Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB
Really? I tend to think it's simple logic.
This just in -- ninjas kill... ergo, if you're a ninja that does not, that's kinda weird. And if the only reason behind why you're a ninja that doesn't kill is because you swore some kind of oath in another life to not avenge the killing of your wife (even though if you'd done so, you would have not only saved the lives of all four of your children but your own!)... well that doesn't make any sense either.
Maybe somebody (Tom?) can explain it to me a little better but right now it's difficult to digest. And I understand the "no killing" thing will be a topic of discussion in the next year of IDW TMNT comics (though I'm almost wondering if by putting the whole thing under the magnifying glass that's only going to succeed in making the issue even more laughable, because as-is I'm not sure it's a topic that's going to hold up under scrutiny).
|
I can understand this to an extent. On one hand, there's definitely some getting used to going from Mirage where killing was never really a question. Heck, if I recall correctly, the Tales of the TMNT issue "Temps" was all from a sympathetic POV of a Foot soldier who gets killed and there are basically no consequences for Raphael offing him.
On the other hand, I can accept if Tom wants to write a TMNT with a "no-kill" morality. Sure, historically ninjas kill, steal etc. But this is obviously a fictionalized version where Eastman acknowledges that they made up this "honor code" about ninjas. If Tom wants to take that to the next step where Splinter and his clan take on a "no-kill" policy, I'm okay with that, but ONLY if it makes sense and is compelling.
So at this point, does it? Is it? The jury is still out for me. I agree that logically, the transition from Yoshi being Foot soldier who is morally okay with "honorable killing" to a "no killing whatsoever" policy has not been overly clear.
His family was killed because he didn't want to kill, so the lesson is... don't kill? I'm not saying it should lead to the opposite attitude, I'm just saying the dots need to be connected a little better.
The only explanations I've heard that we
could infer, is that he believes that Karma is the true reason his family was murdered; a punishment for his life as an assassin and ninja. A second possible explanation is that he has become so embittered by the cruelty of killing in general (as witnessed by his family's deaths), that he no longer wishes to kill at all. They are now ninjas only in the sense that they are skilled in the art of ninjitsu and martial arts, but they live by a different code than the Foot. I'm okay with either of those explanations, really, but I'd like that to be a little clearer since these are just inferences at this point. I think Tom is leaving a little too much unsaid, if we are to really understand Splinter's motivations right now.
Or maybe some or all of the above are exactly what they are going to be exploring in year two.