View Single Post
Old 06-04-2009, 11:11 PM   #26
The Big Bad
Stone Warrior
 
The Big Bad's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 653
Quote:
Originally Posted by Newton Gimmick View Post
Uh, there's no real need for a total reinvention. It's pretty simple. Rocksteady and Bebop instead of being "goofy"... Kill people. Pretty cut and dry actually.

Both characters were threats in the first couple episodes, but soon degenerated into jokes. Still, the basic characters, street thugs turned into mutants, is quite viable. With little change to the overall character. Because as you said, there was a lot room for development there because we never got a ton of character background information.
I disagree: I think Bebop and Rocksteady's stupidity and incompetence is an integral part of their appeal; taking it away would render the new characters to be not quite Bebop and Rocksteady--it'd be like making Team Rocket or Dr. Light competent.

Also, we seem to have a fundamental disagreement on the meaning of the word "threat"--I really don't think "lasting more than thirty seconds" is enough for a villain to qualify. Also, given that their first scene as humans features them getting beat up by the turtles with no trouble, I think the argument that incompetence was something thrust upon them falls on its face.


Quote:
I'm not sure what that has to do with anything. Maybe your point went over my head.

Either way, while I don't think the Turtles' arc is the worst part of the story, it is much, much stronger with April, Casey and Splinter's arcs. I think that's one of the many reasons the 4Kids adaptation is kind of a snoozer.
Actually, it was meant to be more than aside than an actual argument, but the point was that much like emotion is often not the 2003 cartoon's strengh, action is oftentimes not Mirage's--take away the four other stories, and you're left with a story that's not all that much better than its TV adaptation. But while we're on the topic, I don't really think adapting the other four storylines to the cartoon would have helped any; those stories aren't the type the cartoon was equipped to tell, and given the place were the characters were at the time, trying to adapt them would have dangerously derailed the cartoon. What the 'toon version of "City at War" needed was better action, better pacing, and the sense that people could actually die. Had the arc been animated like something like the Spectacular Spider-Man episode accomplices, and had the minor-but-established characters actually died on screen--I'm imagining a battle scene not unlike "Same as it Never Was", here--I think the whole arc would have been considerably more succesful.
The Big Bad is offline   Reply With Quote