View Single Post
Old 01-03-2011, 08:22 AM   #2
Spitfire
Writer • Director
 
Spitfire's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 12,035
This is interesting. I never thought about this let's see.

Archie - I love Mirage and all but Archie had the best continuity and constant quality. The story arcs were awesome and so was the artwork, most of the time. It also spawned some of my favorite TMNT characters.

Volume 1/Tales Volume 1 - It started it all and while it tended to jack around a fair bit in the middle it still had a lot of great issues. I count Tales 1 as part of this series because it was being printed at the same time, had so few issues, and I think everyone of them had a sequel in volume 1 somewhere.

Volume 3 - Probably had the best continuity out of all the volumes. The story was interesting and cool, the artwork was great, and I could tell the writers were enjoying their work.

Tales Volume 2 - A mixed bag, some awesome stuff, and some ass. I wish they would have left some stuff alone, like Rat King's origins, but I liked a fair bit of it.

Volume 2 - Short and a bit pointless. Color was a nice change but it didn't help the art much. The stuff that happened is important but it's more of a mini-series then anything.

Volume 4 - This one has potential to be great but the staggering release dates and lack of plot per issue really kill it. Once it's finished, if it's finished, it could be a lot higher on the list.

DW - I honestly hated this series. They spend several issues focusing on characters that aren't the turtles. They also add in all these pointless "urban" characters. I assume that was because the artist created Boondocks. Great art but crap stories.

I'm not including Bodycount as it holds no relevance to the overall series or any of the other specials/minis.
__________________
Check out my online portfolio
http://www.christopherpelletier.com/
Spitfire is offline   Reply With Quote