View Single Post
Old 10-29-2009, 12:29 AM   #9
moonlai
Random Punk
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 34
I agree that, in many ways, comic book characters are caricatures, but it is in this way that they critique people, not just society. I think the watchmen is a great example of how superheroes can be over-emphasized in a way that accentuates the study of real people. While the watchmen was the first to do it explicitly, I think most superheroes, but particularly batman, have for much of their history done so.
I also will concede that it is true that, when batman was first conceived, he was fairly one dimensional, and it is true that the depth of the character did at one point depend on the depth of the writer, but the character has since, due to these writers, evolved. Batman is no longer the one dimensional character he had been created.
However, I don't believe the depth and evolution of batman is strictly created by the writers. Batman has inherent qualities that predisposed him to becoming such a philosophical, psychological, sociological and even politically oriented character. Look at Batman: Year One. The reason why it became so successful, and why no subsequent "Year One" DC book has had such a profound effect on its source than batman year one, is because it showed exactly what batman could be.
moonlai is offline   Reply With Quote