|
Well, as we can all see here, every person has their own interpretation of the TMNT, and I can see the validity in most. Even Andrew and Tristan Jones were disagreeing on the "clan" aspect, two guys who know their turtles. However, just because something is fantasy or a comic book, doesn't mean it's completely illogical. It still needs to have and abide by its own set of rules and logic. That's the difference between good and bad storytelling.
In the end, it is fiction and it can be whatever as long as it makes sense. It would seem Tom's interpretation is emphasizing the family aspect more than past interpretations. Does that delegitimatize the turtles as ninjas? Perhaps a bit, but not completely. But I don't think there is anything inherently contradictory about ninjas who have differing philosophies and ideologies. After all, they are still people with their own personal beliefs. Perhaps Oroku Saki reflected the more traditional mindset (ruthless assassins) and Hamato Yoshi had a different sense of what ninjitsu ought to be utilized for. Or maybe Yoshi realized the attitudes of the traditional ninja wasn't for him through the lessons and consequences of violence beset upon and by him and now uses the skills of the ninja solely to protect himself and his family. Thus, they would be considered ninjas only because they practice ninjitsu while abandoning its ideals (or lack thereof), sort of like a ronin.
__________________
"Baxter, you slime puppy!"
Last edited by Matches Malone; 01-19-2012 at 05:05 PM.
|