|
Personally I'd go with TMNT: City at War.
It would be a sequel to the previous films, but it would stand on it's own. Build of Karai's hint of the Shredder coming back and combine (in some way) the comic story lines of RTNY and CAW.
There would be no need to reference Winters or the monsters from TMNT, just like TMNT didn't need to reference Super Shredder or their adventures in time, or even the first movie really.
Even with the return of Shredder you wouldn't need to mention Super Shredder. The intro to TMNT said after fighting many battles the TMNT finally beat Shredder - both the original and SOTO were right at the start of their adventures, so Shredder must have come back after that before being killed (as mentioned in TMNT).
Personally I thought TMNT did a good job of rebooting the films - continuing on from the originals (with nice nods to them in the trophy room), not contradicting them, but at the same time moving on (you didn't need to watch them to understand TMNT) and not repeating them. Compare that to Superman Returns which was also a "loose sequel" which made a had confusing continuity with previous films, didn't really move on and was an obvious rip-off of the original's plot.
I felt what TMNT really lacked was a strong villain, but it did a great job at re-establishing the family relationship between the turtles and re-establishing the core cast (Splinter, April, Casey) whilst introducing new secondary characters like Karai. This could easily be built on in a sequel.
That said, why my preference is for a sequel I would have nothing against a reboot.
I suppose it all comes down to timing. The current animated series is said to be ending this season with a DTV movie next year for the 25th Anniversary. The new movie (sequel or reboot) is said to be targetted for late 2010/early 2011 (live action or combined live/CGI). The movie could be just what the franchise needs to get it up and running again (new TV show, maybe a new comic etc). But if the movie fails then I guess that would be it for a while for the TMNT until the next revival comes around.
The main question then is are we better with a reboot which could give a fresh start to the film franchise and also potentially a new TV series. Or are we better with a sequel which could be viewed as the "end" of the current films whilst leaving the door open for future sequels (and could also spin into a new TV series) and would also be a good end for the current revival if takings don't warrant a sequel. Both if successful could potentially lead to a new stand-alone TV series and future films.
Personally I think the timing is better for a sequel, purely because (and I do feel sad saying this) it does look like we're coming towards the end of the current life cycle in the franchise - the new show is, potentially, in it's last season, the toy sales are down, Vol. 4 will be ending (at some point whenever those last 6 issues come...). I would hate for a reboot to come now and be a commercial disappointment as it would likely be longer before they could reboot it again.
A successful movie (reboot or sequel) has the potential to revive the franchise - bring in higher toys sales, possibley revive the current cartoon or generate a new one. But I feel there's less risk in doing a sequel at the end of the life cycle than a reboot. It leaves the door open for a full franchise reboot in the near future if the sequel doesn't do a well as hoped, but if a reboot fails then there would be even less hope of that.
That said I'm not holding my breath for PG-13 (though I really do want to see Leo take the human Shredder's head off on screen!). Whilst the comics have always been aimed at an older audience, the franchise is most famous for the original cartoon and currently popular with kids through the new cartoon. The movies are always going to be aimed at the largest audience possible and with kids a large part of that audience they're not going to do anything that could limit their ability to see the film. Whilst adult fans would love to see this, we don't make up a large enough part of the market for it to be a realistic possibility. The best we could probably hope for would be something like DTV CGI comic adaptations/original movies (as was proposed as part of the 25th Anniversary but never happened) but even then I'd bet they'd be toned down enough that kids could buy them as well.
|