View Single Post
Old 05-30-2009, 12:27 AM   #43
TristanHuwJones
Official TMNT Staff/Cast
 
TristanHuwJones's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 1,419
[QUOTE=Andrew NDB;695597]

Quote:
And I'm by no means saying Tristan is the first one to do something like this, or will even be the last. I just find it's a little bit lacking in creativity and when you dig deep, actually just seems pretty self-gratifying and the equivalent of rubbing oneself off in public.
As far as character creation, yeah it is kind of an easy out, but if you take the characters and do good things with them, like Harley and X23, I have no beef and the creative bankruptcy argument is kinda moot. Ultimately you're telling a story. Any goonbag can come up with a character (Robert Liefeld) but the character isn't **** without a decent writer behind it (Fabien Nicieza).

Quote:
That's not really consistant with the lion's share of the posts I've seen from you about the show.
I think my intentions may be being misinterpreted here. Most of my praises come from the fact that we have them. There was a considerable amount of unwarranted disdain being geared at the show as it went on, then there was this retroactive love for it when Fast Forward came around. It's like how people enjoy Fast Forward now that BTTS is what we have. Overall, it wasn't a bad show. But by season 3, I was completely bored by it.

I will say that I did have fun watching Fast Forward though. I was disappointed by the Lost Season, but thought there were good ideas. Really didn't like the Triceraton invasion, or many of the Triceraton related episodes to be honest... and I love Triceratons! The first couple of seasons always started out well, but then dropped substantially as the seasons went on.
Quote:
Particularly your clamoring that so many of the 4Kids episodes are so close to their namesake comics is eyebrow-raising indeed.
Just because they're close to the comics tonally doesn't mean I'm still a raving fan of the show. I get my kicks from the comics when it comes to turtles. Comics and the first movie. That doesn't mean I can't say that there are aspects of a show that people seem to selectively overlook when jumping on it for others. I didn't particularly enjoy The Batman, but that doesn't mean I can't sing the praises of what I thought was good about it.


Quote:
And I'm willing to grin and bear it as a one-off thing... if things are to become "Tales of Tristan's Refurbished Cartoon Villains™" in a continuing manner, though, that's really not a thing I want any part of.
You want to see what's coming up, click my blog link and have a back-read.

Quote:
Not accusing here. I'm only wary of where you want to go from here, since you seem to be championing this movement toward revisiting cartoon villains so much lately.
My "agenda" REVOLVES, absolutely REVOLVES around the Shredder. Not Oroku Saki, but the mantle of the Shredder. The person you need to keep an eye on is Lin. This isn't just directed at you Andrew, it's towards everyone, but people need to look between the lines. Why would Lin spring Hun from jail? She's part of a group dedicated to the Shredder. The man who Hun hates more than anyone. Hun is possibly more anti-Foot Clan than the Turtles and Splinter. And that's a big clue as how he fits in. The direction of things is pretty obvious when you read #36 and #56 back to back, and it's gonna be made amazingly clear come the last page of #64. There are some little things written into the linking stories that are very specific. The appearance of the Foot in #59 is something to pay attention to as well.



Don't read Spider-Man so I can't really comment on this on one side of the fence or another.

Quote:
If you want a good example of self-indulgance hurting a project, though, you have to look no further than Frank Miller's "The Dark Knigth Strikes Again" or even "All-Star Batman."
I'm on the other side of the fence with All-Star. I knew it'd be self indulgent ********, because Miller said it would be from the start. We already have Dick's origin, this is just another no holds barred romp. I will agree with DKR though.

Quote:
Or pretty much anything Judd Winnick has ever written in comics.
BOO! The only thing he did wrong with Batman was how he brought Jason Todd back to life. Superboy Prime?!


Quote:
Hm. Could you elaborate on this? Because I really am at a loss for how creating a new character is self-indulgant.
It's your character!! King Cobra's appearance in #64, Lauren Stanton in #59 and Razorback coming back in #61 were ridiculously fun to write to the point I would consider it self-indulgent. If people enjoy it, then that's cool too, but I had an insane amount of fun with those specific pieces.
Quote:
If Hun was already a Mirage character using him wouldn't be self-indulgant.
How so? Isn't any character choice by a writer an act of self indulgence?
Quote:
The fact is, he didn't exist in it until you shoe-horned him (nicely, I'll admit, nicely).
Thanks dude, I get what you're saying though.

Quote:
We don't know what the heck is up with that yet.
Exactly my point here.

Quote:
It's not actually paranoia if they're really out to get you... or in this case, you pretty much publically declaring intent to put on a hat, grab a pickaxe, and dive into the children's cartoons for "new" villains for Mirage
.

Except that we know this isn't what's happening.

Quote:
Coupled with an already waning interest in the direction of things in Tales and out (outside of things like your and Dan's issues)... it could well be the straw that broke the camel's back.
Yeah, but Dan and I both said this... the problem with Tales is the format more so than the stories.

Quote:
To be honest, I hate both origins and picking one would be like picking which obese chick I want to bone. I liked the "origin" as it was pretty much dsecribed in the Palladium material.
I don't hate the 2k3 one (though I REALLY, really don't like the comic one and am constantly baffled by it), as it's something more in line with the way I'd imagined him coming to being. What was the Palladium one?

Quote:
So no children's spinoff stuff beyond Hun? Then I have no quarrel.
I do have a couple of girls who I want to use the Touch and Go alias for, but that's as far as it goes. Purely because it just works WAY too well for them

Quote:
It'd be like... if Rocksteady appeared in the comics tomorrow, and actually started shooting and killing people with his machine gun. Maybe that doesn't qualify as a "complete overhaul," but I'd certainly call that a pretty fundamental change in the character -- so why not just make a new mutant that wields a machine gun?
What if said character was only to appear once, and once only? People would accuse it of being a rip-off of Rocksteady and it'd just be a throwaway, which is what so many people complain about with Tales. You could at least give that story some resonance by making it a one off with a character people will get excited about and leave it at that, kinda like the FCBD/Anniversary year One-Shot I pitched.

[QUOTE=Cipher;695575]I think the importing of characters depends entirely on the situation.

If a writer sits down and says, "Let's see what I can do with Bebop," yeah, that's a bit brankrupt. It's just tweaking someone else's character to make them fit their own story. Why?

I think what you mean to say is it's just that thing of trying to come up with a story to suit a character. I didn't say "I want to use Hun, better come up with a story to suit him". If I had've, then yeah, that'd be a problem. Same with the Bebop and Rocksteady story. I actually had a pitch ready where the Foot use arcane lore to open a dimensional rift, and this monster manages to come through by accident. We were joking around after NYCC about the old toon characters and we came to the realisation that Bebop and Rocksteady would work in that story in place of the monster and would make for a great One-shot FCBD/Anniversary story to help attract more fans towards the comics. My story wouldn't've been affected in any way whatsoever, outside of this random one-off monster suddenly becoming two iconic characters for a special once off appearance.


Quote:
But if a writer keeps doing that (retooling cartoon characters) to fit their stories over and over again (in the name of, "Well, I needed a Bishop/Nano/fill-in-the-blank-like villain in this story, so I just went ahead and used Bishop/Nano/fill-in-the-blank villain)... it kind of becomes a sham and we can call the writer out on it, can't we?
Yep. But then again, isn't that what virtually the entire Marvel Ultimate line is? And that's far from a sham.

Quote:
Again, not pointing a finger at Tristan. It doesn't sound like I have much to worry about.
You have nothing to worry about. It just woulda helped me out if you had a look at my blog beforehand
__________________
Still alive (somehow)...
tristansbones.bsky.social
and instagram @ instagram.com/tristans_bones
TristanHuwJones is offline   Reply With Quote