|
"Return to New York" is my favorite story arc, as well. I think the 3-part length makes it more rereadable and, despite only being three issues, it doesn't feel overly compressed at all. It tells a story that had been building up steadily for ten issues and feels suitably epic.
I love "City at War", don't get me wrong. It's perhaps more cerebral and emotional (particularly Casey's and April's segments), which is definately some major points in its favor, but it does feel a bit overlong and, in all honesty, the "Ninja rebellion" thing hadn't been gaining steam in the previous issues of TMNT all that much. We don't find out about the Foot civil war until #45, in a brief bit of foreshadowing, then #46-47 take a turn away from things for a time traveling arc and #48-49 acts mostly as a prologue to Casey and April's storyarcs than the actual City at War.
Whereas "Return to New York" hadd been fueled by the previous 10 issues of the series and the reckoning felt in that arc had tons of forward momentum going for it.
They're both fantastic story lines and two of TMNT's absolute best, but my favorite will always be "Return to New York".
|