Here are some screencaps of the many colors of mutagen throughout the seasons in the OT. There isn't caps froms seasons 6 and 8-10 since I don't recall seeing mutagen in those seasons.
Season 1 episode “Turtle Tracks”
Season 1 episode “Enter the Shredder”
Season 2 episode “Invasion of the Punk Frogs”
Season 3 episode “Mutagen Monster”
Season 3 episode “Leatherhead, Terror of the Swamp”
Season 3 episode “Michelangelo’s Birthday”
Season 4 episode “Slash, Evil Turtle From Dimension X”
Season 4 episode “Were-Rats From Channel 6”