View Single Post
Old 12-11-2008, 01:04 PM   #18
DrSpengler
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 4,842
I felt the streak of quality began to noticeably diminish after season 4 (or more specifically, "Good Genes part 2"). Starting with the Ninja Tribunal arc, the show began to get gimmicky for season-long stretches at a time, when before, gimmicks were employed for maybe an episode at a time. While I don't hate season 5 (I enjoyed much of it, in fact), I could feel a distinct change in atmosphere, direction and overall tone which would only continue to disintegrate.

Fast Forward was some distracting fun that went on for too long and felt unfocused. Ignoring the change in setting, it just didn't have the edge the first 4 seasons had (which I hold in regard as being genuinely GOOD animation, both in story and production).

Back to the Sewers ost my interest after about 4 episodes, focusing far too much on Mikey's juvenile humor (the previous seasons were guilty of this, but never to the extent BttS took it) and some moronic story arcs (collecting Splinter's "bits"). I didn't stick around long enough to see if the payoff with the Shredder War was worth it. I'll just wait for the DVD set.

Anyhow, that's my personal weigh-in on the matter. I think the first 4 seasons make for some of the best animation of the decade (saying this not as a TMNT fan, but from a critical perspective) and proof that America still has the chops to stay in the television animation game (contrary to what most Japanophiles may think). Seasons 5-7 are a sudden drop in quality, while not in the "terrible" department (at least, not immediately), they don't live up to the first 4.
DrSpengler is offline