Thread: TMNT v2
View Single Post
Old 07-24-2010, 06:01 PM   #4
Cipher
Foot Elite
 
Cipher's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 3,454
Up until about issue #4, the series is great. The character moments are just as beautifully written by Lawson as they were in "City at War." Mike's conversation with Leo in #3 especially stands out.

"It's like everything we've ever known. It's over."
"No. Everything's just ... different now."

And then you have those scattered little existential moments like Donatello picking up the religious pamphlet. Looked like it was shaping up to be a pretty intelligent book. Good stuff.

I'm also a huge fan of the art, the colors particularly, in the early issues. It's got a serious indie-'90s vibe going on and I love every bit of it. There are some gorgeous panels of Baxter walking underwater. Although, DrSpengler's right, the art deteriorates as the series goes on and Lawson hits a weird transitional point.

Ironically the only thing I don't dig about Volume 2 is the plot. I'm sure it was headed somewhere, but with it being cut short at thirteen issues, two of those being dedicated to a bizarrely random fight against a fish-woman, it all feels a little inconsequential. Oh well.

Oh, and I love the ending of the first issue. It's one of those little mind-f*cks where you feel like even the staff didn't know what it meant, but I enjoy it anyway. I'll take some surrealism with my Turtles comics.

Overall:
Huge points for character and atmosphere, few points for plot. Almost the direct opposite of Volume 4 for me, in which I like the plots/concepts, but the atmosphere and characters are abysmal.
Cipher is offline   Reply With Quote