View Single Post
Old 09-09-2009, 11:38 PM   #239
Dragon Turtle
Stone Warrior
 
Dragon Turtle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Standing behind you.
Posts: 776
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stryker View Post
A well written PG movie would allow the franchise to grow.

Hell, a well written movie PERIOD would be a step in the right direction. Enough with the rating bullsh*t. A movie can be good regardless of the damn rating.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Katie View Post
2) As unpopular as it may be to some on this forum, you have to appeal to children. if you never bring in new young fans the franchise eventually dies. Plus you have to think business on this. Kids have a TON of disposable income. They will buy most of the merchandise and they represent the biggest portion of the dollar signs the execs see. Also, think of this from the perspective of an adult who was a fan of the 80's toon as a child. (we all know that this is by far the most well known incarnation of the TMNT, and no, I am not a fan of the old toon at all.) These people are parents now and if their kids want to see the movie they will be thinking of that. any of those folks who went to the 2007 movie were very surprised and probably disappointed. They will not go to the new movie because of this. If I had kids, I would not want them to see anything like the 2007 movie was. they will watch the old toon.

3) here is nothing wrong with PG. as I said above, you MUST appeal to younger audiences to make this franchise live. It can be done in a way that we will appreciate as adults. (subtle humor, etc.) but you MUST appeal to the kids. PG will achieve a wider audience. Violence =/= greatness in a movie.

I do not understand the anti PG-13 sentiment that some people seem to have, I have no idea what people assume a PG-13 TMNT movie will include but it will not include graphic depictions of violence as Mirage will not allow such a thing, as it would hurt the biggest money producing side of TMNT, TMNT as a kid franchise.

A PG-13 rating puts it on the same level as any other "kid-friendly" comic book/martial arts/action movies currently out there. Not many people I know will say that movies such as "Spider-man", "Iron-Man", or any non "Rush Hour" Jackie Chan movie is inappropriate and/or will not appeal to kids. Even movies such as the "Dark Knight", "Transformers", and "Star Wars" all saw significant kid attendance backed by a truckload kid friendly merchandise and tie-ins.


When you are dealing with a more realistic setting, with the type of weapons the TMNT use, and the past kid friendly movie track record, you need a PG-13 rating just to get back at the level of the 1990 movie (which I guarantee you would be PG-13 if released today).

Whether a movie is rated G,PG,PG-13, or R, has nothing to do with the quality of the writing of the movie, for all its faults, TMNT 2007 looks like "Citizen Kane" when compared to some of the recent big budget PG-13 summer popcorn movies, so the wanting of a PG-13 movie is not an indictment against the quality of PG or the other movie rating.

And as awful as movies such as Transformers were, no one can deny the overall impact those movies had on the franchise, such movies went beyond their fan base. You need to bring in people who aren't fans of the TMNT franchise, but wouldn't object to actually going to see a movie based on the TMNT. You will not succeed just by going after any single faction of the TMNT franchise, not the OT, NT, or comics. And whether anyone likes it or not, the best way to get people, who are not TMNT fans in general, to spend their money and time watching a TMNT movie, is with the promise of actually going to the movie theater and seeing something thats going to wow them, and the weak action of the 2007 movie (which is about as good as it's going to get for a PG TMNT movie), is not it.
Dragon Turtle is offline   Reply With Quote