View Single Post
Old 01-18-2011, 11:33 PM   #3
John Pannozzi
Stone Warrior
 
John Pannozzi's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Rhode Island
Posts: 762
Quote:
Originally Posted by DrSpengler View Post
This was brought to the attention of Dave Sim who basically came out and said, "Dude, why didn't you just ASK!?" Sim vocally gave Laird permission to reprint the issue, free of freakin' charge, so long as he made sure to include a proper ownership credit. Laird, in all his panic, simply never bothered to ask.
More specifically Sim came up with the "Reciprocal Licensing Agreement" (meaning "I'll let you reprint it if you let me reprint it"), which he explained in a bit more detail in the Spawn Origins Book One Hardcover.

And it's worth noting that Sim's attitude and actions towards intellectual property laws are much looser than most, which means Laird probably didn't know as much about Sim's views over ownership rights as he should (I mean, the two of them were among the co-signers of the Creator's Bill of Rights, for Will Eisner's sake), but also that the other freelancers on TMNT might not necessarily be as easy to work out reprint legalities with as Sim.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Roseangelo View Post
Mirage's support for creator-owned work died in the early/mid-90s (yes, very hypocritical). The material in question that hasn't been reprinted isn't due to Mirage simply not asking, it's due to Mirage requiring all creators to sign over 100% of the rights to their work to Mirage. If a creator, such as Rick Veitch, didn't do so, Mirage basically wasn't going to bother doing anything with that work again.
The last TMNT-related thing published by Mirage and done by outsiders (Pre-Tales v.2, at least) was the Casey Jones 2-part mini-series by Rick Veitch (published in May and July of 1994), right? Though IIRC, Mirage was kind enough to let Gary Carlson keep the rights to some of the characters he created for TMNT vol. 3 (not sure which ones, though, I'd have to check the legal info).

Oh, and I while sympathize with creators, how many characters were actually created by freelancers for Tales v.2? I can't think of too many characters who debuted in that series at the moment, and at least a fair amount of Tales has done by Mirage staffers like Berger, Murphy (
Spoiler:
A.K.A. Clarrain
) and Lawson. Though I wonder if Jake Black, Will Tupper, Ross May and Tristan Jones count as Mirage staff members?

Oh, and to answer the question, from an ethical perspective, yes the creators should ideally retain ownership of the characters they create. But from a logical standpoint, when someone creates a character that's very much a part of an established franchise/series that they do not own, it makes more sense for the IP holders to own incidental characters. Like say, in the Change of Power issue of Tales v.2, I think Ross May created (or co-created, along with Peter Laird and the artists of that issue) a character who was a relative of someone integral to the backstory of the TMNT (not saying who). That would prove tricky if fictional characters were related yet owned by separate legal entities (though for all I know there very may well already be a handful of examples out there). But, to give credence to creator rights, other comics like the Savage Dragon and Powers have cameos by numerous characters owned by other people, and they seldom, if ever, have had to omit or alter any stories in reprinted forms, making Spengler's assessment of Laird seem all the more accurate.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by El Santo
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bergerjacques
It was definitely not a kid's book.
That was the thing that always mystified me about the turn the franchise took when Eastman and Laird licensed the cartoon and the parallel comic book published by the same outfit that gave us Archie. The turtles' original origin story? The whole thing hinges on a for-Christ's-sake rape-murder!!!!
from here.

Last edited by John Pannozzi; 04-01-2011 at 08:38 PM.
John Pannozzi is offline   Reply With Quote