|
My little review:
I already expected this issue to be pretty endearing in a "sweet" sort of a way regardless of how I may feel overall about the artwork or character beats... but I actually liked it a bit more than expected. I wouldn't call it a classic or anything that'll sit in the Halls of Lost Legends of great TMNT stories for years to come, but it's a fun little Michelangelo tale and it never really pretends to be anything more than that anyway.
Tonally it's about on par with the original Michelangelo special from '85, so it's hard to put it under too many screws. I was worried that "Dude Mikey" would be a little bit too much in the forefront (I'll admit, "I wanna be Michelangelo... party dude" made me shudder -- it's the kind of one-note sound byte of characterization one might attribute to Michelangelo if they'd done nothing but, say, watch a few cartoons, the movies, and maybe played with some toys) of what should otherwise be a multi-dimensional character whose true heart lies in things like creativity, writing, etc.. Then I got to thinking... how much of any of the other stuff did we really see in the original Mike special? Not much, really (beyond a humanitarian side with rescuing/adopting Klunk, I suppose) . I mean, sure, Mike there wasn't actively trying to "party" or do anything Mike Cliche™ like that back then, but it was just a pretty barebones tale with heart about him foiling... a heist. Like this story. Foiling a heist. We didn't get anything of Mike's other sides or evolution as a character until later in Mirage, until issues like #17 where we live out a story he's writing.
So I mean to say... the IDW Mike special is very good for what it is and delivers exactly what it's trying to be and it holds it own fairly well next to the original work. It's not a story I particularly wanted to be told, or would like to see regularly, but I did enjoy it. I hope it speaks more of where is Michelangelo is at right now and not where he's going/how he will evolve.
The art? Personal taste: the Raphael special and this one are on completely opposite ends of the spectrum -- where the Raph special features pretty dynamic artwork and top-of-the-line coloring, the Mike special features pretty quirky artwork and pretty plain-jane coloring. Either take is perfectly viable in terms of artistic choice and both seem suitable to their respective story... if I imagine, for example, the Mike and Raph specials swapping artists and colorists, that'd look a little weird.
I think enough has been said here about the oddities of Mike seeking training from Raph and all that, but if I could chime in on the Don thing... the more I think on that the more it bothers me, too. To put things into perspective, here's what we're looking at: Donatello was a young kid in Feudal Japan once, lived about 14 or 15 years, then was killed. He gets reborn as a sea turtle, mutated into a humanoid, then spends 15 months training in ninjitsu with Splinter. The only time Don could have possibly spent learning anything technical, it would've had to have been during these 15 months, 15 months also spent not just coming to grips with being a mutated Turtle in a sewer but, you know, sentience and stuff. It's not like the the Fred Wolf material (or to a lesser degree, the Mirage and 4Kids stuff) that somehow ask us to buy that in 15 years he somehow, inexplicably became more adept than even the top graduates at MIT... no, we're just talking about a little over a year to come up from scratch. All I'm saying is... if IDW starts having Donatello build Turtle Vans or BattleShells or Turtle Blimps or Turtle Blasters or any kind of nonsense like that (note to IDW: please don't) then the bottom's kind of going to fall out on that whole thing.
Also, whatever IDW is paying David Petersen, it's well worth it. Beautiful work he's doing on these covers.
Last edited by Andrew NDB; 12-28-2011 at 10:41 PM.
|