I've got a whole bunch of ideas for TMNT collected books, and here's a few to start with:
*”Mark Martin’s Complete TMNT”
TMNT vol. 1 #18, 22-23
“Lasagna Loves” (mini-comic)
Green-Grey Sponge-Suit Sushi Turtles (one-shot parody)
“Toyoduh in the Naked City” (from the color Turtle Soup #1)
“Velveeduh in The One That Got Away” (from Turtle Soup #2)"
“Viceroy in The One That Got Away” (from Turtle Soup #3)
“Pierrier in The Old Switcheroo!” (from Turtle Soup #4)
*”Rich Hedden and Tom McWeeney’s Complete TMNT”
TMNT vol. 1 #34, & 28-40
“Turtle Power!” (from the color Turtle Soup #1)
“The Maltese Turtle” (one-shot special)
“Yo-Ho-Ho! And a Bottle of Mutagen” (from TMNT Adventures Special #5)
*”Mark Bodé’s Complete TMNT”
TMNT vol. 1 #18 & 32 (both B&W and color versions)
“Times Pipeline” (one-shot special)
“Ninjara VS Mondo Dog Cathcer” (from TMNT Adventures Special #
That's how I would collect most of the crazier guest-creator issues, at least.
What I want to know is how the back-up stories from Tales of the TMNT vol. 2 should be collected? Should they be a part of proper Tales vol. 2 collections, or should they be shuffled off to a Shell Shock-type book with all the other back-ups and short stories? And for that matter, how should the main stories of Tales vol. 2 be collected? I'v come up with this crazy idea for all the Tales vol. 2 stories to be collected in the order of Splengs' timeline, but I don't know if the majority of Mirage TMNT comics fans here would think that would be particularly practical way to do it.
In any case, there are some short stories I feel deserve special placements in the collected books. For instance, maybe the first Vol. 1 book should have the story "Fifteen Years Later..." from Turtle Soup #4, because it serves as a nice complement to the very first issue, and even adds an extra layer and emotional impact to #1's story. Putting "Complete Carnage an' Radical" in the first Vol. 1 book would make the appearance of those characters later on in #28 less confusing to newcomers. I would like "Zog" from Tales vol. 2 inserted between TMNT vol. 1 #19 and 20, and "Temps" from Tales vol. 2 #46 inserted between TMNT vol. 1 #53 and 54, for hopefully obvious reasons

. Inserting the Donatello: the Brain Thief miniseries between TMNT vol. 2 #9 and 10 might also be an interesting idea, same with putting the Michelangelo: The Third Kind mini between TMNT vol. 4 #5 and 6. And including the Super Turtles origin story from Tales vol. 2 #47 as a supplement in whatever book collects TMNT vol. 4 #7 would probably be best, considering that Tales vol. 2 #47 might seen a bit out of place with the other Tales story, what with being set in a different universe than the Mirage TMNT one and all.