PDA

View Full Version : TMNT Sequel - Confirmation of a sequel still pending


Pages : 1 [2] 3

Aryudsoh
07-31-2007, 03:33 PM
First time I remember seeing Mako was in some TV movie called The Last Ninja where he adopted an American boy and taught him the ways of the ninja.

As for his replacement in Avatar, they cast his student or something like that. Mako had been his mentor and they were very happy with how he tested during his audition.

Buslady
07-31-2007, 04:14 PM
Simply put Mako was a legend like Toshiro Mifune. He would be hard to replace. I almost think Splinter should be laid to rest if nobody could come close to that voice. BUT...no way in hell they'd kill off the ol rat.

Splinter's Iroonna
07-31-2007, 04:15 PM
They'd BETTER not!

*gets weapons ready*

Andrew NDB
07-31-2007, 06:46 PM
I think my first exposure to Mako was "Conan the Barbarian."

Now there's a movie.

Spitfire
07-31-2007, 07:40 PM
Simply put Mako was a legend like Toshiro Mifune. He would be hard to replace. I almost think Splinter should be laid to rest if nobody could come close to that voice. BUT...no way in hell they'd kill off the ol rat.

The guy who voiced him in the video game did a mighty fine job I thought they should use him.

Spawn Guy
07-31-2007, 07:42 PM
Definatly.

ToTheNines
07-31-2007, 10:26 PM
I think my first exposure to Mako was "Conan the Barbarian."

Now there's a movie.

Yeah, Conan is a great flick and I loved Mako's crazy wizard character :lol:

J Legault
08-02-2007, 12:17 AM
Hmm, a lot of well thought up compliments for Mako.

And yes, I too agree that having no Splinter in the sequal would do no justice for TMNT.

I mean when was there a TMNT that had no mentor at all to guide the reptiles. Well except for what had happen in the Vol. 4 series.

Splinter's Iroonna
08-02-2007, 12:30 AM
...I mean when was there a TMNT that had no mentor at all to guide the reptiles. Well except for what had happen in the Vol. 4 series.


AAAUUUGHH!!! NOOO!!!

Sorry-- but it still burns me that (and yes, perhaps there is a PART of me that would understand the reason behind it) Splinter was offed! But the guys have become SO separated that it's almost impossible to believe that they might actually remember that they are four brothers and rejoin....

J Legault
08-06-2007, 01:33 AM
Sorry, I was only stating what is true that, it be a bad idea to remove the "mentor" as the supporting charater.

Leogeddon
08-06-2007, 01:37 AM
i remember hearing after the credits that shredder's foot came down on the ground (we are at bug height) and the foot soldiers sprung apart...

could be Kunai/Katara (god, i can't believe i forgot) leading the foot though wearing the shredder outfit...

ToTheNines
08-06-2007, 09:08 AM
It's Karai

Who told you this by the way? I can't deny it because we didn't sit through the credits, but I'm sure some one here did and no one said anything about it.

Roseangelo
08-06-2007, 09:18 AM
There is nothing after the credits.

gobo
08-06-2007, 04:51 PM
100% USDA boneless nothing... You've been had, Tony.

ToTheNines
08-06-2007, 07:07 PM
Yeah dude, someone straight up lied to you... im not saying you should kill them... buuuuuut you know...:evilgrin:

Ecto Jedi
08-07-2007, 01:42 PM
i remember hearing after the credits that shredder's foot came down on the ground (we are at bug height) and the foot soldiers sprung apart...

could be Kunai/Katara (god, i can't believe i forgot) leading the foot though wearing the shredder outfit...

Well, that would have been cool.

Godzilla
08-13-2007, 06:40 PM
Well, that would have been cool.
Yes. An even more not-so-subtle hint.

Andrew NDB
08-13-2007, 06:58 PM
What's after the credits in the movie actually serve as a great teaser for the sequel.

ToTheNines
08-13-2007, 07:34 PM
What's after the credits in the movie actually serve as a great teaser for the sequel.

You're just full of those aren't you?

Ecto Jedi
08-13-2007, 07:58 PM
What's after the credits in the movie actually serve as a great teaser for the sequel.

I'm really beginning to dislike you.

Kendamu
08-13-2007, 08:53 PM
What's after the credits in the movie actually serve as a great teaser for the sequel.
The movie could've been worse. It could've left off with Leo at the Battle Nexus who just met some guy dressed as the Shredder who has a combination name based on both Saki and Yoshi, Don being the size of an action figure, Gammaraph drinking beer and watching TV, and Mikey getting ready to spar with a Triceradon.

That would never happen in any TMNT media, though. ;)

PrivateRadio
08-16-2007, 01:34 AM
What's after the credits in the movie actually serve as a great teaser for the sequel.

Well, I laughed.

Avatar Yuffie
08-16-2007, 04:37 AM
It's Mako.


Well, he voiced a character on The Last Airbender, and they found someone to replace him. I don't know much about that show, though, so I've no idea just how important his role was-- except it must have been important enough to recast it.

It's almost the end of the month.

Actually, Mako voiced quite an important regular character in that show. The new guy who replaces him is not another Japanese guy, but he sounds like him.

I'm dreading and looking forward to his actual performance in the final season.

What's after the credits in the movie actually serve as a great teaser for the sequel.

Yeah. The Lord of the Rings: Revenge of the Wank.

tcclives23
08-16-2007, 09:49 AM
Could this be bad?

There's No Stopping the 300
Source: The Hollywood Reporter
August 16, 2007


300 crushed the competition during its second week in video stores, retaining the top spot on the national sales chart despite a strong challenge from Disturbia, says The Hollywood Reporter.

The newcomer, with a box office gross of more than $80 million, debuted at No. 2 on the Nielsen VideoScan First Alert sales chart for the week ending August 12, though its total unit sales were only about 53% of those of 300.

Disturbia did manage a No. 1 bow on Home Media Magazine's video rental chart, generating $9.7 million. That was enough to push 300 to No. 2 with $9.5 million.

TMNT debuted at No. 3 on the sales chart but could muster only a 12th-place bow on the rental chart.

The Ice Cube comedy sequel Are We Done Yet? debuted at No. 4 on the sales chart and at No. 3 on the rental chart, with earnings pegged at $6.8 million. Fox's Season 10 set of "The Simpsons" bowed at No. 5 on the sales chart.

In the high-definition disc arena, 300 was the No. 1 seller on both the Blu-ray Disc and the HD DVD charts.

Superherohype.com (http://www.superherohype.com/news/topnews.php?id=6210)

Andrew NDB
08-16-2007, 11:04 AM
Could this be bad?

Pretty much the death rattle.

The Shelf
08-16-2007, 11:53 AM
Could this be bad?

Superherohype.com (http://www.superherohype.com/news/topnews.php?id=6210)

What's bad about that? It's no. 3 in sales. Sounds pretty good to me. That's much more important than rentals.

ToTheNines
08-16-2007, 11:58 AM
3'rd aint bad. I'll tell you what is bad tho, is that Are We F**kin Done Yet got rented more than TMNT. But then again, no die hard TMNT fan is gonna rent it.

Splinter's Iroonna
08-16-2007, 11:59 AM
Pretty much the death rattle.

http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y201/cynlee/fox_grapes.jpg

johnnyblaze
08-16-2007, 01:39 PM
so more people are buying it then renting it? that seems kind of odd...

ToTheNines
08-16-2007, 02:33 PM
I just go back from my video store, and they were all out.... as was the whole wall of 300.

Drtooth
08-16-2007, 03:19 PM
3'rd aint bad. I'll tell you what is bad tho, is that Are We F**kin Done Yet got rented more than TMNT. But then again, no die hard TMNT fan is gonna rent it.


There's no stopping a retarded halfassed piece of crap family movie in this "Moral firndly" climate of ours. nothing's funnier than people falling off the roof multiple times. Nothing. That's why half of every PG movie has that at least 6 times in a movie.

Seriously, even as a direct to DVD release, I've seen films that do horribly and get multipe sequals out of it. if anything is keeping the prospect of a sequal down, it's script approval. At least IMO.

I mean, the toys did infinantly better than the movie. It pretty much saved Playmates lately. Even though they are starting to make the same stupid choices that killed the other lines.

How well did the first 2 do to make 3 movies out of them, considering the third one didn't do too well?

ToTheNines
08-16-2007, 06:02 PM
if anything is keeping the prospect of a sequal down, it's script approval. At least IMO.

Better ask Andrew about that one...

johnnyblaze
08-16-2007, 06:30 PM
lol, i actually laughed out loud at that one :)

Dragon Turtle
08-16-2007, 09:20 PM
Could this be bad?



Superherohype.com (http://www.superherohype.com/news/topnews.php?id=6210)


No, pretty much what you could have expected, personally I'm just glad it sold more then "Are we Done Yet" (my my my Ice Cube, you certainly have come a long way since your N.W.A. days:lol: ).


As for its rental position, it was clear it was not going to be a huge player when they have less shelf space allocated to them then "Fire House Dog" and "Pathfinder".:roll:

ToTheNines
08-16-2007, 09:26 PM
As for its rental position, it was clear it was not going to be a huge player when they have less shelf space allocated to them then "Fire House Dog" and "Pathfinder".:roll:

Yep, I've seen it with my own eyes.

Avatar Yuffie
08-16-2007, 10:30 PM
Uh wait, it's a bad thing it never gets rented but has more DVD sales?

Weird...

Dragon Turtle
08-17-2007, 12:04 AM
Uh wait, it's a bad thing it never gets rented but has more DVD sales?

Weird...

No, sales are much more important.

tcclives23
08-17-2007, 01:33 PM
I was just thinking that, though 3rd isn't all that bad, it could be a sign of things to come. Like last week it was 3rd but then this week it could be 6th and it keeps dropping. I'm just wondering what kind of DVD sales would be needed to generate a sequel.

iris
08-19-2007, 05:28 PM
Pretty much the death rattle.
http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y201/cynlee/fox_grapes.jpg

Fabulous.


*snerk*

CyberCubed
08-27-2007, 12:03 PM
Murphy updated his blog and said there's still no news.

This has gotten tiring.

Dragon Turtle
08-27-2007, 07:25 PM
Murphy updated his blog and said there's still no news.

This has gotten tiring.


According to Murphy:

"The problem doesn't lie with Warner Brothers as it does with the contract renegotiation that is taking place between WB and animation studio Imagi. Or so I'm told."


I Knew there had to be more to the TMNT sequel story then just "it depends on whether or not Warner Bros wishes to a make the sequel", between greenlighting "Ace Ventura 3"(without Jim Carry) and watching another big budget movie(The invasion) bomb at the boxoffice, the WB isn't going to just toss aside a movie that has made over 100 million in boxoffice and DVD sales.

Spitfire
08-27-2007, 07:30 PM
That's WB's fault for being mentally retarded and green lighting a 4th remake of a movie. Honestly what a moronic move.

Kendamu
08-27-2007, 09:08 PM
I wonder what the negotiations are about. Maybe we should send Roger Smith in.

Andrew NDB
08-27-2007, 09:24 PM
Anyone interested in what I think this means? :)

gobo
08-27-2007, 09:34 PM
I Knew there had to be more to the TMNT sequel story then just "it depends on whether or not Warner Bros wishes to a make the sequel", between greenlighting "Ace Ventura 3"(without Jim Carry) and watching another big budget movie(The invasion) bomb at the boxoffice, the WB isn't going to just toss aside a movie that has made over 100 million in boxoffice and DVD sales.
Underlined for wisdom... ^_^ Profits are profits, after all.
Anyone interested in what I think this means? :)
Nay.

Dragon Turtle
08-27-2007, 10:12 PM
Anyone interested in what I think this means? :)

Yeah sure, I'll bite. The floor is yours Mr. Andrew.:)

Ecto Jedi
08-27-2007, 10:24 PM
Yeah sure, I'll bite. The floor is yours Mr. Andrew.:)

Aww Jesus, why do you encourage him like that?

Sabacooza
08-27-2007, 10:29 PM
The Toronto Comicon has come and gone and the Mirage crew was there so my friend asked them a simple question. Is there going to be a sequel? They said there's definitely going to be a sequel. Take it as you will but I know we'll all feel better when they post it all over the official site.

Roseangelo
08-27-2007, 10:37 PM
A very similar conversation happened at Comic-Con where there were assurances from a very official source that a sequel WILL happen. It just sounds like it's a details thing before anything can be announced.

Dragon Turtle
08-27-2007, 10:55 PM
Aww Jesus, why do you encourage him like that?

Some dark force compels me to learn more of the inner workings of Andrew's mind, either that or I was just distracted by the smiley face emoticon.:)


Personally, When I hear "contract renegotiation", it just appears to be who wants more money and/or how they can cut money out from the sequel.

johnnyblaze
08-27-2007, 11:20 PM
it sounds more like its in a 'who is getting paid what', 'how much are we putting into the film money wise' stage of negotiations

the saving grace of this film, business wise, seems to be the fact that it is so cheap to make. hopefully that fact will continue to play in its favor

Splinter's Iroonna
08-28-2007, 12:11 AM
The Toronto Comicon has come and gone and the Mirage crew was there so my friend asked them a simple question. Is there going to be a sequel? They said there's definitely going to be a sequel. Take it as you will but I know we'll all feel better when they post it all over the official site.

Sounds like what we were told at comic-con, as Roseangelo mentioned.


But yes-- it would be nice for them to come out and say it.

And just to add fuel to the fire..

http://felixip.blogspot.com/2007/08/same-distributors-again.html

Kendamu
08-28-2007, 12:47 AM
Anyone interested in what I think this means? :)
Well, if you don't take my sig too seriously, please tell. In all seriousness I do like what you have to say even if I don't always agree with it.

tinlunlau
08-28-2007, 03:05 AM
odd...i woulda thought Sony would have a hand in the Astroboy movie.

Courk
08-28-2007, 07:11 AM
Whoever changed the thread title amuses me greatly. :-)

Warhorse
08-28-2007, 08:04 PM
Some dark force compels me to learn more of the inner workings of Andrew's mind, either that or I was just distracted by the smiley face emoticon.:)


Personally, When I hear "contract renegotiation", it just appears to be who wants more money and/or how they can cut money out from the sequel.

How can they cut money from the sequel, easy, (though I honestly dont know how much they were paid, but IO doubt the celebrities in TMNT came forward to volunteer their voices because they are turtle fans) so I say cut the funding for celebrity voice overs.

ToTheNines
08-28-2007, 08:18 PM
How can they cut money from the sequel, easy, (though I honestly dont know how much they were paid, but IO doubt the celebrities in TMNT came forward to volunteer their voices because they are turtle fans) so I say cut the funding for celebrity voice overs.

Well we don't have to worry about Patrick Stweart, and Fishburne is pointless. But I loved the performances we got out of Gellar and Evans, I know some one else could easily do it, but still. And I really want Sunny Chiba and Ken Watanabe to be Shredder and/or Splinter.

Spitfire
08-29-2007, 01:17 AM
I doubt they paid much to have those people included. Especially Evans and Gellar who aren't very popular in Hollywood right now.

And there's not much budget to cut TMNT cost 30 mil to make wasn't it? That's barely anything. It banked 70 Mil plus whatever it makes in DVD and toy sales. I don't think they will cut much for the sequel.

Celebrity VA's don't get paid much extra, VA work is VA work. It's not like they paid Patrick Stewart and Laurence Fishburne a million dollars for their voice work. You get paid by a set minute in that line of work and I know for a fact Laurence Fishburne didn't get alot and he was the biggest name tagged onto the project.

Dragon Turtle
08-29-2007, 01:23 AM
it sounds more like its in a 'who is getting paid what', 'how much are we putting into the film money wise' stage of negotiations

the saving grace of this film, business wise, seems to be the fact that it is so cheap to make. hopefully that fact will continue to play in its favor

Considering how low TMNT's production budget was to begin with and that virtually all CGI sequels cost more then their previous movies, even Warner should expect to pay more, but they will at least try and keep the budget in the same range as the first movie.


How can they cut money from the sequel, easy, (though I honestly dont know how much they were paid, but IO doubt the celebrities in TMNT came forward to volunteer their voices because they are turtle fans) so I say cut the funding for celebrity voice overs.


This being the first major theatrical release for both Imagi and Kevin Monroe, there are probably many places in the technical and planning areas where cost can be cut down.

raphael_is_cool
08-29-2007, 06:42 AM
The celebrity voices are probably deemed as useful marketing tools as well. Considering interviews and TV spots can be made of them.

Not that the 2007 film had brilliant marketing or prominent celebrity roles in the first place.

Dragon Turtle
08-29-2007, 10:04 PM
The celebrity voices are probably deemed as useful marketing tools as well. Considering interviews and TV spots can be made of them.

Not that the 2007 film had brilliant marketing or prominent celebrity roles in the first place.




I haven't seen any real evidence that celebrity voice actors make a huge impact on the success of a movie, in fact, you can go back before the the mid 90's where big celebrity actors wouldn't be caught dead doing voice acting work, Disney's biggest success was their 2D movies that didn't have big name stars, just talented voice actors.

Rooish
08-29-2007, 10:26 PM
Warner is crap. Is there any chance they'll drop Warner and go with someone else?

Sage Ninja
08-30-2007, 12:30 AM
Disney's biggest success was their 2D movies that didn't have big name stars, just talented voice actors.

they also used very talented stage actors from Broadway, which was a smart idea they where so good!


I miss the beautifully animated 2D movies that Disney used to put out. I still think the Hunchback Of Notra Dame was one of the most beautiful movies they ever made. Then it went down hill from there with Hercules ugh :sick:


back about the Movie...yeah, I'm cynical now. I'm not confident that we are going to get a sequal out of this. Or if we do that budget cuts might be made and we won't get the same quality as this movie. :sick:

Roseangelo
08-30-2007, 12:48 AM
I'm not worried about budget cuts, I'm worried about the sequel not getting enough more money. Imagi probably worked cheap even for them on the first one; they will obviously want more. But I also think more needs to be budgeted so that more time can be spent making a longer movie.

The good thing is that development costs will be lower the second time around since they already have the majority of models and environments built.

The Shelf
08-30-2007, 02:06 PM
I'm not worried about budget cuts, I'm worried about the sequel not getting enough more money. Imagi probably worked cheap even for them on the first one; they will obviously want more. But I also think more needs to be budgeted so that more time can be spent making a longer movie.

I don't think budget had anything to do with the length of the movie. They cut scenes out specifically to reach the 1h 20m mark.

The good thing is that development costs will be lower the second time around since they already have the majority of models and environments built.

This isn't necessarily the case. If they decide to move the story out of New York, then there goes most of the reusable environments. And while Imagi would probably reuse the models from the first movie as a base, I'm certain they would spend plenty of time improving those models whether we think they need to or not. I'd certainly be happy if they just reused a lot of stuff from the first movie, but that's not the issue. They'll try to one-up themselves just out of principle and their own personal satisfaction.

In any case, I think the only way the budget will go down is if the movie goes straight to dvd which I really doubt will happen.

ToTheNines
08-30-2007, 03:00 PM
This isn't necessarily the case. If they decide to move the story out of New York,

That's unlikely.

raphael_is_cool
08-30-2007, 05:17 PM
I haven't seen any real evidence that celebrity voice actors make a huge impact on the success of a movie, in fact, you can go back before the the mid 90's where big celebrity actors wouldn't be caught dead doing voice acting work, Disney's biggest success was their 2D movies that didn't have big name stars, just talented voice actors.

Thing is, we're no longer in that era. I'm not saying having celebrities is necessarily a good thing, but that the potential for added publicity is obviously considered helpful.

I only ever saw TV spots or interviews with the big names on the project and that's obviously part of the marketing strategy Warner want to go with.

Kendamu
08-30-2007, 05:25 PM
Hopefully in the sequel the fight scenes can go much further beyond what they were in TMNT. I mean, c'mon, I can find more violence on TV-Y7 programming on basic cable.

ToTheNines
08-30-2007, 05:27 PM
It's not a big deal. You obviously don't want an entire cast of celbrities because you don't want half the budget going to that. And it is good to have a few names attached to any film, and if they do a great job (as Chris Evans, S.M. Gellar, and Laurence Fishburne did) then even better.

ToTheNines
08-30-2007, 05:30 PM
Hopefully in the sequel the fight scenes can go much further beyond what they were in TMNT. I mean, c'mon, I can find more violence on TV-Y7 programming on basic cable.

Like what?

Kendamu
08-30-2007, 06:17 PM
The entire first 26 episodes of Naruto show as a good example of things that should've been allowed in TMNT... Shuriken that you actually get to see leave a person's hand, fly through the air, and stick into someone else... or maybe the whole thing of shillouette of one of the main characters (apparently) being sliced into 6 pieces... or a 12-year-old boy getting throwing needles put into his throat... or the main villain, after being stabbed multiple times and no longer having the use of his arms, charging through a crowd of armed men with a knife in his teeth and using it to kill his ex-boss.

Okay... so, I just looked it up and it was TV-PG. My point still stands, though, as Dragonball Z was TV-Y7 and has more death in it than TMNT and Naruto combined.

I don't necessarily want death... but I felt kind of gypped that the Foot battle outside of Winters Tower lasted a very short amount and didn't really give me the "TMNT vs. cannon fodder" fight I was looking for. If basic cable kid shows can kill people and have characters fight eachother for episodes on end then the TMNT should be allowed to fight without so much crap censorship.

Scandia
08-30-2007, 06:21 PM
I know who I want to see in a sequel:

Miyamoto Usagi and/or Leatherhead

At least one of the two would be fine. I do not know if Stan Sakai would allow Usagi to appear in a movie. But it would ROCK to see any of them on screen.

ToTheNines
08-30-2007, 07:38 PM
Okay... so, I just looked it up and it was TV-PG. My point still stands, though, as Dragonball Z was TV-Y7 and has more death in it than TMNT and Naruto combined.


But when someone died they just went to the clouds with some stupid little halo and hoped for the dragon to bring them back.

And the only example you really used was Naruto...

Kendamu
08-30-2007, 07:43 PM
But the actual violence that brought death to their bodies still happened. My Dragonball example still stands.

Oh, and do I need more than just Naruto? It's a children's show about Ninjas that has more Ninja action than a TMNT movie that was geared towards kids and adults alike. Do you see nothing wrong with that idea?

ToTheNines
08-30-2007, 08:32 PM
But the actual violence that brought death to their bodies still happened. My Dragonball example still stands.

Ok, you're right.


Oh, and do I need more than just Naruto? It's a children's show about Ninjas that has more Ninja action than a TMNT movie that was geared towards kids and adults alike. Do you see nothing wrong with that idea?

You're right again, but what I meant was that you only gave one example. I guess Avatar is more violent, but that's only 2.

Dragon Turtle
08-30-2007, 11:04 PM
I don't think budget had anything to do with the length of the movie. They cut scenes out specifically to reach the 1h 20m mark.


Even though there is a certain unwritten rule that animated movies need to be in the 75-90 minute range(a rule I absolutely hate), I've read several interviews from the producers stating they were not under any specific order to come in under 80 minutes. If anything, the short length of the movie could probably be contributed to the short 18 month production time(they were still working the movie several weeks before its release), in which you also have to factor in language and distance barriers, as well as a certain amount of poor planning (you usually don't see deleted scenes for an animated movie as far along in the developement process as the ones you see on the TMNT dvd).




This isn't necessarily the case. If they decide to move the story out of New York, then there goes most of the reusable environments. And while Imagi would probably reuse the models from the first movie as a base, I'm certain they would spend plenty of time improving those models whether we think they need to or not. I'd certainly be happy if they just reused a lot of stuff from the first movie, but that's not the issue. They'll try to one-up themselves just out of principle and their own personal satisfaction.


While Monroe has stated he wants to do a more down to Earth sequel, possibly in tha vain of "City of War", that may take place entirely in New York, he has also express some dissapointment about the city environments. Monroe had originally wanted the environments to be more complex with the turtles going between and around buildings( just like the first trailer), but due to time and money constraints this didn't happen, also, Monroe may want a more authentic New York city, as only a few parts of New York were actually used in the movie.


Other then the turtles and Splinter, we may have seen the last of the human character designs, as they were the most critized aspect of the animation.




I don't necessarily want death... but I felt kind of gypped that the Foot battle outside of Winters Tower lasted a very short amount and didn't really give me the "TMNT vs. cannon fodder" fight I was looking for. If basic cable kid shows can kill people and have characters fight eachother for episodes on end then the TMNT should be allowed to fight without so much crap censorship.


Animated movies will always face tighter scrutiny then animated tv shows, even the violence in the TMNT 2k3 cartoon would probably require a PG-13 rating, the only way to see true animated turtle fighting action is in PG-13 movie.

Sage Ninja
08-31-2007, 12:01 AM
While Monroe has stated he wants to do a more down to Earth sequel, possibly in tha vain of "City of War", that may take place entirely in New York, he has also express some dissapointment about the city environments. Monroe had originally wanted the environments to be more complex with the turtles going between and around buildings( just like the first trailer), but due to time and money constraints this didn't happen, also, Monroe may want a more authentic New York city, as only a few parts of New York were actually used in the movie.

Good. I want more urban based story lines that take place in the New York City with more "real" situation. I really can't stand the sci-fi crap that filters into the TMNT's format and supriced as heck that given Laird's love of sci-fi stories that this previous movie wasn't a off the wall outer space adventure :dead:. And I really wished we could have seen more of the turtles doing more complex manurvering between and around the buildings. I thought the first teaser trailer with them doing that run over the roof tops was beautiful and I admit I was mildly disappointed that there wasn't maore of that. :(

Animated movies will always face tighter scrutiny then animated tv shows, even the violence in the TMNT 2k3 cartoon would probably require a PG-13 rating, the only way to see true animated turtle fighting action is in PG-13 movie.

Really? I'm supriced, I thought the exact oppisite would be the case. I would have thought that a movie would have more freedom to be more intence with the violence than a cartoon on tv would, since a TV show is more acceciable to any one who turns on the tv. But a Movie is not as easily accessiable to just any one because you have to go through more trouble to view it by going out of your hiuse to the theators and paying for a ticket and what not. SO I figured that a movie would have more lee way when it comes to violence because its in a more controlled on what audiances see it. You know what I'm saying?

Dragon Turtle
08-31-2007, 02:06 AM
Really? I'm supriced, I thought the exact oppisite would be the case. I would have thought that a movie would have more freedom to be more intence with the violence than a cartoon on tv would, since a TV show is more acceciable to any one who turns on the tv. But a Movie is not as easily accessiable to just any one because you have to go through more trouble to view it by going out of your hiuse to the theators and paying for a ticket and what not. SO I figured that a movie would have more lee way when it comes to violence because its in a more controlled on what audiances see it. You know what I'm saying?


And that my friend is the enigma of the secretive arbitrary standards of the MPAA ratings board, who still have antiquated views on movie animation, that all animated movies are strictly for children. But what is really frustrating is their inconsistency when it comes to certain movies. It feels like a well known property like TMNT is under tighter scrutiny then other PG films. While the MPAA may have problems with TMNT's weapons, I've seen broken necks, people getting shot, stab, sucked into airplane engines, blown up, and flowing blood in other PG movies.

And if that wasn't bad enough, you have people like this guy clouding up the PG/PG-13 waters.

http://movies.zap2it.com/movies/movies/reviews/text/0,1259,---29073,00.html

The Shelf
08-31-2007, 09:32 AM
Wow, I wonder what that guy thought of The Incredibles. I thought it was more violent than TMNT and was actually kind of surprised that it was only PG.

Sage Ninja
08-31-2007, 11:58 AM
And if that wasn't bad enough, you have people like this guy clouding up the PG/PG-13 waters.

http://movies.zap2it.com/movies/movies/reviews/text/0,1259,---29073,00.html

well I'm disgusted :evil: that is bull ****. Amybe the TMNT movie should went the live actione route in stead of CGI animation so we wouldn't have to put up with these damn animation restrictions. God, America is so damn conservertive when it comes to animation products. This Cartoons are just for kidds crap has got to go!

xmen510
08-31-2007, 12:08 PM
That reviewer obviously has no clue to the meaning behind the ratings system. He can't even tell the difference between a G and PG rating. He makes it come off as though it was a G rated movie, chich it wasn't. It was PG. Since he cannot tell the difference in the ratings then he should not be reviewing movies in any official capacity.

Avatar Yuffie
08-31-2007, 08:47 PM
You're right again, but what I meant was that you only gave one example. I guess Avatar is more violent, but that's only 2.

Avatar is kind of clever in the violence department (a genocide, a minor character dies helping the main character, main character gets harmed by bad guy), actually... it shows that it can be done.

Splinter's Iroonna
09-02-2007, 01:16 PM
http://the-5th-turtle.blogspot.com/

If I posted something posted somewhere else, my apologies.

But damn, WB just may rise in my good graces.

MoreCowbell5263
09-02-2007, 08:31 PM
I figured the movie would be nominated because some really weird animated movies get nominated each year, why not TMNT? That would be great if it won, but it has to go up against what, Ratatouille? Surfs Up? Simpsons?

Masked Ninja
09-02-2007, 10:37 PM
Just getting a nomination would be significant... and would probably help the sequel cause a lot. I would say it stands no chance to win against Ratatouille and its ilk, but TMNT does have a lot going for it. So the monster part of the plot was dumb, as well as many of the one-liners... from a technical standpoint, it was awesome. Great animation, incredible textures, really nice cinematography and lighting... I think that by itself is worth at least a nomination.

Splinter's Iroonna
09-02-2007, 11:28 PM
There are MANY moments when the animation feels "real"-- case in point, when Raph leaves Casey's and April's and climbs the fire escape-- the subtle movements of him climbing the ladder were so damn real!

And the breakfast scene, where he shrugs and makes that face while Leo is getting all pissy--

I could go on and on, but honestly, let's face it-- that entire fight on the roof, both before Leo knew it was Raph as well as Afterwards-- OMG!!!


Go Imagi!!!

Raph's Girl
09-03-2007, 12:00 AM
Wow...even being nominated is like a major honour for any film. I hope this happens cuz I wanna see what scene they choose (probably the Raph/Leo fight scene). But the recognition of a nomination would definatly be a HUGE push for a sequel.

The first film was nominated for Best Costumes and Best Fantasy Film at the 1991 Saturn Awards, as well as the Most Entertaining Family Youth Motion Picture - Drama at the Young Artist Awards.

iris
09-12-2007, 08:25 AM
Just getting a nomination would be significant... and would probably help the sequel cause a lot. I would say it stands no chance to win against Ratatouille and its ilk, but TMNT does have a lot going for it. So the monster part of the plot was dumb, as well as many of the one-liners... from a technical standpoint, it was awesome. Great animation, incredible textures, really nice cinematography and lighting... I think that by itself is worth at least a nomination.
Don't need an Oscar nom to see how beautiful this movie was, but that would certainly clinch a sequel.

Spitfire
09-12-2007, 09:26 AM
Turtles story focused on the family aspect of things. and out of every family movie I've seen it captured that the best. The emotion behind it was great. I really felt like I was watching a shattered brotherhood rebuild itself.

syd
09-12-2007, 09:55 AM
man,seriously,i will not accept a withdraw of the sequal.>[
that's insane,how can it be possible to happen?that's no logic!
surely they r going on,i just kno it!*think loud*

Courk
09-12-2007, 07:02 PM
I'd be happy with a nomination. I wish there were more categories for animated movies. Can they be nominated for things like best special effects?

MoreCowbell5263
09-15-2007, 03:39 PM
They have like Cinematography awards, but that usually goes to special effects in live-action movies, but it also has to deal with setting and stuff. Animated movies aren't nominated for those.

Courk
09-15-2007, 11:50 PM
That doesn't seem very fair. Animators are almost overlooked since Best Animated Film will surely go to the one with the best story, which isn't typically handled by the animators.

It might just be me, but it seems like more animated movies have been coming out. Perhaps some day they'll have more awards they can win.

Splinter's Iroonna
09-16-2007, 10:53 AM
Well, as far as I'm concerned, "Best Animated Film" is a ghetto category, a segregation-type of award that the Acadamy created to make sure that no other animated film would EVER be nominated for Best Picture-- "Beauty and the Beast" didn't make some powers-that-be happy.

And NOTHING that has won since then is in the same category as "Beauty and the Beast"-- but that is just my opinion.

Roseangelo
09-16-2007, 01:43 PM
Well, as far as I'm concerned, "Best Animated Film" is a ghetto category, a segregation-type of award that the Acadamy created to make sure that no other animated film would EVER be nominated for Best Picture-- "Beauty and the Beast" didn't make some powers-that-be happy.

The category was created the year the first Shrek movie came out because they wanted to give an award to Shrek, but they didn't want to deal with it in the overall Best Feature category.

Masked Ninja
09-16-2007, 06:30 PM
Well, as far as I'm concerned, "Best Animated Film" is a ghetto category, a segregation-type of award that the Acadamy created to make sure that no other animated film would EVER be nominated for Best Picture-- "Beauty and the Beast" didn't make some powers-that-be happy.

And NOTHING that has won since then is in the same category as "Beauty and the Beast"-- but that is just my opinion.It's like a double-edged sword. On one hand, something animated gets recognized every year, but you're right... it pretty much pigeonholes all animated films to that category even if they deserve to take it all. And that's really lame.

Dragon Turtle
09-16-2007, 10:23 PM
Well, as far as I'm concerned, "Best Animated Film" is a ghetto category, a segregation-type of award that the Acadamy created to make sure that no other animated film would EVER be nominated for Best Picture-- "Beauty and the Beast" didn't make some powers-that-be happy.

And NOTHING that has won since then is in the same category as "Beauty and the Beast"-- but that is just my opinion.



There have been rumblings that Disney may try and get "Ratatouille" nominated for best picture, which would be a major feather in the cap for
the folks at PIXAR and a nice bit of ammunition for them in their little PIXAR/Disney feud.

Splinter's Iroonna
10-16-2007, 08:34 PM
*streaks through thread, spamming as she goes....*


Oh, yeah, swiped from Murphy's blog...


Both the owner and the CEO of Imagi (the TMNT movie animation studio) will be visiting us from Hong Kong for a day of meetings next week. Surely this is a good sign...?

a_big_apple
10-16-2007, 11:59 PM
Yeah, when I saw that this morning I was really excited! I hope we know something concrete soon.

Drtooth
10-17-2007, 01:56 PM
There have been rumblings that Disney may try and get "Ratatouille" nominated for best picture, which would be a major feather in the cap for
the folks at PIXAR and a nice bit of ammunition for them in their little PIXAR/Disney feud.

Why would they have a Disney/Pixar fued? They're OWNED by Disney with the stipulation that John lassiter gets control of their traditional animation department.

Rooish
10-17-2007, 02:10 PM
Was Ratatouille even that good? I'd like to see a more epic movie win the "Best Animated Film" category. Not that TMNT would ever win. :(

TMNT
10-17-2007, 02:36 PM
I hope they get nominated and get recognition at least. I'd love to have the Leo/Raph fight play as their clip. But another reason I'd love to see TMNT nominated is because then our boys in green can show up on Oscar night. If you've watched the Oscars in the past years (I don't know exactly when this trend started), they have the "cast" of the animated films in attendence. I remember one year, the penguins from Happy Feet and the kids from Monster House were there. It was a cool idea. So if nominated the turtles can finally hit the Oscars (a nice throwback to a certain Barbara Walters interview).

Tinuvielsdreams
10-17-2007, 06:25 PM
I know what you mean about the characters being in the audience that was cool to see all the penguins in their seats.
I don't see why they wouldn't get nominated, they definitely have what it takes as far as animation goes the look was polished, the effects like the rain were very good, the scores and the voice acting all good.
It is definitely a contender.
The only 2007 movie I worry about taking all could be Beowulf...?

Cure
10-17-2007, 06:45 PM
I know what you mean about the characters being in the audience that was cool to see all the penguins in their seats.
I don't see why they wouldn't get nominated, they definitely have what it takes as far as animation goes the look was polished, the effects like the rain were very good, the scores and the voice acting all good.
It is definitely a contender.
The only 2007 movie I worry about taking all could be Beowulf...?

The previews for that movie pisses me off to no extent. Why have an animated movie with the characters look EXACTLY LIKE THE F*CKING ACTORS?! It's so goddamned pointless.

Tinuvielsdreams
10-17-2007, 06:48 PM
It's basically how they did Polar express, it's rotoscoping. But they do count it as animation. Personally I think there should be a line of separation but Animation is general is such a small category :(
If it were me I would put movies that were hand animated in there and Turtles would do rather well. That studio deserves it too.
Sony is doing Beowulf and of course it's easier for those big name studios to be recognized but Imagi absolutely earned it with their hard work

Masked Ninja
10-17-2007, 07:10 PM
I hope they get nominated and get recognition at least. I'd love to have the Leo/Raph fight play as their clip. But another reason I'd love to see TMNT nominated is because then our boys in green can show up on Oscar night. If you've watched the Oscars in the past years (I don't know exactly when this trend started), they have the "cast" of the animated films in attendence. I remember one year, the penguins from Happy Feet and the kids from Monster House were there. It was a cool idea. So if nominated the turtles can finally hit the Oscars (a nice throwback to a certain Barbara Walters interview).I remember that - it was the first year there was an Animated Film category, when Shrek beat Monsters, Inc. So they had winning/losing animations prepared ahead of time. I loved the "losing" animation for Mike and Sulley... they had these big fake grins and you could tell by their entire posture that they were only clapping because if was polite. X)

Darnit, it'd be awesome to see the Turtles at the Oscars... fiddling with ties or something, haha... and Mikey would be eating the attention all up.

As far as the Oscars go, it's all political, sadly. I strongly suspect that's part of why Happy Feet won, with its "green" agenda. So the question is, would the Powers That Be consider TMNT a "film" rather than a "popcorn movie" and let it get the nomination? Doubt it. I've browsed a few animation communities and TMNT isn't even on their radar in Oscar predictions.

Ratatouille will definitely get nominated, and I would love to see it win, even - it was extremely artsy and beautiful (the ANIMATION asdlfkdjfk), and perhaps not simple entertainment (I remember the smallest kids in my showing getting kind of restless... probably because the movie wasn't aimed specifically at holding their attention).

Surf's Up also has a definite chance - my animation buddies are urging me to watch it, and I do think it looks pretty good just from what I've seen.

Meet the Robinsons probably has a decent shot because of Disney's name recognition, though I only ever heard mixed reviews for it.

TMNT... gah, if that video game monster plot had been cleaned up enough, who knows where this could be now? I don't know if it will be taken seriously enough. Leo vs. Raph in the rain was a beautiful centerpiece (one that a classmate of mine even admitted he got a little choked up during) but it seems that you could only enjoy it if you were willing to care about the Turtles as characters. I just don't see a lot of these people, who consider themselves Experts in Film, allowing themselves to invest as much in characters that they probably only remember being on some goofy little kid show in the '80s. Maybe I don't give them enough credit, but my mental image is of some guy in his early 50s in a nice suit, slouched in his chair, cursing the fact that he was the one who drew the short straw and had to watch this retarded kiddie movie. Never mind that there is a bit of depth there, if you're willing to invest a little.

I think TMNT does deserve the nom. Win, probably not, but definitely the nomination.

And Beowulf... argh. I agree that they should at least take advantage of the medium and not make it look exactly like the actors. What an expensive waste. And their photorealistic rigging is still not quite right, though loads better than Polar Express. And this is all ignoring whether the script/acting is even good.

Tinuvielsdreams
10-17-2007, 07:30 PM
I remember that - it was the first year there was an Animated Film category, when Shrek beat Monsters, Inc. So they had winning/losing animations prepared ahead of time. I loved the "losing" animation for Mike and Sulley... they had these big fake grins and you could tell by their entire posture that they were only clapping because if was polite. X)

Darnit, it'd be awesome to see the Turtles at the Oscars... fiddling with ties or something, haha... and Mikey would be eating the attention all up.

As far as the Oscars go, it's all political, sadly. I strongly suspect that's part of why Happy Feet won, with its "green" agenda. So the question is, would the Powers That Be consider TMNT a "film" rather than a "popcorn movie" and let it get the nomination? Doubt it. I've browsed a few animation communities and TMNT isn't even on their radar in Oscar predictions.

Ratatouille will definitely get nominated, and I would love to see it win, even - it was extremely artsy and beautiful (the ANIMATION asdlfkdjfk), and perhaps not simple entertainment (I remember the smallest kids in my showing getting kind of restless... probably because the movie wasn't aimed specifically at holding their attention).

Surf's Up also has a definite chance - my animation buddies are urging me to watch it, and I do think it looks pretty good just from what I've seen.

Meet the Robinsons probably has a decent shot because of Disney's name recognition, though I only ever heard mixed reviews for it.

TMNT... gah, if that video game monster plot had been cleaned up enough, who knows where this could be now? I don't know if it will be taken seriously enough. Leo vs. Raph in the rain was a beautiful centerpiece (one that a classmate of mine even admitted he got a little choked up during) but it seems that you could only enjoy it if you were willing to care about the Turtles as characters. I just don't see a lot of these people, who consider themselves Experts in Film, allowing themselves to invest as much in characters that they probably only remember being on some goofy little kid show in the '80s. Maybe I don't give them enough credit, but my mental image is of some guy in his early 50s in a nice suit, slouched in his chair, cursing the fact that he was the one who drew the short straw and had to watch this retarded kiddie movie. Never mind that there is a bit of depth there, if you're willing to invest a little.

I think TMNT does deserve the nom. Win, probably not, but definitely the nomination.

And Beowulf... argh. I agree that they should at least take advantage of the medium and not make it look exactly like the actors. What an expensive waste. And their photorealistic rigging is still not quite right, though loads better than Polar Express. And this is all ignoring whether the script/acting is even good.


I agree with you masked Ninja TMNT probably won't be given a fair chance and that really stinks. Let's hope someone out their will say hey if we are going to put Meet the Robinsons in their then we should put the TMNT movie that was out at the same time. Tmnt is such a strong film especially visually and nominating a movie just because of who backs it *cough* Disney *cough* isn't fair although I also did not see MTR so I can't say for sure

You do have to care about the characters to understand The Raph/ Leo roof scene to the degree it deserves. but there is such a beautiful quality to that scene the light and the rain and the camera moves all work together so nicely it just deserves some notoriety

I have a friend who worked on Surf's up and now is working on Beowulf. I haven't talked to her in awhile but I am very curious to see how her experience is going. I wonder which one she feels more strongly about since they are so drastically different

ToTheNines
10-17-2007, 07:38 PM
I hated polar express... I normally love watching a corny Christmas movie during the holidays, but that was baaaad.

Dragon Turtle
10-17-2007, 10:10 PM
Why would they have a Disney/Pixar fued? They're OWNED by Disney with the stipulation that John lassiter gets control of their traditional animation department.

By "Disney", I should have been more clear by saying those at Disney involved in their traditional animation department (who you can understand not liking the Pixar takeover), not the Disney execs. There are a quite a few people at Disney who would love to see John Lassiter and Pixar fall on their faces.




Was Ratatouille even that good? I'd like to see a more epic movie win the "Best Animated Film" category. Not that TMNT would ever win. :(

It was OK, better then "Cars", with the money, talent, and resources at Pixar's disposal, "Ratatouille" possessed the typical high polish of a Pixar film, and will no doubt be the darling of the mainstrem critics, but personally I wasn't wowed by it. A good solid film, but nothing special.


Assuming there are only three possible nominations available for "Best Animated Film", two of the three slots are guaranteed to go to, "Ratatouille" and "The Simpsons Movie".


TMNT will need some fans amongst the voters to vote it number one, or be eliminated outright, looking at the rest of the competition that may not be too difficult.


Meet the Robinsons:

Ignoring the fact that it was fairly average, it's a Disney movie, and could you imagine if it actally beat out "Ratatouille"? The folks at Pixar would throw a fit, there is only room for one Disney/Pixar movie at the Oscars, and that's "Ratatouille".


Shrek The Third:

It will be interesting to see how hard Dreamworks campaigns for this, critics and fans were not to kind to it, and will most likely not win if nominated, so with sequels and spinoffs already in the works, why incur any negative publicity for the franchise?


Surf's Up:

A nice solid movie, nothing more, outside of the penguins and Shia LaBeouf, not very memorable.


Bee Movie:

Not that impressed with the trailers, this years "Over the Hedge" meh, Jerry Seinfield fans will like it.


Beowulf:

I was somewhat interested in this movie (a big budget PG-13 animated movie), but the trailers have been underwhelming, it will also have to overcome the motion capture creep out factor.

Rooish
10-17-2007, 10:41 PM
Beowulf shouldn't even count as an animated feature. It's animators trying to draw as close to reality as possible. An animated feature should require imagination.

I wish that TMNT had emotionally affected more people. Then it would deserve "Best Animated Feature." But it doesn't, because it had that retarded script and monster plot. And what was the point of Karai? Damn ... effing ... WB.

If The Simpsons movie wins, I'm not going to respect the Oscars anymore. Maybe I shouldn't anyway ... they don't mean anything. They're just someone's opinion, or a political move. Why should we trust the Oscars more than our individual judgments?

Dragon Turtle
10-18-2007, 12:16 AM
Beowulf shouldn't even count as an animated feature. It's animators trying to draw as close to reality as possible. An animated feature should require imagination.

I don't see anything wrong with animators going for realism in their movies, not every animated film needs to belong to the "squash and stretch" school of animation. The problem with this type of animation is that is just doesn't come close to matching real life actors, and CGI already has the stigma of being too artificial.



I wish that TMNT had emotionally affected more people. Then it would deserve "Best Animated Feature." But it doesn't, because it had that retarded script and monster plot. And what was the point of Karai? Damn ... effing ... WB.

You can blame WB for many miscues involving TMNT, but scripting and plotting were the responsibility of Kevin Monroe. I thought the script was fine (some the jokes were flat), not the greatest or snappiest dialog but it got the job done, the monster plot was so underdeveloped that it really wasn't of much consequence.



Why should we trust the Oscars more than our individual judgments?

You shouldn't.:)

gobo
10-18-2007, 06:52 PM
I just don't see a lot of these people, who consider themselves Experts in Film, allowing themselves to invest as much in characters that they probably only remember being on some goofy little kid show in the '80s. Maybe I don't give them enough credit, but my mental image is of some guy in his early 50s in a nice suit, slouched in his chair, cursing the fact that he was the one who drew the short straw and had to watch this retarded kiddie movie.
Sounds like you give them too much credit. For the most part, being an expert is all about presentation. If you act sure of yourself, that's enough to make most people think you're an expert.

Splinter's Iroonna
10-24-2007, 01:38 PM
The latest post at Mr. Murphy's blog:

Executives from Imagi have just arrived to discuss the various aspects of the issues surrounding whether or not there will be a sequel to the TMNT film. Not sure if this will be resolved today but...

If this works out, then I'm gonna declare today a TMNT holiday.

Andrew NDB
10-24-2007, 04:00 PM
The latest post at Mr. Murphy's blog:



If this works out, then I'm gonna declare today a TMNT holiday.

Only if you mean a "Black Christmas." :)

Magneto
10-24-2007, 04:09 PM
If the Transporter can get a sequel, then I dont know why TMNT wouldnt be able to.

xmen510
10-24-2007, 06:05 PM
Thats true. The Transporter made half of what TMNT did and just barely became profittable in theatre. TMNT made it's money back and then another half as well. In fact it is now over 95.5 million worldwide which is pretty good in my book since it only cost 34 to begin with.

Splinter's Iroonna
10-24-2007, 06:26 PM
Only if you mean a "Black Christmas." :)

http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y201/cynlee/Kiss-My-Ass-in-Gaelic-Panties_779B2.jpg

Andrew NDB
10-24-2007, 11:34 PM
You can blame WB for many miscues involving TMNT, but scripting and plotting were the responsibility of Kevin Monroe. I thought the script was fine (some the jokes were flat), not the greatest or snappiest dialog but it got the job done, the monster plot was so underdeveloped that it really wasn't of much consequence.

You can blame WB, actually. At the end of the day they still needed him to sell toys and not offend anyone in any country of any age, and with his limited pull at no point could he likely ever say, "I've got a vision for the movie, I'm going to do it my way and that's it."

If left entirely to his own devices I have no doubt Munroe would have turned in a balls-out TMNT film that people -- yes, the people outside of our little bubble of TMNT fandom -- would still be talking about today. That's the tragedy of it.

Magneto
10-25-2007, 12:11 AM
^ Theres ALOT of truth in that statement. A PG-13 TMNT flick under Munroe's own devices, would have very likely been a much more satisfying flick for those who are just casual fans of TMNT in general than what we ultimately recieved. Which was very good, and a great way to bring in new fans, but not quite what might have been I'm afraid.

Dragon Turtle
10-25-2007, 01:08 AM
You can blame WB, actually. At the end of the day they still needed him to sell toys and not offend anyone in any country of any age, and with his limited pull at no point could he likely ever say, "I've got a vision for the movie, I'm going to do it my way and that's it."

If left entirely to his own devices I have no doubt Munroe would have turned in a balls-out TMNT film that people -- yes, the people outside of our little bubble of TMNT fandom -- would still be talking about today. That's the tragedy of it.


I will never pass full judgement on Kevin Monroe's writing abilities without seeing the full original script for TMNT, obviously the PG rating was a hindrance to the creative process (Max Winter's death being one thing that was probably changed from the original script), but Monroe knew where the lines were drawn when going into the project, also from reading his interviews, there didn't seemed to be alot of arm twisting from the powers that be, at WB, Playmates, or even Peter Laird himself. I personally found some definite weaknesses in the scripting and plot, it's also not a good thing to have nearly an hour's worth of deleted scenes laying about, which is either due to poor planning or Imagi's "Jiffy Lube" approach to animation, or a little of both.


Don't get me wrong though, I like Kevin Monroe, given my limited knowledge of the animation industry, I don't believe many people fully appreciate the job Mr. Monroe did on the movie, virtually everything about the production of this movie (first time director/animation studio, small budget, short development time, etc) screamed disaster, if and when a sequel is announced, I believe it would be a mistake not to bring Monroe back as director.



^ Theres ALOT of truth in that statement. A PG-13 TMNT flick under Munroe's own devices, would have very likely been a much more satisfying flick for those who are just casual fans of TMNT in general than what we ultimately recieved. Which was very good, and a great way to bring in new fans, but not quite what might have been I'm afraid.

As far as I'm concerned, there is no legitimate reason a sequel to TMNT should be anything less then PG-13, especially if they want the movie to turn a major profit.

Andrew NDB
10-25-2007, 02:07 AM
I will never pass full judgement on Kevin Monroe's writing abilities without seeing the full original script for TMNT, obviously the PG rating was a hindrance to the creative process

Reading the original script wouldn't really matter much, though, since it's already public knowledge he went into it from the gate knowing that WB already contractually obligated him/Imagi to deliver a PG-rated TMNT film, would it?

As far as I'm concerned, there is no legitimate reason a sequel to TMNT should be anything less then PG-13, especially if they want the movie to turn a major profit.

There's every reason, if you're in a boardroom of WB execs agreeing to fund these things (particularly for properties they don't own and have to pay royalties out to). Bring in the kiddies, the tweens, the toddlers, emasculate the TMNT enough that parents aren't scared to bring their little ones with them to see something with "ninja" turtles.

Munroe has already said -- on this board, no less -- that in any sequel (whether or not there is any hope for one is another matter) he doesn't see it as very likely that they can push for PG-13 in any sequel that develops.

I know... a movie about ninja teenagers... actually... marketed for teenagers, at the very least. Apparently that's just too scary for the suits. Need that toddler cash, for all the good that's done them.

Ramboraph4life aka Matt
10-25-2007, 03:47 AM
This discussion made me remember something from the commentary track Kevin Munroe did for TMNT.

Didn't he at one point in the commentary say he had an idea for an ending where Raphael died??

And something with bringing him being brought back with a device the bad guys were wearing, something like that? I know I heard it on the track, but I think he said that Peter Laird quickly shot that one down.

Too bad...I could imagine Raph taking a shot for Leo...kinda would have brought that Leo/Raph subplot to a more satisfying conclusion (Raph's retribution, that type of thing). Maybe that's just me though.

Spitfire
10-25-2007, 04:10 AM
Laird doesn't like good ideas, he likes ones only he comes up with. And we all know what kind of ideas those are...

Sage Ninja
10-25-2007, 01:12 PM
And something with bringing him being brought back with a device the bad guys were wearing, something like that? I know I heard it on the track, but I think he said that Peter Laird quickly shot that one down.

I'm glad Laird turned that one down because any of the turtles dieing sucks

Dragon Turtle
10-25-2007, 03:10 PM
Reading the original script wouldn't really matter much, though, since it's already public knowledge he went into it from the gate knowing that WB already contractually obligated him/Imagi to deliver a PG-rated TMNT film, would it?



In terms of violence and mood? no, I wouldn't say there would have been a great amount of difference, even though Monroe has said the original cut of the movie was darker, he wouldn't have wasted his time writing in alot of things he knew would eventually get cut, he and the rest of the staff were still worried that the final cut of the movie would end up with a PG-13 rating, and were greatly relieved when it wasn't.

What the original script offers is a better look into the ideas that did or didn't make it into the final cut and how well they were executed. One instance would be the handling of the Max Winters character (as mentioned by Dan Berger in an interview at your site), the monsters, as well as the characters of April and Casey(who played a more major role in the story), there can be no denying that there were some serious compromises to the original story, if the original script was over two hours long and the film ended up with a runtime slightly over 75 minutes.




There's every reason, if you're in a boardroom of WB execs agreeing to fund these things (particularly for properties they don't own and have to pay royalties out to). Bring in the kiddies, the tweens, the toddlers, emasculate the TMNT enough that parents aren't scared to bring their little ones with them to see something with "ninja" turtles.

Munroe has already said -- on this board, no less -- that in any sequel (whether or not there is any hope for one is another matter) he doesn't see it as very likely that they can push for PG-13 in any sequel that develops.

I know... a movie about ninja teenagers... actually... marketed for teenagers, at the very least. Apparently that's just too scary for the suits. Need that toddler cash, for all the good that's done them.

Which is just backwards and outdated thinking on their part, the reality is kids under the age of 13 still go and see movies that are rated PG-13, I can guarantee you that PG-13 movies like Spider-Man 3, Harry Potter, and Transformers made more then 94 million in boxoffice from just the 13 and under crowd alone, I won't go into the amount of merchandise associated with these movies aimed directly at children under the age of 7. Making TMNT a PG-13 franchise will not lose them the kid market, but keeping them PG only hurts them by taking away the only hook the franchise may have in bringing in older casual movie goers, action.

Magneto
10-25-2007, 04:45 PM
The idea that WB feels that the TMNT should remain PG is a very interesting one, considering that there are films under the PG-13 rating that has been very profitable, and for a good number of years now. Pirates, Batman, X-Men, Spider-Man, Harry Potter, most kids love these franchises, and their films have consistantly remained on a PG-13 level. I'm not exactly sure why WB believes PG is more of an asset, than a hinderance (which it honestly is) but that's studio thinking for you I suppose.

If the sequel is given the greenlight, and Munroe does indeed return (which he should), I would hope he can make the argument that this series, in order to reach it's full potential just like the original 1990 flick, should have the right and option to go PG-13 if necessary. Because in 1990, TMNT was making HUGE bank as a kids franchise, and wouldnt you know it. They were able to handle a PG-13 flick. I don't see it being any different for 2008/2009/2010 either.

Roseangelo
10-25-2007, 06:34 PM
Because in 1990, TMNT was making HUGE bank as a kids franchise, and wouldnt you know it. They were able to handle a PG-13 flick.

Umm.. ALL of the TMNT films are rated PG, including the very first one.

Fledermaus
10-25-2007, 07:48 PM
Umm.. ALL of the TMNT films are rated PG, including the very first one.

I thought the first one was unrated. :-?

Magneto
10-25-2007, 10:23 PM
Umm.. ALL of the TMNT films are rated PG, including the very first one.

Good grief, and here I was thinking it was definately a PG-13 film. :oops: :lol:

Splinter's Iroonna
10-25-2007, 11:08 PM
Not that anyone cares, but it's all down to distribution and marketing at this point-- Imagi wants a better deal than they got with the first and who can blame them?

Anyway, despite the naysayers and the armchair pundits, the sequel will happen.


Anyway, you can read briefly about it at Mr. M.'s blog.

Good weekend, everyone!

Andrew NDB
10-25-2007, 11:26 PM
Umm.. ALL of the TMNT films are rated PG, including the very first one.

While true, by no stretch of the imagination it would receive a PG-13 today. Even the original PG-rated Superman movie has been reclassified as PG-13 by the MPAA on the recent DVD re-release... and it doesn't even feature blood, kicks to the head (which is an instant R today alone, I think), or children smoking in it.

Spitfire
10-25-2007, 11:46 PM
I understand what your saying but until you own a movie studio and are willing to fund a movie then quit complaining. They did what they could with the budget they had and the limitations. They weren't allowed to go PG-13, and couldn't afford to do anything but CGI.

So pick one, no TMNT movie, or a lack luster TMNT movie. The movie saved the franchise rather you liked it or not. I don't think it's that great but it got the show another season.

Roseangelo
10-25-2007, 11:49 PM
While true, by no stretch of the imagination it would receive a PG-13 today. Even the original PG-rated Superman movie has been reclassified as PG-13 by the MPAA on the recent DVD re-release... and it doesn't even feature blood, kicks to the head (which is an instant R today alone, I think), or children smoking in it.

PG-13 didn't exist when Superman was first released.

Andrew NDB
10-26-2007, 12:23 AM
I understand what your saying but until you own a movie studio and are willing to fund a movie then quit complaining. They did what they could with the budget they had and the limitations. They weren't allowed to go PG-13, and couldn't afford to do anything but CGI.

So pick one, no TMNT movie, or a lack luster TMNT movie. The movie saved the franchise rather you liked it or not. I don't think it's that great but it got the show another season.

Would have to agree with you. A TMNT movie -- even a crappy one -- keeps things like the comics (which I hold dear to me) and the 4Kids cartoon (which I don't hold dear to me, but enjoy in small doses) afloat, and keeps guys I respect employed.

PG-13 didn't exist when Superman was first released.

Which is really my point. If the original TMNT ever goes under the magnifying glass again by the MPAA, it would receive a gratious PG-13 (short of the R a film would receive nowadays under the "Kicks to the head only in R movies" policy). TMNT 2 and 3 are PG through and through, but then so is TMNT 2007.

Spitfire
10-26-2007, 12:28 AM
Which is really my point. If the original TMNT ever goes under the magnifying glass again by the MPAA, it would receive a gratious PG-13 (short of the R a film would receive nowadays under the "Kicks to the head only in R movies" policy). TMNT 2 and 3 are PG through and through, but then so is TMNT 2007.

Wait what? There's a rule where you can't kick people in the head in movies anymore? That's ****ing stupid.

Masked Ninja
10-26-2007, 01:38 AM
Uhh... I actually think that ratings have relaxed over the years. They're doing stuff (especially sexual content) in PG13 movies that were only possible in R's back in the day. The creation of the PG13 category since those early R's has something to do with this, but still.

Where the ratings get stupid is in movies like TMNT where people are concerned about what kids are seeing and figure nunchucks and any blood at all can only be handled by teenagers or older. In that sense, PG is the new G. But I wouldn't say this trend applies to all films (which is dumb... what's the use of a rating system if it doesn't work the same across the board?)

gobo
10-26-2007, 01:57 AM
'The Secret on Nihm' was rated what? And, the big red ink-pen that was leaking on her arm was where? :P
Wait what? There's a rule where you can't kick people in the head in movies anymore? That's ****ing stupid.
Indeed it is, but we can't expect entertainment politics to be any less stupid than governmental politics.

Magneto
10-26-2007, 02:48 AM
Uhh... I actually think that ratings have relaxed over the years. They're doing stuff (especially sexual content) in PG13 movies that were only possible in R's back in the day. The creation of the PG13 category since those early R's has something to do with this, but still.

Where the ratings get stupid is in movies like TMNT where people are concerned about what kids are seeing and figure nunchucks and any blood at all can only be handled by teenagers or older. In that sense, PG is the new G. But I wouldn't say this trend applies to all films (which is dumb... what's the use of a rating system if it doesn't work the same across the board?)

I can see where you are coming from with these statements. As it very much does apply with films such as TMNT and others that they are a bit more uh, "inspected" on violence and what not, for of course "the childrens sake". Even if those same kids are watching PG-13, and even R rated flicks with their parents on a daily basis. I mean, hell. Parents were taking their kids to Theres something about Mary for christ sakes. :roll:

Dragon Turtle
10-26-2007, 08:13 AM
Which is really my point. If the original TMNT ever goes under the magnifying glass again by the MPAA, it would receive a gratious PG-13 (short of the R a film would receive nowadays under the "Kicks to the head only in R movies" policy). TMNT 2 and 3 are PG through and through, but then so is TMNT 2007.

"gratuitous", umm maybe, but I could easily lower the first movie down to an PG rating with only a couple of edits.


Wait what? There's a rule where you can't kick people in the head in movies anymore? That's ****ing stupid.

Although I'm not sure about an R rating, most explicit martial art scenes are definately removed from the PG setting, although the line between PG and PG-13 can at times be hazy. But, once a film is designated PG-13, all bets are off, as PG-13 is a large grey area. Many martial arts films like Fearless, Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon, and the Rush Hour movies are all PG-13.





But I wouldn't say this trend applies to all films (which is dumb... what's the use of a rating system if it doesn't work the same across the board?)


I have a feeling that if "TMNT" was by created Dreamworks, Pixar or Disney, they could have included beheadings, shootings, and hangings and it still would have gotten a PG rating.


'The Secret on Nihm' was rated what? And, the big red ink-pen that was leaking on her arm was where? :P



If only we could return to a world where all "G" movies were like "The Secret of NIMH".:)

Andrew NDB
10-26-2007, 10:58 AM
While it's true that PG-13 has become a teency bit more lenient and R-esque to some degree over the past decade, at the same time the regular PG rating has become far less lenient.

Wait what? There's a rule where you can't kick people in the head in movies anymore? That's ****ing stupid.

As far as I know a kick to the head is an automatic R under today's MPAA guidelines. And they're either already agreed or are about to make into policy any smoking in movies an automatic R as well.

"gratuitous", umm maybe, but I could easily lower the first movie down to an PG rating with only a couple of edits.

True, true. But why would you want to do that?

Dragon Turtle
10-26-2007, 02:16 PM
True, true. But why would you want to do that?


Definitely not, but I will say that a PG-13 movie on the same level as the first movie (even allowing for a little more fighting), wouldn't be met with a lot resistance from parents, those who would object probably wouldn't allow their children to go see PG TMNT anyway. Using the first movie as precedence as far as content is concerned, a PG-13 rating is easily attainable for any possible sequel.

Andrew NDB
10-26-2007, 02:52 PM
Using the first movie as precedence as far as content is concerned, a PG-13 rating is easily attainable for any possible sequel.

Not according to Munroe.

gobo
10-26-2007, 03:21 PM
Since Munroe doesn't want to risk his career over upping the ante, that's not to say he can't make it happen after Gatchaman... if he's even involved with the sequel. :( And, he better be...

Drtooth
10-26-2007, 03:35 PM
I have a feeling that if "TMNT" was by created Dreamworks, Pixar or Disney, they could have included beheadings, shootings, and hangings and it still would have gotten a PG rating.


And I have a feeling if TMNT was created by Dreamworks, they'd do nothing but recite lines from other movies, and have A-list voice actors play the turtles really badly, and the VA's would be the focus of the film. Until the movie was already in theaters and there for a while did I see an ad that said Sarah Michelle Geller and Captain Picard were in it.

If WB doesn't want to distribute the sequal, and it doesn't happen on their account, It'll be another reason I'm holy crap furious at them (killing Kid's WB with CBS's help, Loonatics Unleashed, and Slowly destroying CN are the main reasons). I don't care if certain members said this film was "kiddy-fied," I thought it was a lot more adult than TMNT 2. Super Shredder? No thanks. I still say it's the best one since the first.


Where the ratings get stupid is in movies like TMNT where people are concerned about what kids are seeing and figure nunchucks and any blood at all can only be handled by teenagers or older. In that sense, PG is the new G. But I wouldn't say this trend applies to all films (which is dumb... what's the use of a rating system if it doesn't work the same across the board?)

IMO, ratings have become a marketing thing, and they do not apply to movies at all. i've seen many PG cartoons the last couple years that could easily pass as G's. But kids, and their parents don;t want to see "G" films. So they make up the "scary images" bullcrap to make it a PG film so they think people will see them. On the contrast, something about Ratatoullie seemed like it was more adult than a G rating. But just in the sense something with lengthy gourmet dialogue would go over younger children's heads.

I mean, the ratings system is bullnuts now. I've heard the complaints about how a PG movie= an R rated movie and all that garbage. But that just doesn't seem to be true. I severly doubt a school shooting would have taken place if there was a little more violence in the film. i doubt little Billy 5 year old would go down to his local 7-11 and pick up some nunchucks and beat the crap out of his playmates. But the parental group facists believe that they have to sheild everyone else's children instead of letting parents parent.

I could go on all day about this, but I really feel TMNT could have gotten away with a G rating. A little more violence and darkness could have helped the movie, but I still think it was amazing.

Dragon Turtle
10-26-2007, 11:27 PM
Not according to Munroe.

Since Munroe doesn't want to risk his career over upping the ante, that's not to say he can't make it happen after Gatchaman... if he's even involved with the sequel. :( And, he better be...


From interviews, Munroe wants to take the franchise into PG-13 territory, but the job of spearheading this step shouldn't be left only on his shoulders, I believe Playmates, 4kids, and Mirage wouldn't mind either, someone else needs to step up and make their opinions heard, if WB just continues to lower their heads and plow forward in keeping TMNT aimed at children.



And I have a feeling if TMNT was created by Dreamworks, they'd do nothing but recite lines from other movies, and have A-list voice actors play the turtles really badly, and the VA's would be the focus of the film. Until the movie was already in theaters and there for a while did I see an ad that said Sarah Michelle Geller and Captain Picard were in it.


You saw ads?:o


If WB doesn't want to distribute the sequal, and it doesn't happen on their account, It'll be another reason I'm holy crap furious at them (killing Kid's WB with CBS's help, Loonatics Unleashed, and Slowly destroying CN are the main reasons). I don't care if certain members said this film was "kiddy-fied," I thought it was a lot more adult than TMNT 2. Super Shredder? No thanks. I still say it's the best one since the first.


WB do want to distribute the sequel, they just want to do it in the same cheap half-hearted way they did the first movie. It's hard to blame Imagi for taking a stand for better distribution.




I could go on all day about this, but I really feel TMNT could have gotten away with a G rating. A little more violence and darkness could have helped the movie, but I still think it was amazing.

It may have had its faults, but at the end day I still consider TMNT a well crafted movie, and enjoyed it more then any other animated film or comicbook based movie that came out this year, and if a sequel was similar in quality I would be fine with it. But, I also believe that there is far more potential to be had in taking the franchise in slightly more mature direction, I also question the logic of aiming the franchise strictly at kids, since there is no telling whether or not kids may have completely moved on to something else 3-4 years from now.

Drtooth
11-09-2007, 09:35 AM
So no one paid attention to this little tidbit on Murphy's Blog?

While I can't give it a full thumbs-up (there remains one new and substantial issue to be resolved), I'm happy to report that Imagi has successfully renegotiated its distribution deal with Warner Brothers for the potential TMNT movie sequel, so at least that particular hurdle has been passed. The next meeting between Mirage and Imagi is scheduled for mid-December, at which point the new issue will be discussed and hopefully resolved to everyone's satisfaction. To be continued. Again.

So until then, fingers crossed. or not. We wouldn't want to jinx it.

Splinter's Iroonna
11-09-2007, 04:41 PM
I was so busy getting report cards ready and other things, I didn't find out 'til just now!

*is happy!*

Rooish
11-09-2007, 06:16 PM
What "little issue" is Murphy referring to?

gobo
11-09-2007, 06:25 PM
What "little issue" is Murphy referring to?
Getting Munroe back on-board, I hope...

Andrew NDB
11-09-2007, 08:21 PM
Getting Munroe back on-board, I hope...

Oh, I doubt that -- I don't see why he wouldn't jump at it as soon as it's on the table.

It's about securing funding.

Splinter's Iroonna
11-09-2007, 09:04 PM
Murphy already said it was NOT about funding.


"someone" said...
" ...there remains one new and substantial issue to be resolved... at which point the new issue will be discussed and hopefully resolved to everyone's satisfaction. "

Sounds like funding problems to me.

Someone needs to kick in a "substantial" amount of money.

November 9, 2007 7:54 AM


m. said...
Not funding.

November 9, 2007 8:37 AM

Bold is mine.

Avatar Yuffie
11-09-2007, 10:23 PM
Man, beaten to it.

Yeah, Murphy said it's not the funding. He did say April wants food. XD

But I'm glad the sequel is sort of secured. Now that's another thing to look forward to.

Andrew NDB
11-09-2007, 10:32 PM
Interesting then, if it's not monetary-related. I'd like to believe everyone is growing a backbone and trying to stonewall WB into "PG-13 or bust!" but I doubt it.

gobo
11-09-2007, 11:18 PM
Oh, I doubt that -- I don't see why he wouldn't jump at it as soon as it's on the table.

It's about securing funding.
True dat. But, Munroe said himself that it doesn't look like he'll get the chance. I'd doubt that was an issue myself if he hadn't said so. Perhaps he was just referring to scheduling conflicts? O_o

Splinter's Iroonna
11-10-2007, 10:41 AM
True dat. But, Munroe said himself that it doesn't look like he'll get the chance. I'd doubt that was an issue myself if he hadn't said so. Perhaps he was just referring to scheduling conflicts? O_o

I swear, Mr. Murphy is gonna arrest me for constantly stealing his blog entries....

<.<

>.>

m. said...
It's related to an issue that even I found surprising but that, now that I've thought about it, makes a certain amount of sense. Wish I could tell you what it is but I can't just yet. Rest assured though that it's interesting from a stylistic POV....

-Mysterious M.

>.>
<.<

Warhorse
11-22-2007, 10:25 PM
So, are we gonna get a sequel or not? And will WB advertise it better than they did for the last flick? I really would love to see the boys back again in a cgi sequel.

And has any television networks secured rights to show the movie on their station yet? What cable company has gotten rights, Showtime, HBO or Cinemax?

Splinter's Iroonna
11-23-2007, 10:29 AM
Sounds like Imagi and Mirage are the only two left to come to agreement. Murphy said the next meeting was mid-Dec.

I would guess that if Imagi managed to come to an agreement with WB regarding the distribution, then they (being WB) will do a better job of promoting it.

Don't know about cable. It's still on VOD here.

MoreCowbell5263
11-23-2007, 07:30 PM
Well, this all seems like great news. Although anything regarding more Ninja Turtles is good news to me. Anyway, does this mean that a sequel is pretty much guaranteed or what? Sounds like they're definitely discussing the matter, which is a plus.

Warhorse
11-23-2007, 10:01 PM
What's the chance of us one day getting some sort of Ninja Turtle marathon? Like, start the day with some episodes of the old toon, then during the afternoon, show some episodes of the new toon, then finish the day and evening with all four Turtle movies. Has there been any Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle conventions? If not, maybe it's about time?:ohwell:

Spitfire
11-24-2007, 02:36 AM
If Beowulf makes some good cash maybe it's possible for the PG-13 boost. Cause that movie was bloody, had ass and boobs, and was rated PG-13.

Roseangelo
11-24-2007, 02:41 AM
If Beowulf makes some good cash maybe it's possible for the PG-13 boost. Cause that movie was bloody, had ass and boobs, and was rated PG-13.

Yeah, but no one's trying to sell Beowulf pajamas to the kiddies.

Spitfire
11-24-2007, 03:36 AM
Yeah, but no one's trying to sell Beowulf pajamas to the kiddies.

No they sell them to goth kids at Hot Topic, along with T-shirts and an action figure line.

ToTheNines
11-24-2007, 09:50 AM
What's the chance of us one day getting some sort of Ninja Turtle marathon? Like, start the day with some episodes of the old toon, then during the afternoon, show some episodes of the new toon, then finish the day and evening with all four Turtle movies. Has there been any Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle conventions? If not, maybe it's about time?:ohwell:

Cartoon Network had a pretty long TMNT marathon on March 24th to go along with the movie, other than that... nothing. You'd think the OT would have been picked up by Toon Disney or some random digital cable channel by now, and the NT is better than almost anything Cartoon Network is dishing out at this point. As for the movies, ABC shows the first two semi-frequently and I think Sci-Fi shows the abomination at like 3 in the morning...

Fiendishglow
11-25-2007, 05:53 PM
What's the chance of us one day getting some sort of Ninja Turtle marathon? Like, start the day with some episodes of the old toon, then during the afternoon, show some episodes of the new toon, then finish the day and evening with all four Turtle movies. Has there been any Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle conventions? If not, maybe it's about time?:ohwell:

I would say 0%. Maybe a mini-marathon of the new toon on Cartoon Network, maybe a marathon of 2 or 3 movies on ABC Family, but nothing else.

Maybe the old toon will get picked up one day, and whoever picks it up will celebrate with a marathon.. but your best bet is to do your own marathon via DVD.

Season 1 and the first 2 movies FTW.

Juniorx
12-04-2007, 03:03 PM
Oh question any word on a sequal yet.Hey what about that movie Beowulf i think its in 3d or cgi.What about seeing turtles that direction with pg13 i dont see why i know for fact kids went to see that beowulf.Pg13 works with transformers,spider-man but i dont see why not.Cause this cgi didnt help at all.Me im praying for wb chang their minds to see that the turtles go with the custums and cgi for the stunts something like spider-man with frank miller directing and any other directors you guys like for a new turtle movie.If you guys don't like what i am talking about i am sorry, im not tryin to pick a fight just fad up with all bullcrap the way our turtles are being treating.

Dragon Turtle
12-04-2007, 09:46 PM
Oh question any word on a sequal yet.Hey what about that movie Beowulf i think its in 3d or cgi.What about seeing turtles that direction with pg13 i dont see why i know for fact kids went to see that beowulf.Pg13 works with transformers,spider-man but i dont see why not.Cause this cgi didnt help at all.Me im praying for wb chang their minds to see that the turtles go with the custums and cgi for the stunts something like spider-man with frank miller directing and any other directors you guys like for a new turtle movie.If you guys don't like what i am talking about i am sorry, im not tryin to pick a fight just fad up with all bullcrap the way our turtles are being treating.

As far as a sequel to TMNT goes, Imagi and Mirage are ironing out the final details, they should be meeting with each other in a couple of weeks.

But even with a PG-13 rating, Beowulf level of violence is most likely out of the question, and a live action version would be too expensive.

xChri5x
12-04-2007, 10:06 PM
I had no idea that Beowulf was CGI, until a few days ago. Admittedly I'd only seen a few short clips and posters. Looks fantastic though!

Masked Ninja
12-04-2007, 11:07 PM
That's the thing, though... it looks good, but it moves horribly. Yet another example of why motion capture sucks... unless you a) have an actual mo-cap actor instead of celebrities who don't know how to act that way, and b) real animators to tweak the performance if needed.

I really did love the Turtles in full CGI, just push those eyes a little closer together and get a much better story next time and I'd have no complaints. :) Or, even better, give some 2D animators a job and do the thing by hand. *wipes drool*

tmntobsessions
12-04-2007, 11:51 PM
Oh question any word on a sequal yet.Hey what about that movie Beowulf i think its in 3d or cgi.What about seeing turtles that direction with pg13 i dont see why i know for fact kids went to see that beowulf.Pg13 works with transformers,spider-man but i dont see why not.Cause this cgi didnt help at all.Me im praying for wb chang their minds to see that the turtles go with the custums and cgi for the stunts something like spider-man with frank miller directing and any other directors you guys like for a new turtle movie.If you guys don't like what i am talking about i am sorry, im not tryin to pick a fight just fad up with all bullcrap the way our turtles are being treating. Beowulf was filmed live action with a cgi layout over top, Robert Zemekis the director of beowulf, to my knowledge is the first to do this in a full length film, he has worked on such films as the Polar Express and Monster House, which were acted out just as beowulf was and then animated, the only difference is that monster house was just acted out just to give the animators a better example of lifelike movement, however i also believe that TMNT was the first CGI movie to have developed a complete muscular system program designed to be more life-like, it also shows veins popping out on raph when he flexes, so that was a good start, for me the storyline was a little weak, i also think that they should have done a better job with the animation of the humans they still looked quite cartoonish, i guess the question you have to ask yourself is, is the film more targeted to kids or old school fans, I have talked to many people about the TMNT movie and most of them usually think the storyline was bad, some people have absolutley no respect for the animation process and how much work goes into it, they just think of it as another cartoon, so if it's a matter of money, cutting back on the detailed animation and focusing on the story side of things would be a better route, even though i personally would much rather have a movie with great cgi imagery. My expectations for a possible sequel would be, of course the shredder returning, athough i still think they need more villians so it's not completely focused on the shredder, also i would love at least a pg-13 rating , and of course if it was up to me the animation would be more close to final fantasy 7, even though i know thats a long shot and would be alot more expensive, But whatever the outcome i will be happy no matter what just to see another sequel period, so let us all cross our fingers.

AquaParade
12-06-2007, 12:03 PM
Looking back, I have to admit, TMNT gave us a kinda rocky start to build on, if were hoping for another trilogy. The animation is beautiful, but the story just wasn't that great, although it had it's moments for sure. I just hope the next two films can be a little more connected and have some of the actual feeling of a trilogy, other then a cameo-sentence...lol.

Splinter's Iroonna
12-10-2007, 02:20 PM
Sounds like we'll know tomorrow!

Check out Murphy's blog entry for today.

http://the-5th-turtle.blogspot.com/

Well, tomorrow's the big day. The three top executives of Imagi Animation are visiting Mirage for a meeting with Peter Laird and CEO Gary in order to decide once and for all whether or not we will be going forward with a movie sequel.

Andrew NDB
12-10-2007, 02:37 PM
What does the Magic 8-Ball say? Signs point to... no. Probably.

From the article, though, this greatly interested me:
"Another thing is that there exists the possibility that Imagi wants to attach a "name" screenwriter or "name" writer-director to the project."

That could be the best thing going for a TMNT Part 5 right there. With a name director or name writer, they could have the weight and pull to make precisely the movie they want to make (whether it's PG or PG-13) with a minimal amount of studio bullying.

Fledermaus
12-10-2007, 02:52 PM
Please let that be the case. Gatchaman got Paul Dini to write the script... *crosses fingers*

TMNT
12-10-2007, 02:56 PM
I guess it's about time. Now, not to nitpick, but I wonder who set the guideline of it taking place in Japan. I'm all for a change in setting but I hope it doesn't take away from New York and the atmosphere set in the first one. The storyline I'm guessing is going to be "new" (with or without the Shredder) seeing that it will take place in Japan. Here's hoping the green team doesn't spend the whole movie there. And it's a bit sad that Kevin may not be writing/directing the second time around. Well, there are my concerns. A bit early as nothing has been set in stone but I just wanted to toss my two cents in. Hopefully everything goes well.

And Andrew, I think you eight ball is broken :lol:. But seriously, I understand your need for a more source based film (and I hope one day someone as passionate about it as you are takes the property there), but for now, I just want to see the TMNT back on screen. Perhaps that's just me being stubborn as I too, would love a "not-always-aimed-at-kids" TMNT movie but I think it's safe to say that, for the time being, the franchise won't be taken in that direction. It's the sad truth, but hey, I'm all for the franchise to be rebooted again in the next decade or so. Just as long as the TMNT continue to live on.

And I agree that attaching a "name" to the project may not be all that bad, provided that whoever is brought on takes the time to fully comprehend the source material and not just base his ideas on what's been done in the past.

Andrew NDB
12-10-2007, 03:11 PM
I guess it's about time. Now, not to nitpick, but I wonder who set the guideline of it taking place in Japan.

Imagi themselves, it sounds like. Probably boils down to silly reasons, but I'm OK with a TMNT film that goes to Japan. Again.

There's potential. For one, it's Foot HQ, and there's always things like the Yakuza they could drum up for suitable ninja action. Or it could be a setup for more Pokemon monsters, only Japanese-flavored this time... ugh...

I'm all for a change in setting but I hope it doesn't take away from New York and the atmosphere set in the first one.

I'm all about getting rid of the atmosphere of the first one (as far as tone, not the artistry of NYC and environs shown, which was pretty much as good as it gets in a CGI film with cartoon/anime-exaggerated humans), but I know what you mean.

And Andrew, I think you eight ball is broken :lol:.

Place your bets!

But seriously, I understand your need for a more source based film (and I hope one day someone as passionate about it as you are takes the property there), but for now, I just want to see the TMNT back on screen. Perhaps that's just me being stubborn as I too, would love a "not-always-aimed-at-kids" TMNT movie but I think it's safe to say that, for the time being, the franchise won't be taken in that direction.

You're very astute, and you also realize the problem. The problem is, things like Munroe's TMNT 4 only serve to reinforce the idea of "TMNT is for kiddies, and toy fandanglers." Now we have to wait even longer for that public perception to fade a bit before they can have any chance of taking a new, serious crack at it again.

It's the sad truth, but hey, I'm all for the franchise to be rebooted again in the next decade or so.

Again? It hasn't even been rebooted once.

Just as long as the TMNT continue to live on.

Well, I've resigned myself that pretty much the way things are going, TMNT in the mass media is going to be indefinitely aimed at toddlers and tweens, but that anything that keeps the Mirage comics afloat I can't knock too badly.

Call it a... necessary evil?

And I agree that attaching a "name" to the project may not be all that bad, provided that whoever is brought on takes the time to fully comprehend the source material and not just base his ideas on what's been done in the past.

That's the obvious concern, and it's a big one. A massive, massive name could come aboard TMNT Part 5, with total pull in Hollywood to even make an R-rated feature if it floated their fancy... but if it turns out this person has only ever watched a few episodes of the original TMNT cartoon or some vague pop culture remembrance of "Cowabunga, dudes!" from the 80s/early 90s, that's the movie they'll probably set out to make.

I would just about run my head through a wall at that point.

CJStyles
12-10-2007, 06:11 PM
Well, hopefully we get a in between film with a PG-13 Movie. It may not be a blood fest R, but it's better then PG if they can get it to PG 13 and bring as close to source material as possible. I think a Rated R TMNT movie will never happen, but it wouldn't be a bad thing if they made on.

Andrew NDB
12-10-2007, 07:18 PM
Well, hopefully we get a in between film with a PG-13 Movie. It may not be a blood fest R, but it's better then PG if they can get it to PG 13 and bring as close to source material as possible.

PG-13 seems the only equitable route. I don't think it's possible to make a proper TMNT movie that's rated PG under today's MPAA... and trying to is crazy (without neutering the action and swordplay for toddlers).

I think a Rated R TMNT movie will never happen, but it wouldn't be a bad thing if they made on.

No, it'll never happen and it really shouldn't. R is pushing things too far, as much as I'd like to see a tasteful R TMNT film.

Warhorse
12-10-2007, 07:24 PM
But do you ever wonder what kind of buzz an R Rated TMNT could generate? You don't think people would flock to the theaters to see what an R Rated Turtles movie would be about?

I always wondered that.

tcclives23
12-10-2007, 07:50 PM
While an R-rated TMNT movie would appeal to us, the older fans, you have to understand that TMNT is still unfortunately a kids favorite. TMNT depends on kids. They probably would not be allowed to see it on DVD let alone see it in theaters. Therefore, it would lose A LOT of money. Now with a PG-13 at least kids would hopefully be allowed to see it and appeal to the older fans as well.

However, I too would love to see what an R-rated TMNT would be like.

The Shelf
12-10-2007, 08:03 PM
But do you ever wonder what kind of buzz an R Rated TMNT could generate? You don't think people would flock to the theaters to see what an R Rated Turtles movie would be about?

I always wondered that.

I dunno, you'd think it would generate buzz, but I have a feeling people would still dismiss it for one reason or another. Most people (not counting people on message boards like this) dismissed TMNT because it wasn't over-the-top silly enough for them.

And frankly, I don't think I really want an R-TMNT anyway. Sure, I'd still watch it, and I'd still love it, but I really don't think TMNT needs it. I've always been happy with PG turtles, but I think PG-13 would be ideal. I mean, if Spider-man can get away with it, then TMNT certainly should be able to.

Besides, I don't think anything in the comic books is even R-rated. The only TMNT comics I've seen that warranted an R if they were to be made into a movie are the Bodycount books. Everything else fits perfectly into a PG-13.

Kendamu
12-10-2007, 09:43 PM
Yeah. PG-13 would be fine. Seems most other comic book movies work out great at PG-13... and they still sell to kids!

Splinter's Iroonna
12-10-2007, 10:57 PM
PG-13 seems the only equitable route. I don't think it's possible to make a proper TMNT movie that's rated PG under today's MPAA... and trying to is crazy (without neutering the action and swordplay for toddlers).

And we ALL know exactly how it's the toddlers that drive the market.



No, it'll never happen and it really shouldn't. R is pushing things too far, as much as I'd like to see a tasteful R TMNT film.

Hmmm... a TASTEFUL R TMNT... I'm trying to remember a tasteful R film that didn't involve surfeit of bloodshed a la "From Dusk 'til Dawn"....

I mean, "Alien" was pretty damn intense and gave the impression of more gore/violence that you actually saw on screen, though that was 1979... don't recall the ratings they used back in the day....

Andrew NDB
12-10-2007, 11:55 PM
Hmmm... a TASTEFUL R TMNT... I'm trying to remember a tasteful R film that didn't involve surfeit of bloodshed a la "From Dusk 'til Dawn"....

Pretty Woman. Rain Man. Jerry Maguire. The Color of Money. The Firm. The Piano.

Most recently off the top of my head, The Constant Gardener.

Andrew NDB
12-11-2007, 12:15 AM
I dunno, you'd think it would generate buzz, but I have a feeling people would still dismiss it for one reason or another. Most people (not counting people on message boards like this) dismissed TMNT because it wasn't over-the-top silly enough for them.

Who are these people? They should be drug into the street and shot, and educated of the source material. :)

And frankly, I don't think I really want an R-TMNT anyway. Sure, I'd still watch it, and I'd still love it, but I really don't think TMNT needs it. I've always been happy with PG turtles, but I think PG-13 would be ideal. I mean, if Spider-man can get away with it, then TMNT certainly should be able to.

You're right. And both Spider-Man and Fantastic Four comics are collectively far kiddier than the Mirage TMNT comics... yet both spawned PG-13 movies.

Go figure.

Besides, I don't think anything in the comic books is even R-rated. The only TMNT comics I've seen that warranted an R if they were to be made into a movie are the Bodycount books. Everything else fits perfectly into a PG-13.

Oh, I don't know. The very first issue of TMNT would have to be censored a bit, what with Leonardo ramming twin katanas graphically through Saki's chest, then the whole business of Saki exploding messily over the rooftop. Then TMNT Vol. 1 #21 would have to have the splash page of Leonardo decapitating Saki pretty ambiguously quick cut. And some pretty graphic stuff in "City at War" also. Also I'm pretty sure underaged drinking (even of the teenaged mutant turtle variety) would probably be frowned upon in PG-13.

On the whole, though, you're right. They could 98.5% pretty much make it conformed to a PG-13 movie, don't get me wrong.

Drtooth
12-11-2007, 12:18 PM
There's potential. For one, it's Foot HQ, and there's always things like the Yakuza they could drum up for suitable ninja action. Or it could be a setup for more Pokemon monsters, only Japanese-flavored this time... ugh...


Yeah. Monsters aside, they could really delve more into Karai in this film. Sounds like this could be a great way to get into her character past the point we were in the last film.

Andrew NDB
12-11-2007, 05:18 PM
Sounds like this could be a great way to get into her character past the point we were in the last film.

You mean on the ground, at April O'Neil's feet? :roll:

Better if they just reveal that wasn't Karai at all in the first movie, but Karai's daughter or something (she did have a 16-19-ish daughter in "City at War," after all).

Aryudsoh
12-12-2007, 12:21 PM
Sounds like we'll have to wait at least another 4 months now!

http://the-5th-turtle.blogspot.com/

Andrew NDB
12-12-2007, 12:32 PM
Seeing a pattern here...

Buslady
12-12-2007, 12:58 PM
ARGH!

Jeez, Pete wears a skirt...I hope it's a kilt.

The Shelf
12-12-2007, 01:11 PM
Haha, well, hmm. Okay, so everyone mark your calendars for April 12th-ish. Somehow I kinda expected this to happen. They really should get the ball rolling so that they can release this thing in 2009 (probably late 2009 is the best we can hope for). I want the year of the turtle to hit with a resounding thunder.

Drtooth
12-12-2007, 01:57 PM
I'm still hopeful. Though Imagi was kinda naive to only have one proposal. Considering both sides still want to see a sequal happen at one point, I'll just wait for the next set of news.

Andrew NDB
12-12-2007, 02:15 PM
I'm still hopeful. Though Imagi was kinda naive to only have one proposal. Considering both sides still want to see a sequal happen at one point, I'll just wait for the next set of news.

The fact that Imagi only brought one proposal to the table yesterday suggests to me it was kind of a, "Well, this is the only idea we'd be interested in pursuing. Take it or leave it." And Laird left it. Though they have another 4 months to bring something else to the table... I wouldn't hold your breath.

ToTheNines
12-12-2007, 03:10 PM
The fact that Imagi only brought one proposal to the table yesterday suggests to me it was kind of a, "Well, this is the only idea we'd be interested in pursuing. Take it or leave it." And Laird left it. Though they have another 4 months to bring something else to the table... I wouldn't hold your breath.

Well, I used to think that you didn't want a sequel just because you didn't like the film... but now I agree with you: we won't be gettin a sequel. This is taking to long and apparently Imagi wants a comedy driven plot... **** that, I'd rather there be no sequel at all than to see that happen.

Andrew NDB
12-12-2007, 03:12 PM
This is taking to long and apparently Imagi wants a comedy driven plot...

Could be. Or it could be flipped... maybe Laird wants monsters and magic and such, and it's Imagi that wants more of a no-nonsense ninja-type movie, something it doesn't seem like Laird is interested in (in the comics nowadays, or otherwise). We don't know which party is playing hardball with the better intentions, but it doesn't really matter.

This ain't happenin'.

ToTheNines
12-12-2007, 03:22 PM
I just read at Murhpy's blog (in one of his comments, not the actual post) that Imagi proposed the comdey bull, and Pete denied that. He also didn't like Murphy's idea...

Andrew NDB
12-12-2007, 03:30 PM
Ah, just read that now as well. So yes, looks like Imagi's only pitch now was primarily a comedy. Yeah, they can pretty much take that pitch and shove it up their collective asses.

Splinter's Iroonna
12-12-2007, 05:06 PM
ARGH!

Jeez, Pete wears a skirt...I hope it's a kilt.


I hope he wears SHORTS under it! :o:lol:*bleaches brain of bad scary images*

Fledermaus
12-12-2007, 06:16 PM
Just read Murphy's blog. I'm going to restrain from all comments regarding Imagi and especially Mr. Laird. I truly don't know what to say.

I'm glad Murphy's trying his best even if there's no guarantee he'll get credit for his work -- he just wants to see a good movie made like any fan of the TMNT. Its a terrible shame he doesn't have more authority in the franchise. It must be terribly frustrating to be an artist in his position.

The more crap I see going on like this, the more it motivates me as a fan and person who draws stuff to do something... permanent about it.

Roseangelo
12-12-2007, 06:26 PM
If this doesn't end up happening, the reason obviously has nothing to do with money. I hope I don't see those stating it as fact months ago that the movie did not make enough to warrant a sequel claiming "victory" about "being right" if the deal does fall through.

Just an observation.

The more crap I see going on like this, the more it motivates me as a fan and person who draws stuff to do something... permanent about it.

Whatever you've got in mind, can I get in on it? (Even if I lack artistic skillz?) ^_^

Spitfire
12-12-2007, 07:24 PM
I hope Laird reads this. Laird is a moron who needs to learn how to treat his fans. It doesn't matter if he doesn't like characters HE created in the past people still do and he needs to learn to use them.

End of story.

Leonardo Mystic
12-12-2007, 07:41 PM
I'm rather disappointed to hear IMAGI's lack of creativity here. However, I hope they'll come back with a better proposal. There's still time, and it takes that and patience to develop something really worthwhile, which I believe will turn out as such.

The Shelf
12-12-2007, 08:10 PM
EDIT: Blah, whatever, thought erased.

EDIT x2: I think Laird did the right thing. So far he seems to have done pretty well in shooting down bad ideas. But it seems to me that we've got two options. We can have a successful turtles movie, or we can have a good one. I don't think we can have both. Imagi's pitch probably would have been successful (more OT-like). If Murphy, Andrew, myself, and whoever else prefers Ninja over Teenage had our way, then the movie would probably be really good, but it wouldn't fly with enough people to make it a success.

Dragon Turtle
12-12-2007, 09:11 PM
EDIT: Blah, whatever, thought erased.

EDIT x2: I think Laird did the right thing. So far he seems to have done pretty well in shooting down bad ideas. But it seems to me that we've got two options. We can have a successful turtles movie, or we can have a good one. I don't think we can have both. Imagi's pitch probably would have been successful (more OT-like). If Murphy, Andrew, myself, and whoever else prefers Ninja over Teenage had our way, then the movie would probably be really good, but it wouldn't fly with enough people to make it a success.


Don't be tricked into believing that, sure, an OT-like movie could probably do business similar to other disposable cgi movies in the 90-120 million range (if marketed).

But there is no reason a PG-13 movie can't be just as successful, in fact, if you put in enough PG-13 action into the movie (a reason for people to go back for multiple viewings), I truly believe you can do far better financially.

Also, there is no reason a PG-13 movie needs to forsake every aspect of the old toon. TMNT could have done a little more to appease old school cartoon fans, and it probably wouldn't have taken alot to do so.

Andrew NDB
12-12-2007, 09:12 PM
I actually really applaud Laird for the veto (his vetos in other areas of the franchise lately... not so much, but he's the bossman). A man of less conviction and backbone would just buckle, sign on the dotted line, and throw any old sequel out there to make a buck, no matter how much it might drag the name of their creation through the turd bucket.

Andrew NDB
12-12-2007, 09:16 PM
The more crap I see going on like this, the more it motivates me as a fan and person who draws stuff to do something... permanent about it.

You know, the first time I read this, I thought you were talking about murder.

Roseangelo
12-12-2007, 09:22 PM
Laird can shoot down two dozen bad ideas for all I care; I have no qualms with the Imagi proposal rejection. But he's not exactly offering them any alternatives (at least that's the picture that's been painted) and I think that's really stupid.

If Murphy's outline was true to what we are craving in a TMNT film, like many of us suspect it was, how the heck to you justify essentially shrugging your shoulders at that?

Dragon Turtle
12-12-2007, 09:37 PM
Laird can shoot down two dozen bad ideas for all I care; I have no qualms with the Imagi proposal rejection. But he's not exactly offering them any alternatives (at least that's the picture that's been painted) and I think that's really stupid.

I'm actually more concerned that Imagi are pitching ideas at all. What is all this talk about getting "named" directors and writers, if the premise of the movie is going to be determined beforehand, are they just going to be window dressing?

gobo
12-12-2007, 09:51 PM
So, I guess they actually were thinking Ratner... :dead:

Andrew NDB
12-12-2007, 09:55 PM
Laird can shoot down two dozen bad ideas for all I care; I have no qualms with the Imagi proposal rejection. But he's not exactly offering them any alternatives (at least that's the picture that's been painted) and I think that's really stupid.

I got the impression that there were probably plenty of ideas floated to Imagi, but they keep coming back with things that Laird can't sign off on (the previous meetings and false starts). In any case, if you really think it was just Imagi and Peter Laird sitting at a table with nothing more than Laird just saying, "No" before showing them the door, then that's a bit silly.

Kind of reminds me of the late 90s, in a way. Eastman and Laird were shooting down idea after idea, script after script for TMNT IV. They submitted ideas, then even at one point Peter Laird himself wrote up a treatment for the sole purpose of steering things in the right direction... yet TPTB kept coming back with goofy nonsense they had to just keep vetoing until there was no longer any option to make the movie at all. It was the right decision then, it's the right decision now if that's the same crap that's happening.

If Murphy's outline was true to what we are craving in a TMNT film, like many of us suspect it was, how the heck to you justify essentially shrugging your shoulders at that?

Well... can't really justify that at all. :(

Spitfire
12-12-2007, 10:35 PM
My problem with Laird is he has entire universes filled with awesome characters to use in movies or the series and he refuses to use them. Who gives a crap if Bebop and Rocksteady are from the old series? Anyone ever read Archie? Krang was ruthless he could use Krang. What about all the good guy mutants, they all had origins as well. Wyrm, Scumbug, Armaggon, Verminator X all these villains would be amazing to see in a movie or the series. They all have great backgrounds and are bad ass in their own respects.

But will he use any of them? No. Because he's a moron and doesn't want to own up to the fact that if he did they might do better then what he's doing now. Playmates even said they wanted him to use Archie characters and he shot the idea down. He hates Archie because he knows its better then the garbage he's making now.

Andrew NDB
12-12-2007, 11:19 PM
My problem with Laird is he has entire universes filled with awesome characters to use in movies or the series and he refuses to use them. Who gives a crap if Bebop and Rocksteady are from the old series? Anyone ever read Archie? Krang was ruthless he could use Krang. What about all the good guy mutants, they all had origins as well. Wyrm, Scumbug, Armaggon, Verminator X all these villains would be amazing to see in a movie or the series. They all have great backgrounds and are bad ass in their own respects.

But will he use any of them? No. Because he's a moron and doesn't want to own up to the fact that if he did they might do better then what he's doing now. Playmates even said they wanted him to use Archie characters and he shot the idea down. He hates Archie because he knows its better then the garbage he's making now.

I think Laird refusing to resurrect characters from the children's cartoon of the 80s and early 90s (as much as us nostaligics today may still harbor a soft spot for it) is pretty effing far removed from any of the problems surrounding TMNT at large today (in film or otherwise). But you're obviously passionate about those cartoons and that's fine; I'm passionate about the Mirage comics, the source material. What irks me (but not a whole lot... it's Laird's ship to sink if he wants to, as much as you or I want to be the guy on the Titanic shouting at the captain: "Iceberg! Dead ahead!") is Laird trying to not keep TMNT in line with the original Eastman & Laird's™ TMNT comics... but rather retool them into Laird's™ TMNT comics... which lately seems to mean shifting things away from the ninja stuff, fights, and things of this nature, and more toward sci-fi and other oddities that don't seem to pique many's interest.

Roseangelo
12-12-2007, 11:32 PM
is Laird trying to not keep TMNT in line with the original Eastman & Laird's™ TMNT comics... but rather retool them into Laird's™ TMNT comics... which lately seems to mean shifting things away from the ninja stuff, fights, and things of this nature, and more toward sci-fi and other oddities.

I actually think this is the heart of Spitfire's complaint, too. You're just seeing it from different angles.

The original toon and Archie series do not reflect Laird's™ TMNT, as you coin it (quite correctly).

I do not personally need new merchandise or anything based on the old cartoon. However, I think it is incredibly stupid to not take advantage of the marketing possibilities that can be done with it. The upcoming Retro push is obviously a joke, as can be seen by the recent April drawings. Even with that it's becoming Laird's™ TMNT Retro. If Playmates thinks there's a market for classic characters/figures, they should be able to make those figures.

I personally long for more Archie stuff. Hopefully the Forever War will actually see daylight, but Ryan Brown's and Murphy's efforts to resurrect that series in whole has been shot down completely.

His dictator attitude is insulting to fans and I do not believe he has the right to sink the ship, even if he solely owns it.

Pepzi
12-13-2007, 09:46 AM
Archie Comic serise was gold. Love the mutant cross overs and the team ups, but lets face it TMNT 2k3 is far away from that style, it's only hope for old characters like Jagwar and so on, is twisted and skilled story lines they cant just pop out of a cows head and there he is...
As for a sequal I know if they get another shot Peter Laird will deliver on a good story I have faith in him.

Splinter's Iroonna
12-13-2007, 08:34 PM
As long as everyone is willing to keep talking, there's hope.

And someone out there who has artistic talent-- or many of you, rather-- perhaps a contest is in order:

Draw Peter Laird in a skirt!

Spitfire
12-17-2007, 04:17 AM
It's his boat he can sink it. That's a great attitude to have. It's okay if I build up a fan base with thousands of people who look to me for entertainment, adore my creations, then I get a wild hair up my ass on day and decide to ruin it all, that's okay? Really I don't get that logic. A smart person knows when to quit. If he can't make good decisions he needs to step down.

Rose is right that's my problem, if he wants to stray away and go off to more sci-fi things use the stuff he already created. Alot of people already have a love for those things and it would drive alot of fans crazy if he used some of those characters and plots. I'm pissed to find out the Mutimammals series was actually into pre-production scripted and everything and it got canned. I would have loved to see that.

Roseangelo
12-17-2007, 09:55 AM
I'm pissed to find out the Mutimammals series was actually into pre-production scripted and everything and it got canned. I would have loved to see that.

To be fair, Mirage supported that would-be show wholly. It was the failure of Bucky O'Hare more than anything else that doomed it.

However, Peter is the one not allowing anything new to be done with the characters currently.

Dan
03-26-2008, 01:27 AM
http://www.moviehole.net/news/20080319_caffeinated_clint_19308.html
TMNT 2
Never say Never, but last I heard, Warner Bros are abandoning their plans to do a sequel to last year’s “Ninja Turtles” restart. The plan originally, was to do a further two films – the next would’ve seen the heroes in hardshells taking on old foe, Shredder – in the series. Some initial work had even begun on the next sequel. After the lacklustre performance of “TMNT” though, the studio put the sequels on indefinite hold.

Roseangelo
03-26-2008, 01:34 AM
http://www.moviehole.net/news/20080319_caffeinated_clint_19308.html

Based on everything Murphy has said, that entire paragraph is BS.

Whitewolf89
03-26-2008, 02:27 AM
Based on everything Murphy has said, that entire paragraph is BS.
That's pretty much what I thought. I mean, since WHEN is over 95 million in profits "lackluster"?! And if he meant that the animation, or the story, or the action, or whatever were lackluster, he's off his nut about a mile and a half. The movie was great!!!

I was almost tempted to join that forum and figuratively yank a knot in that idiot's tail for calling it that! (Please notice that I said "almost".)

Sheeeesh, some people........!!!:roll:

Andrew NDB
03-26-2008, 02:43 PM
To launch a franchise, a 90 million worldwide first installment (minus a 35 million dollar budget and minus whatever millions went into the marketing/distribution budget) is pretty damning nowadays, especially considering the time and resources it took to produce -- time and resources that could be put to other projects more guaranteed to turn in bigger profits.

Dan and Steve saying that WB's funding for a sequel was never a problem was a bit surprising, but whatever.

Dragon Turtle
03-26-2008, 02:53 PM
There is no substance to this article since WB and Imagi had come to an agreement on the distribution of the sequel well after the boxoffice numbers had come in.


90 million for a franchise, that was poorly promoted, is pretty good in any day and age.

Drtooth
03-30-2008, 01:33 PM
TMNT 2
Never say Never, but last I heard, Warner Bros are abandoning their plans to do a sequel to last year’s “Ninja Turtles” restart. The plan originally, was to do a further two films – the next would’ve seen the heroes in hardshells taking on old foe, Shredder – in the series. Some initial work had even begun on the next sequel. After the lacklustre performance of “TMNT” though, the studio put the sequels on indefinite hold.

BS or not, Warners is a piss poor run corporation that wants to slash absloutely everything in order to correct their piss poor judgement as of late. Last I remembered, Warners couldn't promote a movie for shizz. Maybe Batman Begins and to some extent Superman Returns, but whoever runs their movie marketting department really needs to learn to say "You want fries with that?"

I only take the fact that they're slashing absolutely everything (including their animation department outside of DTV's) into account when it comes to this. Lackluster? Feh! the way these entertainment companies are run, if things don't get Spiderman reciepts on opening night, than it is Lackluster. Of course, the fact that it was released a week before Disney's Meet the Robinsons didn't help much either. But it didn't tank as bad as "The Last Mimzy" did. It did great opening weekend.

So, the hope rests, BS or not, that imagi and Mirage can work something out. If Warners doesn't want to do it, eff them! They don't even know what to do with evergreen properties like Looney Tunes. I'm sure they can find someone else to finanically back them.

Whitewolf89
04-10-2008, 04:18 PM
Speaking of any further news ON a possible sequel, HAS there been any lately? I know that the parties involved are SUPPOSED to meet again to discuss it soon. Like either this month, or soon, anyway.

gobo
04-10-2008, 07:01 PM
Murphy's blog reported no movements on that project just a week ago. Imagi hasn't come up with anything more suitable than their comedy idea.

Andrew NDB
04-12-2008, 06:32 PM
Murphy's blog reported no movements on that project just a week ago. Imagi hasn't come up with anything more suitable than their comedy idea.

And how long ago did Murphy say Peter rejected the comedy idea? However many months ago it was, we were told Imagi had 6 months from that time to come up with an alternate take on the material or the whole thing is officially dead.

Andrew NDB
04-12-2008, 06:39 PM
If Warners doesn't want to do it, eff them!

You do realize that Laird, and Laird and Eastman together before that, had been trying to secure financing for TMNT Part 4 for nearly 15 years before the deal with WB/Imagi? And they'd gone through many different studios... New Line/Golden Harvest, Tri-Star, etc., all trying to forcefeed comedic, toddler rubbish (and knowing what some of those pitches were back then in the 90s and early 2000s, I can actually say something positive about Munroe's TMNT -- its story is probably the best of the bunch... but that's like winning a farting contest... you'll all stink, but your stink is the only one people will remember) and all getting rejected by Peter and Kevin.

Clearly it's not as simple as "Eff WB! Just go get someone else, Pete!"

I do, however, take the stance of, "Eff WB! Eff any studio/financier unwilling to make a proper Mirage TMNT comic book film. If it takes 10, 15 years to find a studio/financier with the balls and backbone to do it, so be it."

Spitfire
04-13-2008, 02:30 AM
Keep in mind Lion's Gate wasn't around back then. Lion's Gate will release anything, seriously. They release SAW movies every year*Yeah they make SOME money*, they release foreign films*Most of which make no money*, and movies film makers have been trying to get released for years such as Rob Zombie's crap-fest "House Of A Thousand Corpses".

They could run to Lion's Gate. And LG wouldn't censor them either. They'd have no issues with turtles being a PG-13 or even R rated film. They might not be around much longer since they pretty much release anything and hope it does well but it works for me if it means i get to see **** I wouldn't otherwise.

Also while on the subject of "TMNT" bombing your failing to see the profits made by the action figures and other merch. The toyline sold well, even if most of us hate it. They continue to make toys for it because it's continuing to sell well. Sorta pisses me off, not it really pisses me off. They canned tons of FF toys because that were ready to be released to put out the movie line. I guess kids might get confused if theres FF toys and movie toys on the shelfs at the same time...oooooh nooo!

Kendamu
04-13-2008, 05:34 AM
Keep in mind Lion's Gate wasn't around back then. Lion's Gate will release anything, seriously. They release SAW movies every year*Yeah they make SOME money*, they release foreign films*Most of which make no money*, and movies film makers have been trying to get released for years such as Rob Zombie's crap-fest "House Of A Thousand Corpses".

They could run to Lion's Gate. And LG wouldn't censor them either. They'd have no issues with turtles being a PG-13 or even R rated film. They might not be around much longer since they pretty much release anything and hope it does well but it works for me if it means i get to see **** I wouldn't otherwise.

Also while on the subject of "TMNT" bombing your failing to see the profits made by the action figures and other merch. The toyline sold well, even if most of us hate it. They continue to make toys for it because it's continuing to sell well. Sorta pisses me off, not it really pisses me off. They canned tons of FF toys because that were ready to be released to put out the movie line. I guess kids might get confused if theres FF toys and movie toys on the shelfs at the same time...oooooh nooo!
That's funny considering that when the movie figs came out for SotO I was never confused... They sold the 'toon figs and the movie figs right along side each other.

I never cared about either line of toys, but for those who do I'm not really happy that suddently it's so easy to "confuse people" from a corporate standpoint.

Drtooth
04-17-2008, 10:41 AM
Clearly it's not as simple as "Eff WB! Just go get someone else, Pete!"


My stance on the whole matter is Eff WB for not knowing what they hell they want to do with their own company. they're going through a crap period right now, loosing money hand over fist, not knowing what to do in animation except for DC comic related DTV's... basically really crappy stuff like that.

I mean, wasn't the film a three way partnership between Imagi, Warners, and The Weinstine Company? I would say, theoretically, the Weinstine Company could release it themselves, and 4Kids could have a stake in it as well (since they're the TMNT licensing group).

But what it boils down to, and I said this before, if Imagi is still in business and still going through with their projects. That's the worrysome blotch now. As it stands, KM left Imagi during Gatchaman to do another project, and Something fishy's going on with Astroboy as well. If these films don't make it, we can kiss any chance of a sequal, Theatrical or DTV, goodbye.

Also while on the subject of "TMNT" bombing your failing to see the profits made by the action figures and other merch. The toyline sold well, even if most of us hate it. They continue to make toys for it because it's continuing to sell well. Sorta pisses me off, not it really pisses me off. They canned tons of FF toys because that were ready to be released to put out the movie line. I guess kids might get confused if theres FF toys and movie toys on the shelfs at the same time...oooooh nooo!

2 Things. WB didn't care about the profits, because I don't think they got that much of a percentage of the toy line. I don't think. I'd be inclined to see that the merchandise was mostly between Mirage, the companies that produce the toys/clothes/candy, and 4Kids. Maybe some to Imagi, some to Weinstines, and a little to WB.

The second thing, I thought the canning of the FF toys in favor of the Movie line wasn't so much consumer confusion, but more of the part of the retailors. I mean, TRu was able to have both lines co-exist, but they rose the prices of the FF toys to reflect the movie line. Of course, that doesn't explain why Spider-Man toys were able to co-exist as basic Comic Spidey and Spider-Man the movie Part III toys, each with different price points. But then again, Hasbro is a big boy in the toy business. Playmates basically has the TMNT, and not too much else.

Sage Ninja
04-17-2008, 01:03 PM
maybe the best thing, and I know this is a long shot that is very unlikely to happen, is for a very passinate fan with lots of money to piss away takes up the project of a TMNT sequel and finaces it him self with out going through a company with all their censoreship crap so that mirage has the freedom to make a TMNT movie as gritty and close to the comics as they want. So...any one here with dollars upon dollars of cash to piss away so we can make this happen the way we want it? :ohwell:

Newton Gimmick
04-17-2008, 04:01 PM
TMNT kinda shot itself in the foot by going the CGI route. Had this been a totally new suitimation with some CGI sprinkled in movie, it'd done better money. It'd cost more too, but that's besides the point.

With the retro stuff so popular, it would have made money. Once they went with the cartoonish look, they alienated a WHOLE bunch of people. Mostly adults who didn't have kids. I think they were trying to make a Toy Story type crossover, but some parents won't take their kids to see violent stuff, so they split the audience twice. First making it such a kids movie and second still being TMNT which some parents don't approve of.

But if they'd made a movie be hip, edgy and cashing in on nostalgia like Transformers, GI Joe, etc, they'd have drawn in all the 20 somethings who did not go see TMNT.

That said, I loved TMNT and thought it was great and can't wait for the sequel. Even if it's a long wait.

ToTheNines
04-17-2008, 05:44 PM
But if they'd made a movie be hip, edgy and cashing in on nostalgia like Transformers, GI Joe, etc, they'd have drawn in all the 20 somethings who did not go see TMNT.

Meh, **** conformity.

AquaParade
04-17-2008, 07:13 PM
maybe the best thing, and I know this is a long shot that is very unlikely to happen, is for a very passinate fan with lots of money to piss away takes up the project of a TMNT sequel and finaces it him self with out going through a company with all their censoreship crap so that mirage has the freedom to make a TMNT movie as gritty and close to the comics as they want. So...any one here with dollars upon dollars of cash to piss away so we can make this happen the way we want it? :ohwell:

"I got five on it."

TMNT kinda shot itself in the foot by going the CGI route. Had this been a totally new suitimation with some CGI sprinkled in movie, it'd done better money. It'd cost more too, but that's besides the point.

With the retro stuff so popular, it would have made money. Once they went with the cartoonish look, they alienated a WHOLE bunch of people. Mostly adults who didn't have kids. I think they were trying to make a Toy Story type crossover, but some parents won't take their kids to see violent stuff, so they split the audience twice. First making it such a kids movie and second still being TMNT which some parents don't approve of.

But if they'd made a movie be hip, edgy and cashing in on nostalgia like Transformers, GI Joe, etc, they'd have drawn in all the 20 somethings who did not go see TMNT.

That said, I loved TMNT and thought it was great and can't wait for the sequel. Even if it's a long wait.

A live action would have probably been the more wiser route...but in the right hands, a cgi movie has so much potential...they just need to up the ante...look at Beowolf.
People would kill to see a at least slightly gritty return of the comic book tmnt in cgi form...that would totally get people talking.

Newton Gimmick
04-17-2008, 07:33 PM
Didn't Beowolf bomb in the same fashion that TMNT bombed? Which is to say, not really "bombed" but didn't meet expectations?

Actually a quick check confirms that after production budget is subtracted, TMNT made hand over fist more then Beowolf. Beowolf barely made more then cost.

Which goes back to my point. I don't think people are ready to go see "cartoon movies" yet... And I know I heard people say that about both of the aforementioned movies. People can accept movies that are mostly CGI but have real actors, but aside from Disney/Pixar, people aren't going to see total CGI movies.

Masked Ninja
04-17-2008, 09:15 PM
The medium has little to do with it. Hand-drawn, CGI, or live action... if it's a good movie it's a good movie. TMNT was OK, but played it too safe and had some poor writing. Pixar only gets attended because they make good movies that more than just kids will like. Non-Pixar movies usually don't do as well because they're usually not as good. Though there are some anomalies, for sure... The Shrek series isn't nearly as good as the box office says it is.

I think TMNT didn't do as well as they hoped partially because people were turned off by it not being like the old toon. Drama? Infighting? In a Turtles film? Shock! I guess its real problem was it tried to pander to the old toon (groan-inducing one-liners, everything Mike does, silly monster plot, etc) and the comic (dramatic lighting, acting like ninjas, Leo vs. Raph, Turtles with their REAL personalities, etc) crowds at the same time. This led to middle-of-the-road mush, with the bad and good blended into a mediocre paste.

And Beowulf bombed because straight motion capture will never be good.

X
04-17-2008, 09:26 PM
The reason it didn't perform so well isn't because of the movie itself. It had its charm that would make kids flock to it.

Blame Warner.

It goes like this. You don't open a movie that hasn't been in theatres since 1993, when you have -

- 300 in theatres and still performing strong. Although the first week, this made number 1 on the top ten, which is impressive.

- Meet the Robinsons a week later. Because everyone has to be a bandwagon fan, thinking that since it is Disney made, it is automatically worth seeing.

- Blades of Glory opening the same day as Meet the Robinsons. We all know if it's Will Ferrell, bandwagon fans will go see it, because he is funny I assume? Personally I think the guy was only funny in Taladega Nights. His other movies sucked imo. Having Napoleon Dynamite (ie. Jon Heder,) in it could've contributed to its succsess.

Now tell me why TMNT wouldn't have done good, if no movie opened around the same time it did, before and after? People need things to do in my opinion, so had it been the only new release in a larger span between the holiday movie rush, and the summer movie season, I'm sure it would've obtained 100 mil in the US. Now you won't catch me saying it would've gotten Shrek like takes, or Pixar like takes (which Shrek not being a Pixar movie sits higher then any Pixar movie,) but it would've at least achieved 100 mil, or at little over.

Warner needs to learn a lesson, or whoever is directing the sequel. Use some knowledge. See what is coming before or after your planned release, and go from there. Don't release something you aren't sure about in lue of competition. Good things come to those who wait.

-X-

AquaParade
04-17-2008, 09:26 PM
Alright...bad example haha. But I still stand by my statement.

Andrew NDB
04-18-2008, 12:12 AM
The medium has little to do with it. Hand-drawn, CGI, or live action... if it's a good movie it's a good movie.

Absolutely. You speak the truth.

I think TMNT didn't do as well as they hoped partially because people were turned off by it not being like the old toon.

So the reviewers would have us believe... none of which sound like they were ever really even TMNT fans to begin with, but rather in Googling TMNT in a "I need to research TMNT because I'm doing a review about the latest movie" they turn up mostly cartoon/childhood nostalgiac stuff. Which is to be expected.

No, you had it right the first time. If it's a good movie... it's a good movie.

Dragon Turtle
04-18-2008, 12:16 AM
They could run to Lion's Gate. And LG wouldn't censor them either. They'd have no issues with turtles being a PG-13 or even R rated film. They might not be around much longer since they pretty much release anything and hope it does well but it works for me if it means i get to see **** I wouldn't otherwise.
!

Unless Warner Bros gives up the sequel rights to TMNT, we're stuck with them.



And Beowulf bombed because straight motion capture will never be good.

Honestly, I don't believe most people care about the difference between CGI and motion capture.


The reason it didn't perform so well isn't because of the movie itself. It had its charm that would make kids flock to it.

Blame Warner.

It goes like this. You don't open a movie that hasn't been in theatres since 1993, when you have -

- 300 in theatres and still performing strong. Although the first week, this made number 1 on the top ten, which is impressive.

- Meet the Robinsons a week later. Because everyone has to be a bandwagon fan, thinking that since it is Disney made, it is automatically worth seeing.

- Blades of Glory opening the same day as Meet the Robinsons. We all know if it's Will Ferrell, bandwagon fans will go see it, because he is funny I assume? Personally I think the guy was only funny in Taladega Nights. His other movies sucked imo. Having Napoleon Dynamite (ie. Jon Heder,) in it could've contributed to its succsess.

Now tell me why TMNT wouldn't have done good, if no movie opened around the same time it did, before and after? People need things to do in my opinion, so had it been the only new release in a larger span between the holiday movie rush, and the summer movie season, I'm sure it would've obtained 100 mil in the US. Now you won't catch me saying it would've gotten Shrek like takes, or Pixar like takes (which Shrek not being a Pixar movie sits higher then any Pixar movie,) but it would've at least achieved 100 mil, or at little over.

Warner needs to learn a lesson, or whoever is directing the sequel. Use some knowledge. See what is coming before or after your planned release, and go from there. Don't release something you aren't sure about in lue of competition. Good things come to those who wait.

-X-

Well, in their defense (yikes! I'm defending Warner), TMNT was originally set to open March 30th and Meet the Robinsons was to be released in Dec 2006, but Disney switched the release date to March 30th, causing Warner to push TMNT's release date up a week. As for not taking other movies that appeal to older twenty-somethings into account, that was simply short sightedness on Warner's part, to the them this movie was a straight kids movie based on the success of the 2K3 cartoon/toys and was marketed as such, there was little interest in selling this movie to older fans.

But still, whether as a movie directed at kids or older nostalgics, the movie had crap marketing, TMNT had worse marketing then "The Last Mimzy" for pete's sake.
TMNT was treated as a second class movie in terms of importance, and any movie, regardless of quality, will struggle if not promoted properly.

Sage Ninja
04-18-2008, 02:15 AM
"I got five on it.".


five mil or just five bucks :|

Drtooth
04-18-2008, 08:58 AM
TMNT kinda shot itself in the foot by going the CGI route. Had this been a totally new suitimation with some CGI sprinkled in movie, it'd done better money. It'd cost more too, but that's besides the point.


How so? CGI is far cheaper to produce than Live action. And you just couldn't do half the movie in live action with Henson style suits. Personally, I'm glad the film was entirely CGI. I'd have hated to see something where the Turtles were CGI in a live action environment. I'm getting tired of live actors pretending to talk to CGI special effects. it seems so plastic, and inorganic.


The reason it didn't perform so well isn't because of the movie itself. It had its charm that would make kids flock to it.

Blame Warner.

It goes like this. You don't open a movie that hasn't been in theatres since 1993, when you have -

- 300 in theatres and still performing strong. Although the first week, this made number 1 on the top ten, which is impressive.

- Meet the Robinsons a week later. Because everyone has to be a bandwagon fan, thinking that since it is Disney made, it is automatically worth seeing.

- Blades of Glory opening the same day as Meet the Robinsons. We all know if it's Will Ferrell, bandwagon fans will go see it, because he is funny I assume? Personally I think the guy was only funny in Taladega Nights. His other movies sucked imo. Having Napoleon Dynamite (ie. Jon Heder,) in it could've contributed to its succsess.

Now tell me why TMNT wouldn't have done good, if no movie opened around the same time it did, before and after? People need things to do in my opinion, so had it been the only new release in a larger span between the holiday movie rush, and the summer movie season, I'm sure it would've obtained 100 mil in the US. Now you won't catch me saying it would've gotten Shrek like takes, or Pixar like takes (which Shrek not being a Pixar movie sits higher then any Pixar movie,) but it would've at least achieved 100 mil, or at little over.

Warner needs to learn a lesson, or whoever is directing the sequel. Use some knowledge. See what is coming before or after your planned release, and go from there. Don't release something you aren't sure about in lue of competition. Good things come to those who wait.


Okay, Warners usually does a terrible job promoting movies. A terrible terrible job. Kid's movies especially. look at what happened to Looney Tunes Back in Action. They underpromoted it, released it the same season adults would rather see Will Ferrel in an Elf suit acting like a yutz, and Mike Myers in a cat suit, acting like a yutz AND massacring a classic. That one was so bad, we got Loonatics unleahsed out of it (long story short, they blamed the underperformance of the movie on the LT not being popular, leading to stylized relaunching to appeal to a younger, hipper demographic).

And yes, they did release it too close to Meet the Robinsons, which did cut into their kiddy box office. If it wasn't for that, it would be the only kid's film not made by Walden Media (those guys just don't know how to make an appealing film outside of Narnia, do they), and they would have had at least another good week.

But in merchandising the movie shined. And if WB got a bigger cut of that, they would consider the sequal a little more thouroughly.

I'm still saying, Hello? Weinstine, Imagi, 4Kids... they could go into the next one togther if they had to. But it still depends on imagi at this point. not so much if they want to make another, or get a script that Laird will like, it's all about them actually being in business long enough to make one.

Newton Gimmick
04-18-2008, 10:06 AM
I'm not against CGI. I thought the film looked good. I prefer all CGI to CGI sprinkled in...

But I don't think the majority of movie going audiences are. There just hasn't been a CGI movie that's made big money that wasn't a kids movie. If there has, someone please correct me. But Beowolf was supposedly hampered by people not sure about seeing a "cartoon movie" and so on.

I agree with the argument that if a movie is good, it'll do well, but I think we all know that doesn't necessarily ring true. Some of those god awful movies do really good while really great movies sometimes bomb.

And I'm just speaking from personal experiance but I know at least 25 people who TMNT could have struck a chord with who did not go see it because it was a "cartoon movie" despite the fact that I told them how cool some of the fight scenes were and such.

I guess it's splitting hairs. But I'm not saying it's the whole reason the movie didn't do "well" but I certainly think it's a factor. Along with a few key other things.

Masked Ninja
04-18-2008, 10:39 AM
So the reviewers would have us believe... none of which sound like they were ever really even TMNT fans to begin with, but rather in Googling TMNT in a "I need to research TMNT because I'm doing a review about the latest movie" they turn up mostly cartoon/childhood nostalgiac stuff. Which is to be expected.

No, you had it right the first time. If it's a good movie... it's a good movie.Did you stop at the first sentence of that paragraph? I only said the old-toon expectations were "partially" to blame.
I guess its real problem was it tried to pander to the old toon (groan-inducing one-liners, everything Mike does, silly monster plot, etc) and the comic (dramatic lighting, acting like ninjas, Leo vs. Raph, Turtles with their REAL personalities, etc) crowds at the same time. This led to middle-of-the-road mush, with the bad and good blended into a mediocre paste.

I do think I get ya, NG, and that's just a problem with audiences... animation is still saddled with that kiddie label it managed to garner during the '50s (and probably even before). Films like The Incredibles and Iron Giant are still kid-friendly but with a definitely more adult tone, and older people seem to be less embarrassed to admit they like those movies. We just have to keep going with that... push the border a little more. A big jump into R-rated territory will only push most people away, I think. It's gotta be gradual, so that eventually people will wake up and realize that any story can be told with animation, not just kid stuff.

TMNT might have been a proud banner-carrier for more mature animated drama, if it hadn't tried to split its audience to have broader appeal. Ironically, I'm pretty sure that's what kept it from having much popular approval in the first place.

Dragon Turtle
04-18-2008, 02:04 PM
TMNT might have been a proud banner-carrier for more mature animated drama, if it hadn't tried to split its audience to have broader appeal. Ironically, I'm pretty sure that's what kept it from having much popular approval in the first place.



Most of the people who botherd to see the movie in theaters seem to enjoy it well enough, as TMNT enjoyed solid ratings from many user polls, the problem is most people didn't bother to see it, since the ads did the hard sell for this movie as a kids movie, completely shutting off older fans, or just not getting the general audiences hyped up about the movie enough to go see it in theaters.

AquaParade
04-18-2008, 03:21 PM
five mil or just five bucks :|

Five bucks....:/

Drtooth
04-20-2008, 09:05 AM
Did you stop at the first sentence of that paragraph? I only said the old-toon expectations were "partially" to blame.

GAH. I hated that. A lot of the older, and more casual fans probably didn't want to see it because Shredder wasn't being pimped out again, and Bebop and Rocksteady weren't in it. Shredder, I could understand... but other than the old toon (and that pretty much includes the Archie comics and video games, and stuff) those two never set foot into the franchise. Other than a couple references and asides in the new series and like that, nothing.

I feel the new film kept true to the tone they used in the first 3 films. Raph and Leo were constantly at eachother's throats, Mikey was a goof ball, and Donny was only slightly like his cartoon counterpart.

Problem is, the main audience they WERE trying to get was the younger kids who watched the current series. Because the film and the current series had the same tone, the kids weren't lost at all. In fact, they probably liked it the most.

But thinking from a parents point of perspective... think this way. You kid likes TMNT, but you either hate it, or don't care about it, would you spend 10 bucks per person to take your kid, when a week later, you have the safety net of something stamped with the Disney lable on it?

But think this way. Meet the Robinsons was a mild success, sure... but walk into a Disney Store. Walk into one. They're pretty much still trying to get rid of those toys. The plush are like 2 bucks each. Now go down the aisle of a Target or something and look at the TMNT toys. They keep selling constantly, even a year after the film came out. I guess having a current TV show also helps, yes... but you can't deny the film was more successful on a marketable level.

TerranigmaFreak
04-20-2008, 10:38 AM
I'd have hated to see something where the Turtles were CGI in a live action environment. I'm getting tired of live actors pretending to talk to CGI special effects. it seems so plastic, and inorganic.

That's the single most contradictory statement I've ever heard. I guess silicon suits aren't plastic and inorganic. Me, I believe in using the best technique to do the job done, whether it's CGI or suits.

TMNT
04-20-2008, 04:33 PM
I believe more so than anything, cost was a huge factor. Yes, live action and CG can look good. It can also look really bad. We've seen both sides of the spectrum. But those films had quite the budget as well. A movie like King Kong comes to mind. Imagine TMNT done in that style. But I agree, it was a medium not tried before and for the most part, it made that transition with ease. Most of the complaints come from the writing and overall story. The sequel, when it happens, should definitely push for a PG-13 (yes, I'm aware of that whole debate). Because the possibilities are literally endless and would be amazing if someone would just grow a pair and take that risk. Because I have enough faith in the public's taste (though recently it's been slipping with these genre spoofs) that they'll definitely check out the turtles when they reappear if even for nostalgia's sake. But a good story and good animation, etc. makes all the difference. I want it to stand the test of time, which the original does (for the most part, fan or not). Good marketing or not, a good movie is a good movie. And I think we've all made that point pretty clear. I guess that's my two cents. It's nice to see this thread back up and running. Some really good discussions as of late.

Masked Ninja
04-20-2008, 10:09 PM
That's the single most contradictory statement I've ever heard. I guess silicon suits aren't plastic and inorganic. Me, I believe in using the best technique to do the job done, whether it's CGI or suits.I think the point here was that when you're dealing with CGI characters, the real actors have to talk to ping pong balls on a string or something. They never really seem to be looking at the replaced character. And unless they and/or the animation team is really good, they don't usually take cues off each other's subtle shifts or expressions like you would with a real person. At least with the live action suits, the character is physically there to take those cues. In CGI there's usually one animator doing all the characters in the scene, so they can plan in detail how each character reacts to the other.

Agreed that CGI/live could be really cool, but they'd have to nail it. And do you think there will be a budget for that, especially given that TMNT underperformed?

Drtooth
04-23-2008, 09:26 AM
That's the single most contradictory statement I've ever heard. I guess silicon suits aren't plastic and inorganic. Me, I believe in using the best technique to do the job done, whether it's CGI or suits.


Rewatch the Star Wars prequals. You'll see what I mean. Silicone suits are actually quite different, because the actors have something to react to. You can't aknowledge subtilties in a performance in an actor that isn't there. At least one is in the suit. Voice dubbed in, yes... but you can react to what you can see.