Donny,
I must say, the first movie was the best. Just taking a look at those screen caps of Leonardo gritting his teeth fighting a Foot Ninja was breathtaking. Sorry for the dramatic language.
I do believe that the first movie was almost as accurate to the '84 comics. But, I also believe the second film was a continuation of the first film. The Shredder
did come back. Was that one the best? No. But it was fun to watch. Besides, Super Shredder was awesome.
Now, I will say that I don't count the third film as an actual TMNT flim because it was silly, and all the turtles seemed to get out of character for a lot of scenes.
I enjoyed the CGI animated film. It seemed to be a continuation of the first two films. There were some of those classic elements shown in the film. Example: Shredder's helmet in the trophy room (or closet - I don't know what it really was).

Plus, I never considered it a 2k3 meets OT film. This seemed to be something new. Now that I think about it, it might have been just a test. It seemed that Mirage was floundering with
Fast Forward so they had to think of something fast to keep TMNT in the public eye again. I enjoyed reading the junior novel of the film. But I realize, I would have LOVED for the Shredder to come in. They made an action figure of him in armor that he never wore. That's a cool figure by the way.
I'm hoping the new TMNT film will be like a
Batman Begins kind of story. That would be great. Maybe the film could be a mix of the new 2k12 Nickelodeon series meets the IDW comics. What do you think?