Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB
|
I probably should have elaborated more. It was said earlier that if the characters aren't going to be portrayed in the same way, why include them? But aren't most remakes about shaking things up a little, telling a similar story but putting new spins? That would include possibly making changes in character behavior.
For instance, in the Battlestar Galactica remake, Baltar went from being supervillain evil in the original to being portrayed as narcissistic, self serving, and willing to do anything to save his miserable butt, while still having redeeming qualities and feelings of guilt over what he did. That is quite a change for the character between versions, but that's what remakes do. They take things the audience is familiar with, but add new twists to make things interesting.
I think that if someone is doing a remake of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, then all of the characters from the past should be fair game for being re-imagined. Especially characters that are as recognizable as Bebop and Rocksteady. I don't see why certain characters should be excluded just because of the tone of the old cartoon. Just because they were characterized one way, doesn't mean they can't be intimidating and bad ass in the comic. After all, we're talking about a giant rhino, that
should be intimidating.
I don't see why the writers should have to come up with completely new characters to fit that role, when the fictional universe isn't even original in the first place. Nostalgia is what kept the TMNT going for so long, so I don't think the writers can be faulted for wanting to have more recognizable characters in their story.
My take is that the new comic's take on old characters should be judged by what happens in the comic, not necessarily how the characters were portrayed before. It's a sticky subject, because the whole reason the characters are there is because they are familiar. Really, in the end, it's just fiction, and it's not like the old comics or cartoons are going to go away because there's a new version we may or may not like. That's what I try to tell myself after every horror remake.