stores before they opened.
When the most you can hope for as an indy person is like 10,000 copies...where that is like "WOW"...its just hard for the little guy to get out there and make something impactful happen today. Factoring the higher costs of doing business leading to higher cover prices, I doubt there has ever been a tougher time than right now to put out comics with new characters.
On the subject of indy stuff, I met the guys at "Big City Comics" who publish "Ant", "Dragon Cross", "Totem", "Tempest"...They're on the level of printing 5000, getting diamond orders for 2500, and sitting on an additional 2500 copies which they sell direct and sell at events/conventions. I was set up behind them at the FX Show in Orlando in January. I guess there have been talks about getting "Ant" picked up for an animated series. There was even a statue made...but still...they're not seeing big money rolling in from the sale of the books. I definitely wish them the best of luck-they've got all of the elements to be successful, but its so tough in today's comic marketplace. If they can continue to just keep the books going out, they still build a library of stories that can be turned into something bigger down the road. Hopefully they can see bigger sales on a monthly basis, but man...its a fight I am not brave enough to fight.
11,501 is definitely respectable and if
I were putting out a book, I would love to see numbers like that, but you'd think
turtles could do significantly higher numbers with their comeback issue in 2001. Thats not me being negative...I really expected to find higher numbers there. With them dipping into that 2500 ballpark as things continued on, its just tough to stay afloat if thats you're only revenue stream...of course for mirage it isn't relying on comic sales to pay the bills at this point, but there is only so much time that can be devoted to a project that isn't making money. For every hour an artist works on a comic that makes no money, its an hour he can't be working on dvds, cartoons, animation models, etc.
I am hoping the new distribution model they're going to try will yeild greater profits. Ironicly, giving away the issues for free and selling even 200 of the 1,000 books they've printed at $10 a pop may yeild a better return than selling 2500 through diamond. I didn't sit down to do the math, but I hope it all works out for everyone. While people can joke about Laird having piles of money, the comics themselves are not where that money is coming from at this point. I think its awesome that new stories are getting put out there. I know people could be critical and think there are better stories to be told, but that is proof of how successful the turtles have become. Everyone has a different idea as to what direction the stories should take. Once people fight over the stuff, and have strong opinions, you know they care. I'd rather have people rabidly hating what I was doing as a creator rather than being indifferent to it

.
Ok, thats it for me...no more posting in the thread for me...