I'm surprised a lot of people do not like TMNT 4. As far as I'm concerned, I rank it second after the first movie, which is by far my favorite. TMNT 4, besides Casey & Michelangelo, was pretty dark in my opinion, a lot closer to the first movie than the other 2 live action films were. I mean, Raph and Leo come to blows for god's sake. Pretty dark material.
I voted TMNT 2 as the worst. I used to love it as a kid, but these days I almost find it hard to watch. Don's mask was ultra-light purple - not cool. Dark purple all the way. I liked the Turtle suits (Don in specific) from movie 1, and even movie 3, better than 2. I also really just can't get into the Ninja Rap at the end. The fighting is just...bad. Movies 2 & 3 lacked the darkness and suspense that 1 had. I mean, c'mon, Shredder is defeated in 2 by Mikey hitting a keytar on full volume. It's just not right. I like 3 more than 2 maybe just because I'm biased and it's the only movie I remember seeing in the theatres and being more excited for than a kid on Christmas morning.
But hey, that's just me.