TMNT: Saturday Morning Adventures #4. Preview and discussion

[AlZarkovski]

First look:

Spoiler:

[oldmanwinters]

Poor Splinter, what a way to go... gassed like an unwanted rat!

[frank_one]

Nice nod to the Mirage folks in the Ace Duck poster.

[Shedder]

Is this the final issue or will this series continue past 4?

[Cowabung-Gal]

Originally Posted by frank_one

Nice nod to the Mirage folks in the Ace Duck poster.

Technically Ace didn’t appear until the Fred Wolf cartoon, and before that he was just an action figure that was conceived by Playmates.

[CyberCubed]

These issues feel like those licensed Random House children's books from the 90's rather than being written like an actual original cartoon episode would be. That's the closest thing I can relate it to, those old 90's children books drawn based on the Fred Wolf cartoon and had unique stories...but they never felt like an actual episode because the way the Turtles/characters and stories were written just didn't feel the same.

It's sad because I really wanted to get into this but it just, "doesn't feel the same."

[oldmanwinters]

Originally Posted by CyberCubed

These issues feel like those licensed Random House children's books from the 90's rather than being written like an actual original cartoon episode would be. That's the closest thing I can relate it to, those old 90's children books drawn based on the Fred Wolf cartoon and had unique stories...but they never felt like an actual episode because the way the Turtles/characters and stories were written just didn't feel the same.

It's sad because I really wanted to get into this but it just, "doesn't feel the same."

Modern comics don’t tend to follow the traditional 3 Act structure like old cartoon episodes did.

[LeotheLateBloomer]

Are anyone buying these? Cause I completely forgot they exist.

[Chaotix12345]

Originally Posted by Shedder

Is this the final issue or will this series continue past 4?

This is the last one for now, but I could definitely see them doing more in the future. (Especially since the trade collection of the first four is labeled "Volume 1.")

[oldmanwinters]

I think Sat Morn Adv might be featured as a FCBD issue this year.
https://www.cgmagonline.com/news/fre...book-day-2023/
https://www.instagram.com/p/CnMxL9oL...d=YmMyMTA2M2Y=

[CyberCubed]

I checked out the first issue but not the others so far. I guess you can just never "recapture" what the original cartoon actually was. It's hard to describe, but every time they try to make a comic, homage or continuation of it, it just feels not the same.

I guess it really was lightning in a bottle.

[Anarchistguy]

Not sure how I feel about the TMNT calling each other by their nicknames since it never happened in the cartoon.

[neatoman]

Originally Posted by Anarchistguy

Not sure how I feel about the TMNT calling each other by their nicknames since it never happened in the cartoon.

This mini quite literally features TCRI as a major plot element and implies they might have been responsible for the mutagen rather than Krang or Shredder, there are bigger deviations from the cartoon than using the Nicknames.

Originally Posted by CyberCubed

These issues feel like those licensed Random House children's books from the 90's rather than being written like an actual original cartoon episode would be. That's the closest thing I can relate it to, those old 90's children books drawn based on the Fred Wolf cartoon and had unique stories...but they never felt like an actual episode because the way the Turtles/characters and stories were written just didn't feel the same.

It's sad because I really wanted to get into this but it just, "doesn't feel the same."

Originally Posted by CyberCubed

I checked out the first issue but not the others so far. I guess you can just never "recapture" what the original cartoon actually was. It's hard to describe, but every time they try to make a comic, homage or continuation of it, it just feels not the same.

I guess it really was lightning in a bottle.

Well, it is difficult to emulate 10-15 minutes of filler in a comic book, not to mention impossible include animation errors and terrible sound mixing. And oh gosh darn it, the monthly schedule coupled with the reasonable amount of installments meant the writer must have given into the temptation of spending more than a single hour writing each script, so not even the sloppy writing has been emulated! Oh no, I am so sad that crappy cartoon that should have by all rights been considered nothing but an embarrassing relic by now can't be replicated properly, will we ever be able to see something do that piece of shit show justice?

OK, I'm not going to pretend this comic is interesting, because it's essentially children's comic book aimed at 40-somethings. However, I'm not going to pretend it's less interesting than the actual Fred Wolf show itself. Had these issues actually been episodes of the show back then, I doubt you would have disliked them, they might even have been considered some of the better episodes on the basis that they're more coherent than most episodes. And what are the actual plots here? VR with plenty of villains teaming up, A Rock Soldier learning the meaning of Rock 'N Roll, Casey Jones with Electric Superpowers and Fantastic Journey but with Mousers... Do any of those sound like something you would have had a problem with as a kid?

[Coola Yagami]

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters

I think Sat Morn Adv might be featured as a FCBD issue this year.
https://www.cgmagonline.com/news/fre...book-day-2023/
https://www.instagram.com/p/CnMxL9oL...d=YmMyMTA2M2Y=

Looks like it's just gonna be a reprint of the first issue with an extra Rise back up story?

Originally Posted by neatoman

And what are the actual plots here? VR with plenty of villains teaming up, A Rock Soldier learning the meaning of Rock 'N Roll, Casey Jones with Electric Superpowers and Fantastic Journey but with Mousers... DO any of those sound like something you would have had a problem with as a kid?

Don't hold back Neatoman, tell us how you really feel.

Honestly though, the stone warrior rock and roll one felt the most out of left field even for the 80's show.

[Sumac]

Originally Posted by neatoman

Well, it is difficult to emulate 10-15 minutes of filler in a comic book, not to mention impossible include animation errors and terrible sound mixing. And oh gosh darn it, the monthly schedule coupled with the reasonable amount of installments meant the writer must have given into the temptation of spending more than a single hour writing each script, so not even the sloppy writing has been emulated! Oh no, I am so sad that crappy cartoon that should have by all rights been considered nothing but an embarrassing relic by now can't be replicated properly, will we ever be able to see something do that piece of shit show justice?

You won't get that Mirage adaptation for Christmas, so might cry all you want, LOL.

[neatoman]

Originally Posted by Sumac

You won't get that Mirage adaptation for Christmas, so might cry all you want, LOL.

So you're perfectly happy with this comic then?

[Sumac]

Originally Posted by neatoman

So you're perfectly happy with this comic then?

Haven't read it, yet.
Just don't see necessity to **** on an old cartoon, which have ended more than 20 years ago.

Let it go, mate. Remove crust from your pants and look into the future.

[neatoman]

Originally Posted by Sumac

Haven't read it, yet.
Just don't see necessity to **** on an old cartoon, which have ended more than 20 years ago.

Let it go, mate. Remove crust from your pants and look into the future.

Well, see, what I'm trying to say is that is that if this comic is intended to capture the spirit of that cartoon which ended more than 20 years ago (which it is clearly intended to do), then it hasn't exactly failed if it's generic and dull.

[Sumac]

Originally Posted by neatoman

Well, see, what I'm trying to say is that is that if this comic is intended to capture the spirit of that cartoon which ended more than 20 years ago (which it is clearly intended to do), then it hasn't exactly failed if it's generic and dull.

It could have been done without ******** on an old series.

[neatoman]

Originally Posted by Sumac

It could have been done without ******** on an old series.

... Well, I kind of can't, the whole premise of the argument is that an uninteresting comic can't be worse than the cartoon on the basis that the cartoon sucked in the first place. I guess I didn't need to be sarcastic about it but I can't say the Fred Wolf cartoon is bad without saying the Fred Wolf cartoon is bad.