View Single Post
Old 08-12-2008, 06:12 AM   #2
Andrew NDB
Weed Whacker
 
Andrew NDB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Auburn, WA
Posts: 34,636
Quote:
Originally Posted by Goongasnootch View Post
Well, Volume 3 was a whole lot of, "Oh my fscking God! How could they do that to [so-and-so]?! This is so not cool," for me. However, something about it kept bringing me back whenever I could get ahold of an issue. Something deeper than instinct told me that Vol. 3 was worth continuing to read because everything was gonna turn out okay if I just stuck with it.

As far as I know nowadays, the Image team was going to get around to fixing up everything that had been done and resolve all the fun plot points while they were at it and it would've been great to read. Too bad Vol. 3 has basically been retconned in favor of the Turtles sitting around and doing nothing \in the rarely-updated Vol. 4.
I remember writing the same thing about Vol. 2 in the Vol. 3 lettercols.

It's funny, I remember just a few years ago I wrote Peter Laird a letter that was published... around #20 or so in Vol. 4. I expressed my background as a fan, that I'd followed TMNT since I was a wee lad, even once sleeping in TMNT cartoon bedsheets. Then even that as an adult I'd found out my "friend" quietly sold off all the TMNT comics I'd collected stored in his garage so that he could buy weed (all right, so I left off that last part).

I then explained the reasons, to Laird, why it was crazy to me for him to write off Volume 3. That Volume 3 at Image was widely announced by Mirage and ninjaturtles.com to fans to be a continuation of the Mirage books, that Gary Carlson made it a point to honor all the continuity that came before it (even bringing back Klunk, for goodness sake), taking the baton that Mirage passed to him/them and ran with it... and that it was a big slap in the face for Mirage to suddenly turn around and say that none of Volume 3 happened when all those folks involved had done Mirage (and the fans) a huge favor. I even listed the things that stood in potential conflict with Volume 4 and how easily they could be explained away.

Peter Laird answered me in the lettercol, acknowledging that it would be quite easy to accept Volume 3 into canon. He said plainly, though, that to do so just wouldn't "Feel right" to him.

You know what, though? That was good enough for me. It took a while for that to really settle with me, but it did.

For the larger part of Vol. 3's lattermost run when it was losing money it was mostly being quietly funded by Laird. Even barring that, it was always spoken that Image/Highbrow/Erik Larsen/Carlson were only taking up the duties until such a time if/when Mirage would resume things.

Though I admit I'm a tiny bit still torn. I do recall reading that Peter Laird was at least peripherally involved in the co-plotting of Vol. 3, and certainly involved in the approval process of each and every story (and he even is quoted in the TMNT Vol. 3 TPB loudly applauding those comics)... if I had to twist an old nit, I really would wish if there'd been any thought in the back of anyone's head about "If/when we take back over the TMNT comics, this won't/shouldn't be in canon" that those thoughts had been communicated to the folks involved in Vol. 3 before each issue had been approved so that they had been more in line with the overal canonical vision.

"Working with Gary Carlson from the 'approvals' end of things, here at Mirage Studios, I've had the pleasure of watching the book develop from a slightly tentative start to the exciting, innovative comic it is today. This new iteration of the TMNT has heart, soul... and balls." - Peter Laird, TMNT Vol. 3 TPB
Andrew NDB is offline   Reply With Quote