View Single Post
Old 02-22-2010, 09:35 PM   #3
DrSpengler
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 4,842
I'm going to save my complete thoughts for an article I plan on writing once the entire series is finished. But for the sake of conversation...

As already mentioned, "hit and miss" sums it up pretty concisely.

The series wasn't everything it could have been. Though an anthology title, it could have boasted more multi-issue plot threads. I find that the ones we got were some of the best stories the series produced, such as the Worms of Madness/Loops arc and the Gang Wars arc. Several ongoing threads were begun but never completed, often being dropped because of "editorial changes", whatever *that* meant. As a reader, there's nothing more frustrating than seeing a storyline begun and then unceremoniously ignored as if it never happened. 70 issues and they couldn't find the time to complete those threads? Unacceptable.

When the series was good, though, it produced many of the best TMNT stories ever written; instant classics. The rotating cast of Mirage staffers was a treat, even digging up some great non-Mirage TMNT talent like Chris Allan. Sure, not all the Mirage staffers got to do full issues, but those that did were a nostalgic treat and those that could only provide covers and frontispieces, their contributions were appreciated. Jim Lawso was utilized FAR too much, though, and I think his rather unappealing style (at least so far as mainstream readers are concerned) partially resulted in the poor sales number (likewise goes for Volume 4). But he seems to be joined to Peter Laird at the hip, so there was nothing that could be done about that.

Mirage staffers aside, I think the MOST ADMIRABLE thing about Tales Volume 2, and something I eternally respect Mirage and Laird for, is that it gave opportunities for lots of budding writers and artists to contribute to the series and get their feet wet in the professional comics medium. Lots of talented, unknown folks got to have their big break on Tales of the TMNT and the Mirage crew encouraged their participation. Having "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" on your resume has got to be pretty impressive and a great way to get your foot in the industry's door. The fact that Mirage facilitated something like that is really, truly a beautiful thing and I will always respect them for it.

Almost all the spin-off minis were let-downs in my opinion, for varying reasons on each title (to say nothing of Lawson's art). Most of them carried on the most inane plot threads from the least important one-shots, where-as more important and mre interesting threads were left to wallow in incompletion. The only one that really seemed necessary to me was "The Third Kind", which is probably the only story we needed to take place in the Volume 4 six month gap.


I could go on and on, and I WILL when #70 has come and gone and I write my full article, but these are just the bullet points. The series was a rollercoaster ride of excruciating lows and phenominal highs. Somehow, it both lived up to its potential and fell short of it miserably at the same time.

More so than any other TMNT title (well, with the exception of Volume 1), it's a series best left cherry-picked for content, but when it was good, it was REALLY good.
DrSpengler is offline   Reply With Quote