View Single Post
Old 10-13-2008, 03:21 PM   #2
Cipher
Foot Elite
 
Cipher's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 3,454
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tomoshibi Amatsu View Post
Plain and simple. If Mikey is written so horribly then he should be a forgettable character, which I guess is hard since he's a main character, but all I'm saying is that you wouldn't really remember much of Mikey in this incarnation if he was written horribly. Yet NT Mikey is rememberable. In that sense he's not written horribly.
I also remember the Ancient One, simply because he's a terrible stock character that I wish wasn't in the show. I remember the main character from the 1998 American Godzilla movie because all of it was so laughably bad. Remembering or expressing dissatisfaction with a character does not mean they are well written. That you think so is just...mind boggling.

Quote:
In that sense NT Mikey is also written well especially because he can invoke the emotions of the audience. A badly written Mikey wouldn't be able to do that. He'd be so bland and boring that people would just forget him and never care enough to bitch about how much of a douche Mikey's gotten.
A well written character evokes the emotions that they're supposed to evoke. If a character is funny and well written, the audience will laugh. If a character is sympathetic and well written, the audience will feel for them. If a character is mean and well written, the audience will hate them (and maybe enjoy them.)

As things would have it, new toon Mikey is supposed to be funny, but most of the audience hates him. That's wrong. That's bad writing. (The word "audience" here refers to the adults who the show isn't aimed at, but who started this discussion anyway.)

Quote:
So yeah you may think he's badly written just because he's lost some of the things his mirage counterpart possesses.
I miss two aspects of his Mirage counterpart: layers and likability. Those can be done in anyway. He could be a mutant firefighter astronaut jokester, and as long as he showed depth and wasn't a douchebag, I'd like him.

Quote:
I don't have to prove anything. I just like Mikey. Douche or not he's still one of my favorite turtles and I just wanted to defend him. That's all. I'm not here to make enemies or anything.
That's totally fine. Other people just want to defent their dislike of this version, or their hope that he could be written differently. If anyone's actually getting angry over this discussion, I think I might just have to cry myself to sleep.
Cipher is offline   Reply With Quote