View Single Post
Old 02-15-2009, 04:35 PM   #4
The Big Bad
Stone Warrior
 
The Big Bad's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 653
Quote:
Originally Posted by oldmanwinters View Post
I would have preferred if Saki had been portrayed as a deeper character, who operated by his own twisted ethical code, ala Lex Luthor.
We did get some hints of humanity from him--his adoption of Karai, and to a lesser extent, the way to took Hun in as an understudy. While there was a selfish undercurrent to both--he wanted to obtain loyal underlings--the fact that he gave them better lives, that neither turned into the psychopath he is, and that both look at that period with some fondness says good things about how he raised them. However, these things were kept waaay under the surface, which I think worked for the best for this series.

To elaborate: both Lex Luthor and David Xanatos work, in part, because their counterparts are unquestionably noble. The turtles, as shown through the whole series, are not. They technically have no problem with the Foot--their emnity with the organization stems from bad blood, not philosophical difference. Had the Shredder been less evil, then the turtles lose what moral high ground they have--there's no real reason to root for them.

What's more, I feel a more nuanced Shredder would have overshadowed other villains. Hun works, in part, because while he's amoral, he's not a psycho--were the difference between himself and the Shredder less defined, he would feel as The Shredder Lite. Likewise Karai, whose more noble aspects stand out precisely because the Shredder is an evil [expletive].

TMNT is not lacking in villains with twisted ethical codes. The Shredder did not need to be one of them.

As to the broader question, I think the series has my favorite rogues gallery in cartoons, particularly once the creators figured out what worked and what didn't. The sheer number alone is incredible, and barring the Shredder, I don't think any overstayed its welcome, which is incredibly rare in long-running cartoons. What's more, the fact that about half of them are original--as opposed to most animated adaptations of comic books, where the ratio is skewed much more severely in favor of source material characters--and they still work just as well as the adapted ones is amazing.
The Big Bad is offline   Reply With Quote