The Shredder is actually better utilized as the Mirage comics portray him. Since the theme (of Volume 1 at least) is all about vengeance, having Shredder's death be a single incident that creates a spiral of violence is much more poignant. The Turtles feel not only the Shredder's continued presence, but the continued repercussions of their own actions. And it all culminates beautifully in "City at War." That could've been the end to all TMNT, and it would've been perfect.
And after that, there hasn't been much mention of Shredder, save for the seperate character, Oroku Yoshi. And that's how it should be. That chapter of their lives has been told, that story put to its thematic end.
That said, if there was ever a way to bring back the Shredder and still have it add something to the story, Raph picking up the mantle was the way to do it. That was a
great choice on the part of Image.
Quote:
|
The New Toon gave him arcs, but always with heavy non-Shredder-related stretches in-between. Then they did away with him in season 3, leaving his legacy to fill his boots via Karai, the Demon Shredder and Cyber Shredder for 4 seasons.
|
I might be more inclined to believe you if the Shredder arcs weren't always the main events. And even after they got rid of him, they still had to have a new villain fill the role. Constantly. I'm all for new Shredders, but holy sh*t. And Shredder was the sole threat in seasons five and seven (probably why they felt so dull). The new toon was Shredder city.