View Single Post
Old 06-15-2008, 09:32 PM   #7
Dragon Turtle
Stone Warrior
 
Dragon Turtle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Standing behind you.
Posts: 776
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
Well, think of it like this.

Tier 5) These are your Steven Spielburghs, George Lucases, Peter Jacksons. These guys can basically make whatever movies they want, however they want with **** all outside interference.

Tier 4) These are your established directors that might not have tons and tons of movies under their belt but enough that they have a proven record with Hollywood. These are your Christopher Nolans, your Sam Raimis, your Del Toros, etc.. They don't have unlimited pull in Hollywood, but enough to more or less still make the movie they want with only a minimal amount of concessions.

Tier 3) These are your worksman-class directors, your Brett Ratners, your Len Wisemans, your Paul W.S. Andersons... they have a bit of pull in Hollywood, enough to kind of get their vision on the screen, but still they are more or less there to do the studio's film in the studio's way.

Tier 2) These are your new directors. Maybe they put out a low-budget independant film at Cannes that only 20 people have ever seen, maybe they've done a couple. They may be on the rise, or you might never see them again. If they get a big break in Hollywood, they'll be given a very short leash by the studio/financiers until they get established.

Tier 1) Non-directors. These are people who have never directed a film before. Maybe they have dabbled in video games or music videos, but nothing more. They're looking for their big break in feature films for big studios and even if they get it, they are going to have 0 pull until they can put out some moneymakers.


Yes, TMNT Part 4 went with a Tier 1 director. TMNT needs somewhere between a Tier 3 and a Tier 4 director... I think it can get it. But it needs to be a director established as such that either is already a TMNT fan or is fascinated by (and respects) the material, that picks it up as a pet project/labor of love.

As far as directors go, I think we should be prepared to settle for (going by your criteria) a 1 - 3 tier director. Especially if the movie franchise remains in full animation, Kevin Monroes' selection was pretty typical of animation directors, someone who has worked in the industry for a long time and knows the inner workings of producing animated features, I don't know alot of tier 4 directors working in animation, maybe a Brad Bird. Live action directors just don't direct animated movies, at best they may be "Executive producers", such as John Woo, George Lucas, and Steven Spielberg.

Tier 2 and 3 directors aren't bad, really even guys like Nolan and Del Toro were not far removed from tier 2 directors when they directed movies like Batman Begins and Blade 2.

But ultimately it will be the studio's decision as to what direction the next TMNT movie will take, if they want a PG kid friendly movie, then they will make sure that they're on the same page with any director/producer before any contracts are signed.



Quote:
Originally Posted by Warhorse View Post
I thought that the star wars had very good CGI/Live action interraction. And to be honest, that wont be the last thing people will remember. Narnia, The Golden Compass, the infamous LOTR, Transformers, all had excellent CGI and human interractions. You people keep confusing the Turtles with the likes of Garfield. The Turtles will look awesome because it's not going to be a complete comedy, but action filled with some slap stick humor. It'll be easier for CGI and human interraction to flow with that kind of a flick as opposed to some comedy.
Putting aside the budgets of the aforementioned movies, it is much easier to compare TMNT with Garfield because unlike Transformers, there would have to be more close up interaction between the turtles and the real world, that includes fighting, either in hand-to-hand or weapon combat, interacting with their environments, or just more quiet face-to-face conversations, thats much different then "interacting" with giant robots or dragons. I have a feeling that the action in a hybrid TMNT movie will mostly be made up of pratfalls and slap schtick.


Quote:
Originally Posted by ToTheNines View Post
That's what I'm getting at, chances are there ain't any TMNT fans among directors.
Kevin Smith? Let's not be to quick to sell the turtles short, I'm pretty sure there are turtle fans out there in director land, or at least directors fascinated enough by the concept to take the job of directing a TMNT movie. Jon Favreau admits he wasn't a huge Ironman fan, and I doubt Del Toro was the world's biggest Blade fan.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jester View Post
Uh...wasn't Steve Barron, the director who brought us the first live action TMNT film a Tier 1 director?
He sure was. I don't believe Andrew is insisting that tier 1 directors are bad, just that they don't have much influnece.
Dragon Turtle is offline   Reply With Quote