So… the Grand Finale of the first IDW TMNT year is here. I have mixed feelings about it.
Honestly, I don’t like to read story arcs’ finales. They’re all too predictable. The whole last issue was nothing but depiction of a long fight, in which the good are victorious, and the bad are defeated. I’m interested in the story itself. The finales do not advance the plot, they just put end to it. And, as I said, they’re always predictable. As was in the case with the fourth issue of IDW TMNT (the conclusion of “Quest for Raphael” story), so it is with the most part of DC and Marvel comics. Well, I can’t say the same about the eighth issue (when the part about Mousers ended), but it was just a “formal” finale. Actually, the story ended only right now. And what do we have here? Very predictable fight with Foot Clan and Shredder, in which the Turtles win. What a surprise!
And a couple of words about realization. There are both positive and negative things. The positive ones:
1. I liked the dialogue between Shredder and Splinter during their fight. It was actually impressive. We see Shredder’s side of the story, and that gives us the new perspective, from which we can see that he’s not just a common thug, but a person with his own world view.
2. Leo’s phrase “I’m the one who believes in miracles”. After all these long arguments with Don, it sounds very nice, short and simple.
3. The reference to Leo’s micro-series and his phrase “I’m unimpressed”. This writing technique is very old, but here it fits perfectly.
4. The conclusion of Baxter Stockman/Krang/Old Hob conflict. Without unwanted sentiments and without unnecessary violence. Everything’s logical, clear and correct. Now we’re waiting for “Plan B” and Old Hob’s return.
And what about other important things? I mean the fight with Foot Clan and Shredder? There’s no dynamics and no drama, no ANYTHING. Duncan’s empty backgrounds, Waltz’s empty panels.
Well, speaking about Duncan… He should have tried better at least for the last issue. When Casey cries about ninjas being like cockroaches, and at the same time we see NO NINJAS on the background, it’s just ridiculous. Especially in comparison with the great cover art from Eastman.
But the most epic fail is the fight with Shredder. I understand that the amount of pages is limited, but when the Turtles kick Shredder’s ass just in 4 (!!!) panels, it’s just not right. And no homage to Mirage turtles’ first fight with Shredder will ever justify that. Bad. Sorry, but it's bad.
6.5/10 points.
PS. Looks like making Angel an adult girl instead of a child was a deliberate move. There’s going to be April-Casey-Angel love triangle, it seems.