View Single Post
Old 04-17-2011, 08:37 PM   #4
Galactus
Foot Elite
 
Galactus's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 3,009
This has been alluded to before in Lavigne/Brownes blog which stated that the Archie book was on the brink of breach of contract with it's cartoon adaptions.

Quote:
Originally Posted by oldmanwinters View Post
I can't say that I have a big problem with an animation company claiming rights to its own programs. Studios claim ownership rights over movies based on licensed properties (i.e., Universal= Hulk, The Incredible Hulk, Sony= Spider-man 1-3, Fox= X-Men films, etc.)

It doesn't strike me that Fred Wolf did anything crooked, unless he violated a prior "verbal agreement."
Or a written one. If I'm interpreting Farley's words correctly and assuming they're an accurate description of the situation back then it seems that Fred Wolf decided he owned the TV version of the turtles.

Owning the show which is their work is one thing but Mirage owns the TMNT in all it's likenesses. Obviously that's what we eventualy ended up with since we got the '87 toon characters and world recreated accurately in Turtles Forever. We didn't get the old shows soundtrack or any animation for the the old show since that does and should belong to Fred Wolf.

Of course intellectual property is a huge grey area anyway. If for example Mirage or rather Nickleodeon now decide that they don't want anyone using the character of Leatherhead does that mean they can't release anymore DVDs of eps of either cartoon that feature him.


Quote:
Originally Posted by DrSpengler View Post
I think the difference here, though is that the "work for hire" Farley speaks of was retroactive.
Well it's as good as definitely but since he got some money for it then they essentialy wanted to buy the work from him...even if it wasn't what he would consider a fair price. I don't believe they had no choice in this matter since Rick Veitch told 'em to take a hike.

Quote:
I've read that Sim is notoriously... "difficult" and has lived a rather checkered lifestyle, though the way Sim tells it, Laird never even made an attempt to contact him to negotiate terms.

So its certainly understandable why Laird would have been intimidated by Sim's reputation, though to not even make an effort is a tad less excusable.
Dave Sim isn't that easy to get a hold of since he doesn't use email and he doesn't use contracts and to quote Farley here "get everything in writing, even if it's your own mother". Sim did eventualy agree to a very basic contract.

The lack of communication goes both ways. Sim stated that he doubted that Laird would allow TMNT #8 to be reprinted in Cerebus miscellany and made no attempt to find out. I believe the right for Sim to reprint #8 was part of the contact that allowed it to be reprinted in Mirage's own trade.
Galactus is offline   Reply With Quote