Haven't watched seaons 5-7 yet but I can safely say it was a good show, it wasn't perfect, not even close but it was good.
It was well animated, it had exciting fight scenes specially the ones with Shredder(Man, was he a badass in this show) and The Foot.
It also had nice continuity which always kept you interested in watching the next episodes.
There are things I didn't really like:
- The voice acting wasn't that good at the beginning;
- The art looked kind of ugly and exagerated sometimes. I'm not much of a fan of the Battleshell and the Turtle's Lair design. Also, why did most females look masculine?;
- Sounded pretentious sometimes, it was hard to take this show seriously when Michelangelo cracked a joke that not even 10 year olds would find it funny;
- Raphael was a bit too angry and hard headed and Michelangelo got retarded by season 2;
- Casey was fine in season 1 but by season 2 he got as dumb as Michelangelo, maybe even dumber. Also, he got his a** handed to him in every fight since then;
- Most of the humor wasn't funny it was more like meh or facepalm like;
- The theme song. Definitely a step back compared with the OT.
- Baxter Stockman's mutilations, seriously;
- Notes From undergroudn arc and the Ylinthians(however that's spelled) story, by mid season 4 I was sick and tired of it;
- Leonardo hogging the spotlight, now I know he's the leader so that naturally makes him slightly more talented than his brothers but they almost made it seem that he was the main character of thje series in some episodes, mainly season 4 when he gets his ridiculous "wannabe badass" voice.
- Nanotech Robot, UGH!
- Karai. Did she really believe the Utroms were the ones who were "evil" and not Shredder?

- Some of the single episodes weren't that great, namely Garbage Men, Nanotech eps, The Golden Puck, Monster Hunter and a few others.
I won't compare it with the OT since they're different shows.
I think that the show was kinda overhyped. I remember reading comments on this show back when it aired in 2003 and people were praising it like it was the best thign ever and how the OT sucked compared to it, so I was a little bit disappointed.
Which one do I like the best? Wel, I grew up with the OT while I haven't fully watched the 2k3 yet and have been doing it in the past couple of months so it's kind of hard to answer this question.
I guess most people would rather pop in an OT episode instead of a 2k3 one bevcause the OT was episodic so it's easier to watch a single episode while the 2k3 series has continuity and if your memory of it is kinda foggy it's not a good idea to watch a random episode, meaning you would have to watch the whole series again.