View Single Post
Old 07-21-2009, 01:47 AM   #11
Dragon Turtle
Stone Warrior
 
Dragon Turtle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Standing behind you.
Posts: 776
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
Other than it being a very cyclical example of a limited nature... they come out with a new incarnation every generation or so, and folks outgrow it within a few years... reboot, rinse, and repeat.
If it works, no real reason to stop.


Quote:
Why not come up with a new take on TMNT in the mass media that isn't quite as arbitrarily outgrowable? It seems in everyone's best interests... fiscal and otherwise.
A forward thinking company would be able to do both.


Quote:
There's no reason fully "mature" TMNT stories can't be told in PG-13 fashion. And if you believe that a successful movie must be "for" any fandom -- yes, even the Mirage fandom -- then you're not seeing the bigger picture.

The gangbuster TMNT movie we all know in our hearts there can be needs to reach well out beyond any existing fandom. Any fandom showing up for opening weekend would only be the icing on the cake, not the cake itself. In fact, if you were populate the seats with all the still-active fans of the Mirage, original cartoon, and newer cartoon... you still wouldn't arrive at box office numbers that would even be satisfactory, let alone a box office smash.
Yes, I agree.

Quote:
Which isn't relevant on the basis that none of these folks would even be within the target demographic of a PG-13 action movie... and on what I elaborated a bit on above.
It's relevant to idea that 2k7 movie embraces the stereotypes and cliches of the old cartoon. And who is the target demographic for a PG-13 action movie, the 20-30 somethings who grew up with the old toon and the people who don't have any real ties to the fandom but will still possibly go see a movie featuring the TMNT, seem to be a couple of the target audiences that you may want to go after.

Quote:
I won't argue with any of this. But it doesn't mean I or anyone else have to bite down and accept it as, "Well, at least it was as best as we can expect, given the old cartoons and all that."
No, there is no reason that you or anyone has to accept something that is not to their liking, if people don't like the movie because it's not enough like the Mirage comics or enough like the OT, that's perfectly fine. But for a movie designed specifically as a kids movie, the 2k7 movie along with the 2k3 cartoon, makes the idea of doing a really serious TMNT movie not be viewed as a complete joke to the masses.
Dragon Turtle is offline   Reply With Quote