PDA

View Full Version : TMNT Sequel - Confirmation of a sequel still pending


Pages : 1 2 [3]

sdp
04-24-2008, 10:32 AM
Anyone else not excited about it anymore?
I know this news is not new anymore but since I've found out Kevin and other talent was just kicked(screwed) out of anything with Imagi with their new management I really don't know if they can make a good sequel. Kevin was pretty passionate, about TMNT and Gatchaman and now who knows what is going to happen with Gatchaman. Its obvious this new "imagi" only cares about money.


------------------------


I think the movie was promoted well, the thing is people my age indeed didn't like the movie being CGI, they felt it as being more of a "kids" movie instead of something like other 80s revivals that can be for both. I wouldn't have gone any other way, going CG was the way to go, it has more to do with the world not ready to take animation anything but for kids.

AquaParade
04-24-2008, 01:38 PM
I dont know...I'm still hoping that if they do another one they will do it right. The direction has to get past Mirage as well...and they already rejected the comedy idea. I'm hoping they know we want something serious.

Dragon Turtle
04-24-2008, 03:57 PM
I think the movie was promoted well, the thing is people my age indeed didn't like the movie being CGI, they felt it as being more of a "kids" movie instead of something like other 80s revivals that can be for both. I wouldn't have gone any other way, going CG was the way to go, it has more to do with the world not ready to take animation anything but for kids.

Keep in mind half the opening weekend audience were older fans, a group that Warner mostly ignored, if Warner had really pushed the movie as something worth seeing in theaters, more casual fans would have gone, instead of just being content to wait for it to hit dvd.

sdp
04-24-2008, 11:31 PM
Keep in mind half the opening weekend audience were older fans, a group that Warner mostly ignored, if Warner had really pushed the movie as something worth seeing in theaters, more casual fans would have gone, instead of just being content to wait for it to hit dvd.



What evidence do we have of this?
All I know is my friends didn't seem to care for it at all and that was the older fans. I have a pretty large range of friend types and really most of then didn't care at all. Most were definitely turned off by the CGI and brushed it as a kids movie. And I saw plenty of commercials for the movie in shows aimed at people my age so I do think they tried to market for an older audience at least with TV ads.

Andrew NDB
04-25-2008, 12:20 AM
Anyone else not excited about it anymore?

Never was.

I think the movie was promoted well

I agree. It was promoted just fine.

it has more to do with the world not ready to take animation anything but for kids.

That was working against TMNT Part 4 as well, yes. The trouble was, even if they filmed that same script as live-action, average people would still have gone into it and realized, "Oh, I've been fooled... it really is just a kid's movie." And word would still have spread to that end.

I dont know...I'm still hoping that if they do another one they will do it right.

The battered-wife syndrome again. "He'll get better, he will," but he doesn't, he just keeps on beating.

Keep in mind half the opening weekend audience were older fans, a group that Warner mostly ignored

If you mean "older fans" by fans of the comic book source material, you're right. If you're implying "fans of the 80s/90s cartoon," I think these fans received more than their fair share of nuggets.

What evidence do we have of this?

None. Dragon's "Half the opening weekend audience were older fans" was made-up. If you were to break it down, I wouldn't be surprised if the actual, tangible number of existing TMNT fans in the fandom right now only comprise a very small percentage of ticket sales... because there's not that many to begin with.

A proper TMNT movie needs to aim far and wide beyond that. They keep going the kiddy, "how can we make the TMNT as least offensive as possible" route and it keeps biting them in the ass, yet they keep on trying it. Like the picture of the snake eating its own tail.

By this point it's just baffling. History repeats itself, over and over again.

Dragon Turtle
04-25-2008, 12:28 AM
What evidence do we have of this?


Warner Bros' own exit polls (ahem not made up):

http://www.boxofficemojo.com/news/?id=2279&p=.htm


All I know is my friends didn't seem to care for it at all and that was the older fans. I have a pretty large range of friend types and really most of then didn't care at all. Most were definitely turned off by the CGI and brushed it as a kids movie. And I saw plenty of commercials for the movie in shows aimed at people my age so I do think they tried to market for an older audience at least with TV ads.


There were a few commercials that aired on tv that weren't strictly aimed at little kids, but these were few and far between, the tv spots that got the most airplay were those "First Great Family Movie of The Year" spots, that were shown mostly during the day time, whose only audience were stay at home moms and dads looking for a babysitter for their preschoolers. Internet info was dead, with the exception of one set visit, and print ads were simply nonexistant. The only major attempt to stir up older audience support was Kevin Monroes' amazing one man show at a couple of conventions.



If you mean "older fans" by fans of the comic book source material, you're right. If you're implying "fans of the 80s/90s cartoon," I think these fans received more than their fair share of nuggets.


By "older fans" I'm refering to any older casual fan who might be the least bit interested in seeing a TMNT based movie, not just die-hard Mirage comic, 80s/90s cartoon fans. And not everyone shares your view of TMNT being a kids movie incapable of being enjoyed by an older audience.

Drtooth
04-25-2008, 09:25 AM
At the risk of sounding contradictory or something, weren't the first 3 TMNT films kid's movies? They just had the advantage of being made before the ratings police turned G rated films into PG rated films. had this film been made the same time, we would have had more violence and at least a little swearing. I really wish that someone stuck out and said, "we want it to be a little more gritty than what we have now." Weird Al told the studio that made UHF to keep the flying poodles and Emo Phillips cutting his thumb off violently scenes in, and it gave them a PG 13 rating...

Hmm... then again, those seem like stupid reasons to make a movie PG 13... like any idiot kid is gonna throw their poodles out the window.

Anyone else not excited about it anymore?
I know this news is not new anymore but since I've found out Kevin and other talent was just kicked(screwed) out of anything with Imagi with their new management I really don't know if they can make a good sequel. Kevin was pretty passionate, about TMNT and Gatchaman and now who knows what is going to happen with Gatchaman. Its obvious this new "imagi" only cares about money.


Not excited? i just flat out doubt it's gonna happen at all at this point. I want names of the new people in charge so I can curse them. Oh, you want to be another kiddy movie factory that makes celebrity voiced farting animals? Good luck. Other than Pixar, that's all we've been getting lately. I have no desire to see crap like Hoodwinked, Surf's Up, or Kung Fu Panda. I want to see a kid's movie that doesn't talk to kids like they're all hyperactive Shin-chan clones with the IQ of tuna salad.

I agree TMNT could have been better, but it also could have been much, much worse.

Damn. At this point, let 4Kids make the damn movie, and make it directlty based off the 2k3 series. even DTV. The fans shouldn't be screwed out of a second film just because a changing of the guard gave us the same slimey, money crazed execs that have no business working in the industry.

Tinuvielsdreams
04-25-2008, 10:09 AM
This is all so disappointing...I really thought we had a chance there for awhile now I am starting to think it isn't going to happen either. My only hope at this point is that whomever has control of all this will wake up and realize this is a good franchise with a lot of potential.

Andrew NDB
04-25-2008, 04:09 PM
At the risk of sounding contradictory or something, weren't the first 3 TMNT films kid's movies?

With the one before it coming out some 15 years previous, TMNT Part 4 needn't have been a slave to those movies' toddler panderings (I do, of course, mean this more to TMNT 2 and 3, though even part 1 had a few dodgy bits).

Hmm... then again, those seem like stupid reasons to make a movie PG 13...

The source material is quintessentially upper-level PG-13 material (R in places, but no need to throw the baby out with the bathwater just for that... I think most fans of the comics would find PG-13 perfectly amicable in a film). What more reason do you need, exactly?

Damn. At this point, let 4Kids make the damn movie,

That's a horrible idea. I don't think any company announcing they're "For Kids" should have anything to do with a TMNT film on principle alone.

Drtooth
04-26-2008, 11:22 AM
The source material is quintessentially upper-level PG-13 material (R in places, but no need to throw the baby out with the bathwater just for that... I think most fans of the comics would find PG-13 perfectly amicable in a film). What more reason do you need, exactly?

I was referring to UHF... the PG 13 rating (according to the commentary) was due to Emo Phillips' bloody, spurting cut thumb, and Raoul's flying poodles getting tossed out the window.



That's a horrible idea. I don't think any company announcing they're "For Kids" should have anything to do with a TMNT film on principle alone.

4Kids is the licensing company anyway. they clearly had some smaller hand in the film... hell, I'd bet they were some of the people pressuring them for a PG rating. I'd rather them just make a movie version of the cartoon series than "TMNT Comedy Movie" anyday. At least, if they made it as dark in tone as before Fast Forward.

Considering Imagi is going the "animashuns R four kiddiz" route, I don't see how that's gonna affect it one way or another. Probably a lot less poo jokes. Maybe that's about it.

thebrownranger
04-26-2008, 10:11 PM
I dont know...I'm still hoping that if they do another one they will do it right. The direction has to get past Mirage as well...and they already rejected the comedy idea. I'm hoping they know we want something serious.

Yeah. Something Mirage vol 1. #50-62 serious...:fshifty:

Monte Williams
05-23-2008, 12:48 AM
This thread's a real bummer for me; I loved the new movie and had no idea the future of the film company and the TMNT movie franchise was so uncertain. :-?

Whitewolf89
06-07-2008, 02:04 PM
Just out of curiosity, what's the news on a sequel? Has anyone heard anything new? I thpught that we were SUPPOSED to hear something in April, 'cause wasn't that when Pete and the associated parties were SUPPOSED to get together to hash out some more ideas for it?

Like I said, I'm just curious about this.

Kendamu
06-07-2008, 02:21 PM
Just out of curiosity, what's the news on a sequel? Has anyone heard anything new? I thpught that we were SUPPOSED to hear something in April, 'cause wasn't that when Pete and the associated parties were SUPPOSED to get together to hash out some more ideas for it?

Like I said, I'm just curious about this.
From http://the-5th-turtle.blogspot.com/2008/05/tmnt-movie-2-update.html

The rumor circulating with regards to the animation studio Imagi and its relationship to the sequel of the TMNT film is, perhaps, true. Below find the official word:

Imagi's unilateral option to produce and distribute a sequel to the 2007 TMNT CG-animated movie expired on April 30, 2008. As a result, while Mirage continues to speak with Imagi, Mirage has begun discussions with several other movie companies regarding the production of a new TMNT film for distribution sometime in the not-too-distant future.

We should have substantial news on this to report by the end of summer. ;)

Dragon Turtle
06-07-2008, 03:18 PM
As close to an official response from Imagi as you're like going to get, came today from Felix IP (executive producer of TMNT) via his blog:

When asked about the relationship between Mirage and Imagi and any future sequel, his response was:

"there are always something is out of your control...don't ask me more...i feel sad enough about that, we did a very cool new designs."

NightwatchersOnlygirl
06-08-2008, 11:27 AM
That's means no Nightwatcher

Jester
06-08-2008, 01:37 PM
yes, yes it does.

ToTheNines
06-08-2008, 02:30 PM
Didn't there used to be an ignore option for other users?

Whitewolf89
06-08-2008, 02:59 PM
From http://the-5th-turtle.blogspot.com/2008/05/tmnt-movie-2-update.html
Thankies for the news, bro. I appreciate it.

The rumor circulating with regards to the animation studio Imagi and its relationship to the sequel of the TMNT film is, perhaps, true. Below find the official word:

Imagi's unilateral option to produce and distribute a sequel to the 2007 TMNT CG-animated movie expired on April 30, 2008. As a result, while Mirage continues to speak with Imagi, Mirage has begun discussions with several other movie companies regarding the production of a new TMNT film for distribution sometime in the not-too-distant future.

We should
.;)
Hmmm, looks like we'll have a bit of a longer wait to find out about that sequel. Ah, well............:roll:

But the bits about the "production of a new TMNT film for distribution sometime in the not-too-distant future" AND about the "having substantial news on this to report by the end of summer" (slight paraphrase there) are good news. IMHO.

Although, as usual, ther are some worrywarts around here that I wish would quit their gloom-and-doom and stressing over stuff that hasn't happened yet. Lighten UP, people! SHEESH!!!

Krang
06-08-2008, 11:02 PM
Didn't there used to be an ignore option for other users?
Here it is (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/profile.php?do=ignorelist).

ToTheNines
06-09-2008, 07:15 AM
Here it is (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/profile.php?do=ignorelist).

Thank you soooo much.

Cowabunga Carl
06-09-2008, 05:19 PM
I really liked TMNT. It was a good movie and that world I feel deserves more screen time. What I want to know is what or who Kari was refering to.

The comic adaptation and it's prequills make it clear they've been around and faced more then Shreader. I believe it is th Raph book they are fighting Tricaratons in.

Ralphmacchio
07-02-2008, 10:26 PM
I wonder who the other studios are? I would love to see Dreamworks jump on this property. I think they could pull it off in either a total animation style or live-action with CGI.

tOkKa
07-15-2008, 04:26 AM
I wonder who the other studios are? I would love to see Dreamworks jump on this property. I think they could pull it off in either a total animation style or live-action with CGI.

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3126/2670145073_30615c9010.jpg

@ http://www.flickr.com/photos/terrible2z/2670145073/

-->> ..!!

>v<

Ralphmacchio
07-17-2008, 06:26 PM
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3126/2670145073_30615c9010.jpg

@ http://www.flickr.com/photos/terrible2z/2670145073/

-->> ..!!

>v<

So is that official? I just read on AICN they pulled that news off the playmates site.

Here is the link:
http://www.aintitcool.com/node/37499

VaughnMichael
07-17-2008, 06:47 PM
It was and thanks to Tokka for bringing the information to me then me e-mailing Murph about it he told Peter and Peter went off on playmates.
Ah the circle of life isn't it loverly.:lol:

Ralphmacchio
07-17-2008, 07:39 PM
It was and thanks to Tokka for bringing the information to me then me e-mailing Murph about it he told Peter and Peter went off on playmates.
Ah the circle of life isn't it loverly.:lol:

I can't picture that guy going off on anyone. There must be more to the story, I doubt Playmates would just go ahead and do that without a logical reason.

VaughnMichael
07-17-2008, 07:46 PM
I can't picture that guy going off on anyone. There must be more to the story, I doubt Playmates would just go ahead and do that without a logical reason.
Nope that's all, they wanted to hype things up in bad times.
And they did just that, well look what it got them now I fist full of Pe...um wait I'm not gonna say that there's to many pervs on this site.:lol:

Roseangelo
07-17-2008, 07:49 PM
I can't picture that guy going off on anyone.

Apparently you've never read Vol. 4 or his blog.

Ralphmacchio
07-18-2008, 12:10 PM
Apparently you've never read Vol. 4 or his blog.

Can't say I have read his blog. What it is called?

Dan
07-18-2008, 06:03 PM
Playmates site now says that Mirage is in negotiation with several companies about a new movie.
http://www.playmatestoys.com/turtleshome/#/tmntmovie/

NameGoesHere1066
07-19-2008, 10:56 PM
Peter Laird seems like the type of person who can verbally rips you into little shreds. :lol:

CyberCubed
07-28-2008, 11:58 AM
Peter is a very nice man in person, not so much online.

I'm convinced they're two different people, honestly. The Peter Laird in real life is so nice and friendly that its really strange to see how different he is online.

Anyone who has met Peter in real life has only said good things about him.

Sabacooza
07-28-2008, 03:30 PM
It's very easy to be nasty online when you don't have to say it in front of someone's face. Many people are guilty of this, myself included sometimes but it doesn't make it right. Maybe if Laird responded to comments a little more professionally and as kindly as he does in person, maybe there wouldn't be so much bad blood between the fans and himself. He has to realize that when he speaks to people on his blog or in his letter column, he's not only speaking to fans, he's also speaking to customers. If you intend to keep customers around you have to get that mindset that the customer is always right even though they might not be. That's just common business sense.

duhril
08-20-2008, 11:26 AM
I just noticed this on Peters blog:

"Yes, we had a movie meeting yesterday (one of several we've had over the last few months). As Mirage policy is to not discuss details until an actual deal is in place, I must be circumspect. However, I can say this -- the people we met with are enthusiastic and energetic and very much want to do a TMNT movie, and I believe they have the wherewithal to accomplish that goal. And it is almost entirely certain that if we do the movie with these folks, it will be a live action/CGI hybrid. -- PL "

This is rather exciting news!

Whitewolf89
08-20-2008, 12:03 PM
I just noticed this on Peters blog:

"Yes, we had a movie meeting yesterday (one of several we've had over the last few months). As Mirage policy is to not discuss details until an actual deal is in place, I must be circumspect. However, I can say this -- the people we met with are enthusiastic and energetic and very much want to do a TMNT movie, and I believe they have the wherewithal to accomplish that goal. And it is almost entirely certain that if we do the movie with these folks, it will be a live action/CGI hybrid. -- PL "

This is rather exciting news!
Indeed! Can't wait to find out the particulars when Peter CAN reveal them!

And, IMHO, a live-action/CGI TMNT would be good. I mean, just look at the 2007 Transformers movie. IT was CGI/live-action, and IT did INCREDIBLY well! It was excellent, both in terms of the storyline AND the way that the live characters interacted with the CGI ones, and I think that a TMNT one done that way would be JUST as excellent. Mainly because it is just AMAZING what they can DO with CGI and special effects stuff these days! Here's hoping that it does as well as TF if they DO do it that way!

And hey, Warners just signed a deal with Wendy and Richard Pini to do an Elfquest movie, and from Wendy and Richard have BOTH said (on their official website and accompanying forum, the "Scroll of Colors", on Richard's blog, and several OTHER official souces connected to them), there is a VERY large likelhood that IT will be done in a CGI/live-action format, as well, so anything is possible!

Anyway, let's hope that we hear MORE on this soon!:D

Tinuvielsdreams
08-20-2008, 12:30 PM
Where on his blog did you read this? Which entry?
This is just so nice to hear even though I am taking this news very cautiously it still good to know things are moving after all

duhril
08-20-2008, 12:50 PM
It was in the "Quazine at the pool... table" blog entry.
http://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=1686991059820767773&postID=872928262252000167

Whitewolf89
08-20-2008, 12:55 PM
Where on his blog did you read this? Which entry?
That's what I'D like to know! I went over to the official website, found Pete's Blog, and went all the way THROUGH it, and never found THAT entry!

Hey, I'm NOT saying that YOU'RE fibbing; just that I, silly Mousey that I oft-times am, could NOT find it. Help?

This is just so nice to hear even though I am taking this news very cautiously it still good to know things are moving after all
Ditto, Tinny. As much as I love this news, I, too, am inclined to lean on the "cautiously-optimistic" side.

It was in the "Quazine at the pool... table" blog entry.
http://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=1686991059820767773&postID=872928262252000167
Cool!

And I FINALLY found it. Guess I was just looking in the wrong place...again. Silly me.:P

Anyway, thankies for the link, duhril. I really appreciate it!;):D

Tinuvielsdreams
08-20-2008, 01:11 PM
Ditto, Tinny. As much as I love this news, I, too, am inclined to lean on the "cautiously-optimistic" side.


Cool!

And I FINALLY found it. Guess I was just looking in the wrong place...again. Silly me.:P

Anyway, thankies for the link, duhril. I really appreciate it!;):D

awesome you did find it :)
Yes cautiously optimistic is the way to go when it comes to this subject whitewolf.
Thanks for the link!

Extreme_Enigma
08-20-2008, 04:46 PM
Finally some movie news. I hope it does happen because I like both CGI and Live Action. I wonder if it's the turtles CGI and everyone else Live Action or the turtles and Splinter CGI with everyone else Live Action.

funatic
09-10-2008, 11:46 AM
Warners just signed a deal with Wendy and Richard Pini to do an Elfquest movie, and from Wendy and Richard have BOTH said (on their official website and accompanying forum, the "Scroll of Colors", on Richard's blog, and several OTHER official souces connected to them), there is a VERY large likelhood that IT will be done in a CGI/live-action format, as well, so anything is possible!

Really? Awesome! It seems like all my favorite comics are hitting the big screen these days... Although it's so nerve-wracking hopeing that they get it right! With the Spirit, Watchmen, Wolverine: Origins, Sin City 2 (& 3?), Scott Pilgrim, Tintin, & now ElfQuest coming up (plus a possible TMNT 2) - I don't think I'll ever be able to sleep for the anxiety and excitement of it all!!!

PizzaPower
09-16-2008, 05:46 PM
so i have been out of the loop a bit
and kinda lost

are we getting a new movie????

Andrew NDB
09-16-2008, 09:46 PM
so i have been out of the loop a bit
and kinda lost

are we getting a new movie????

Maybe. There's a deal on the table. That TPTB don't seem to be rushing to approve it suggests TPTB may not be 100% happy with the deal on the table. It may get reworked and approved, it may not.

TMNT Part 4 went through about 20 deals like this that all petered out before getting made... let's see how many deals it takes TMNT Part 5.

PizzaPower
09-17-2008, 10:29 AM
ah ok plus i read the interview from PL yesterday right after i posted. I dont see why any company would deny the turtles.

Andrew NDB
09-17-2008, 11:11 AM
ah ok plus i read the interview from PL yesterday right after i posted. I dont see why any company would deny the turtles.

What companies? Movie studios? There's a flotilla of reason they'd "deny the turtles," not the least of which being the massive underperformance of the last movie.

PizzaPower
09-17-2008, 12:49 PM
ya movie companies, i dont see why really though.

Andrew NDB
09-17-2008, 04:13 PM
You don't see why companies/studios want to maximize profit and minimize/avoid gambles and/or losses where multi-millions of dollars are concerned? It's not that hard to fathom, really.

PizzaPower
09-17-2008, 05:52 PM
well ya i do see it that way, but the turtles do pretty good with sales really.

Drtooth
09-18-2008, 08:27 AM
What companies? Movie studios? There's a flotilla of reason they'd "deny the turtles," not the least of which being the massive underperformance of the last movie.

Though, to be honest... a lot of movie bombs get sequels. Look at Garfield. That movie tanked over here, and they decided to make a second one. Of course, the second one was a hit in Hong Kong... just no where else. (and wasn't that also due to Shrek 2 and Spider-Man 2 being banned from the country for violence?).

But I agree with what the other dude is saying. The movie merchandise did more than enough good business to warrant a movie based on the selling of merchandise.

Though I do worry for the live action standpoint. While it would look good, the only reason the TMNT movie did as good as it did was because it was relatively low budget. They definitely made back the film's cost. Not to say that a live action film wouldn't attract more eyes...

However, I say if any company would be attached, I could see the Weinstines getting involved. They usually take on the smaller projects. They're funding the Fraggle Rock film that's being written now.

Dragon Turtle
09-18-2008, 01:34 PM
Though, to be honest... a lot of movie bombs get sequels. Look at Garfield. That movie tanked over here, and they decided to make a second one. Of course, the second one was a hit in Hong Kong... just no where else. (and wasn't that also due to Shrek 2 and Spider-Man 2 being banned from the country for violence?).

But I agree with what the other dude is saying. The movie merchandise did more than enough good business to warrant a movie based on the selling of merchandise.


Given the the fact the movie was poorly marketed and planned out in terms of release, it did as well as could be expected, a fact that wasn't lost on WB and other studios who were suprised not just by it's opening weekend performance, but the type of audience it ultimately attracted.


Though I do worry for the live action standpoint. While it would look good, the only reason the TMNT movie did as good as it did was because it was relatively low budget. They definitely made back the film's cost. Not to say that a live action film wouldn't attract more eyes...


The main problem I see with a live action/CGI film is if they go cheap it would look horrible. The only way I see Hybrid type movie working is if they use the same motion capture technique used for Gollum in "Lord of the Rings" or Davy Jones from "Pirates of the Carribean", hire actors/stuntmen/martial artists who can move and fight like Tony Jaa or David Belle, and get a true action/fight choreographer like Donnie Yen. Bad cheap CGI will be a lightening rod for criticism and mockery.

PizzaPower
09-19-2008, 02:54 PM
i agree that could be bad if they just do it with cgi on the action.

CyberCubed
12-17-2008, 12:32 PM
lol, we're almost in 2009 now, what the hell happened to the 5th movie deal Pete was talking about for months?

Dragon Turtle
12-17-2008, 12:50 PM
lol, we're almost in 2009 now, what the hell happened to the 5th movie deal Pete was talking about for months?

We probably won't hear much until New York Comic Con - February 6-8, 2009, the big event that Steve Murphy said would be the most likely place and time for such an announcement, although the last time I wrote to Dan Berger, he mentioned that the current economy was having an effect on the negotiations.

Daniel Orduna
12-18-2008, 04:00 AM
so¡ I am confused... conclusion ...will be a 5th part for the turtles?

goood please pg 13 ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡

turkishproverb
12-18-2008, 09:21 PM
You don't see why companies/studios want to maximize profit and minimize/avoid gambles and/or losses where multi-millions of dollars are concerned? It's not that hard to fathom, really.

You mean the movie that most people agreed did a "respectable" buisiness? Or the movie that the advertising was "botched" on?

Both "Botched" and "respectable" come from professionals on the subject, not the boards. Whatever comes up here, I tend to make my own decisions on the matter irregardless of what I want.

When it comes to holywood and risks, I question how much you really know. Transformers. HUGE risk. Most people thought it would bomb until the trailer came out. Smash hit. Batman begins. After Batman and robin that property was thought radioactive. HULK by Ang Lee should have killed the property, but INcreadible Hulk got made and had a respectable box office take, and a very successful DVD launch. Actually, from what I've heard, TMNT has had good dvd sales as well...

Studio's and backers have shown a tendency lately to give things surprising second chances (IE PUNISHER, HULK) based on the potential of a property. Similarly, after transformers the 80's are significantly more worth taking a risk on in the studio's eyes than they were before.


Andrew, I must tell you yet again that just because an explanation gives you the excuse to be Snarky, it isn't necessarily right.

Reusing the turtles, even ignoring my own fanboyisms (which I learned to ignore pretty fast when it comes to these situations) makes a great deal of sense from a marketing standpoint. When it comes to films, the turtles have ALWAYS turned a profit, even 3 and TMNT. In the case of TMNT it was a respectable profit, and the dvd has sold steadily since.

Daniel Orduna
12-19-2008, 04:37 AM
dude wtf nobody lisen 2 me

Newton Gimmick
12-19-2008, 03:18 PM
dude wtf nobody lisen 2 me

Most of us can't figure out what you're bloody going on about!

IamtheKnight
12-19-2008, 05:59 PM
I hope there is a new movie coming out. Lets just hope that there is a better plot to it.

BoggleKng
12-19-2008, 06:14 PM
Given the the fact the movie was poorly marketed and planned out in terms of release, it did as well as could be expected, a fact that wasn't lost on WB and other studios who were suprised not just by it's opening weekend performance, but the type of audience it ultimately attracted.



The main problem I see with a live action/CGI film is if they go cheap it would look horrible. The only way I see Hybrid type movie working is if they use the same motion capture technique used for Gollum in "Lord of the Rings" or Davy Jones from "Pirates of the Carribean", hire actors/stuntmen/martial artists who can move and fight like Tony Jaa or David Belle, and get a true action/fight choreographer like Donnie Yen. Bad cheap CGI will be a lightening rod for criticism and mockery.

Yes, no CGI.. please or dont totally rely on it.. That's what ruined the Star Wars Episodes..vs. LOTR which had good aspects of CGI.. and I liked the Live Action in the first TMNT movie.. .

Andrew NDB
12-20-2008, 04:06 PM
so¡ I am confused... conclusion ...will be a 5th part for the turtles?

Probably not, but we'll see what happens with the deal that's out there. Gauging by the amount of time that's passed since we've been told the deal was on the table, probably it's a dead duck by now. Coupled with an economic recession, studios/financiers less likely to take risks (factoring in TMNT Part 4's poor performance, a Part 5 is hardly money in the bank), and a S.A.G. strike looming over things... I'm not thinking odds are in its favor.

goood please pg 13 ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡

No ***t.

Daniel Orduna
12-22-2008, 05:16 PM
Probably not, but we'll see what happens with the deal that's out there. Gauging by the amount of time that's passed since we've been told the deal was on the table, probably it's a dead duck by now. Coupled with an economic recession, studios/financiers less likely to take risks (factoring in TMNT Part 4's poor performance, a Part 5 is hardly money in the bank), and a S.A.G. strike looming over things... I'm not thinking odds are in its favor.



No ***t.


thanks

ohh 2 bad :( and u really dont want a pg 13 tmnt movie==???

turkishproverb
12-22-2008, 05:48 PM
Probably not, but we'll see what happens with the deal that's out there. Gauging by the amount of time that's passed since we've been told the deal was on the table, probably it's a dead duck by now. Coupled with an economic recession, studios/financiers less likely to take risks (factoring in TMNT Part 4's poor performance, a Part 5 is hardly money in the bank), and a S.A.G. strike looming over things... I'm not thinking odds are in its favor.



No ***t.

I repeat.

You mean the movie that most people agreed did a "respectable" buisiness? Or the movie that the advertising was "botched" on?

Both "Botched" and "respectable" come from professionals on the subject, not the boards. Whatever comes up here, I tend to make my own decisions on the matter irregardless of what I want.

When it comes to holywood and risks, I question how much you really know. Transformers. HUGE risk. Most people thought it would bomb until the trailer came out. Smash hit. Batman begins. After Batman and robin that property was thought radioactive. HULK by Ang Lee should have killed the property, but INcreadible Hulk got made and had a respectable box office take, and a very successful DVD launch. Actually, from what I've heard, TMNT has had good dvd sales as well...

Studio's and backers have shown a tendency lately to give things surprising second chances (IE PUNISHER, HULK) based on the potential of a property. Similarly, after transformers the 80's are significantly more worth taking a risk on in the studio's eyes than they were before.


Andrew, I must tell you yet again that just because an explanation gives you the excuse to be Snarky, it isn't necessarily right.

Reusing the turtles, even ignoring my own fanboyisms (which I learned to ignore pretty fast when it comes to these situations) makes a great deal of sense from a marketing standpoint. When it comes to films, the turtles have ALWAYS turned a profit, even 3 and TMNT. In the case of TMNT it was a respectable profit, and the dvd has sold steadily since.



Andirew, learn what your talking about. Hollywood typically accepts franchise that are steady moneymakers. Every turtles film has made money. Most of the reasons these films have problems getting produces is Laird. The big exception (The last film not getting a direct sequel) had to do with how many other projects the studio was working on (astro boy, gatchaman, etc...)

Just because an opinion is negative doesn't make it right.

Andrew NDB
12-23-2008, 12:28 AM
thanks

ohh 2 bad :( and u really dont want a pg 13 tmnt movie==???

Sure I do.

Andirew, learn what your talking about. Hollywood typically accepts franchise that are steady moneymakers. Every turtles film has made money. Most of the reasons these films have problems getting produces is Laird.

And you still seem to fail to grasp that, while yes, TMNT made a small profit (overseas, total), there is still only X amount of resources at any given studio.

Let's put yourself in the financiers' place. You are given a budget for the fiscal year to maximize profits to fund motion pictures under your studio's banner to generate the maximum amount of revenue and take the least amount of gambles (especially in these times) over the course of the year.

Throwing money at what would be the fifth movie in a film franchise whose last installment barely turned a profit (when, again, the general rule of thumb/expectation in Hollywood -- at least in terms of the guys ponying up the money to make these -- is that a sequel is expected to do about half the revenue of the previous movie... which is fine, if said movie did 200, 300 million total), with even its cartoon and toys now slated to be cancelled (so now there may not even be a built-in audience, not that it even helped the last movie much)... it's just poor business. A risky gamble, even a fool's gambit.

But for the sake of argument, forget that. Let's assume that, OK, somehow, some way, TMNT Part 5 is guaranteed to earn a small profit. Let's say... optomistically... it turns a 30 million dollar profit total over the production and marketing budgets. That's a tidy profit, right?

But putting such a thing into production requires an enormous amount of man hours, resources, and otherwise money (all of this being finite... studios have set budgets for a given year, you know) that could be put into other movies that are much less of a gamble, that would stand to make a great deal more. You know, Twilight, Hannah Montana numbers.

The big exception (The last film not getting a direct sequel) had to do with how many other projects the studio was working on (astro boy, gatchaman, etc...)

What you're typing here pretty much flies in the face of everything we were told by Steve Murphy and Mirage over the past year or so. There was a deal in play... Imagi was on board, Warner Bros. was on board... they came to Laird and gave them their pitch for TMNT Part 5 as a comedy and Laird told them to go F themselves.

I give him props there.

Just because an opinion is negative doesn't make it right.

I hope that made sense when you typed it.

turkishproverb
12-23-2008, 01:09 AM
Sure I do.

Clearly not a fraction of what you think.

And you still seem to fail to grasp that, while yes, TMNT made a small profit (overseas, total), there is still only X amount of resources at any given studio.

Let's put yourself in the financiers' place. You are given a budget for the fiscal year to maximize profits to fund motion pictures under your studio's banner to generate the maximum amount of revenue and take the least amount of gambles (especially in these times) over the course of the year.

Throwing money at what would be the fifth movie in a film franchise whose last installment barely turned a profit (when, again, the general rule of thumb/expectation in Hollywood -- at least in terms of the guys ponying up the money to make these -- is that a sequel is expected to do about half the revenue of the previous movie... which is fine, if said movie did 200, 300 million total), with even its cartoon and toys now slated to be cancelled (so now there may not even be a built-in audience, not that it even helped the last movie much)... it's just poor business. A risky gamble, even a fool's gambit.

But for the sake of argument, forget that. Let's assume that, OK, somehow, some way, TMNT Part 5 is guaranteed to earn a small profit. Let's say... optomistically... it turns a 30 million dollar profit total over the production and marketing budgets. That's a tidy profit, right?

But putting such a thing into production requires an enormous amount of man hours, resources, and otherwise money (all of this being finite... studios have set budgets for a given year, you know) that could be put into other movies that are much less of a gamble, that would stand to make a great deal more. You know, Twilight, Hannah Montana numbers.

Must...resist..urge..to giggle.

Fact is, expecting a sequel to make half the money of the original has only been the case for low budget Horror films, sports movies and comedies traditionally. Furthermore the expectation has been thrown somewhat for a loop with several franchise doing better than they should have over the past decade. Most of the trends you speak of were common back when Rocky was getting regular sequels with roman numerals behind them, rather than after the end of the twentieth century. The market has changed, greatly.

Furthermore, you have this strange assumption that Twilight and hannah montana are the only types of films to come out in a year. I recall the is spirit coming out later this year. A recent report on The Phantom, a movie that did poorly in the ninties, is being given another chance, and both the Hulk and Punisher got new films, when each of those films bombed horribly at the box office (despite having actual marketing) only to do steady dvd business (much like the turtles).

LImited resources is a separate issue entirely, and really tends to effect the budget a project like turtles would get rather than it being picked up. Ignoring old properties like Turtles generally went by the wayside long before Transformers became a a success. At this point even Dark Crystal is getting a sequel, while the Muppets (despite several flops at the box office) and Fraggles are getting theatrical films made. You seem to be the only one failing to remember that Hollywood likes bringing back old things.

Furthermore, new Toys are another issue when it comes to a property, and they are usually used as advertising for a film to the extent they release before it and the commercials double. The fact a toy line does not exist at the moment will effect mostly the royalty negotiations. While the cartoon show is a small issue, I feel the urge to remind you that the Transformers did not have a current cartoon show when their movie was released, but rather one that released shortly after it.

Ironically, you fail to address the parallel question of how you, as a producer, wouldn't take the opportunity to grab up a franchise that made steady money, even when it was given very little to no advertising.


What you're typing here pretty much flies in the face of everything we were told by Steve Murphy and Mirage over the past year or so. There was a deal in play... Imagi was on board, Warner Bros. was on board... they came to Laird and gave them their pitch for TMNT Part 5 as a comedy and Laird told them to go F themselves.

I give him props there.

1. I should have specified. I was talking about their "Well, we could deliver it eventually...." response on the direct to DVD issue 1 film.

2. So you admit Laird is the issue with getting a film off the ground? And yet somehow your right about noone in their right mind wanting to make a turtle film out of profitability issues? Bwa?




Just because an opinion is negative doesn't make it right.

I hope that made sense when you typed it.

You say that after your last comment?

So, because an opinion is negative, that does make it right then?

'Fraid not.

The comment makes perfect sense. Your opinions are almost always snarky and mean spirited. it seems to define them. And on at least two major issues you fail to see the layers of issues, or even basic problems of the situation.

Roseangelo
12-23-2008, 02:19 AM
I think the ultimate point is that no matter how much Andrew continues to insist that TMNT 2 will never be made due to how TMNT "failed" at the box office, those numbers have absolutely nothing to do with why there has been no sequel announcement.

Really, the most prevalent reason for why there has been no sequel announcement, after Peter Laird was quoted as being "REALLY close" to making a deal, is because the TMNT franchise as a whole is in the midst of nose-diving and you'd have to be stupid to throw any money into it period.

Andrew NDB
12-23-2008, 03:02 AM
Clearly not a fraction of what you think.

Whuh? Of course I want a PG-13 TMNT movie. Why wouldn't I?

Must...resist..urge..to giggle.

Don't stop yourself on my behalf.

Fact is, expecting a sequel to make half the money of the original has only been the case for low budget Horror films, sports movies and comedies traditionally.

Just for kicks, can you offer a citation there? Because it's been the rule of thumb for any kind of "franchise," sequel-driven type of thing for the better part of twenty years now.

I'll kindly eat crow if you can offer such.

Furthermore, you have this strange assumption that Twilight and hannah montana are the only types of films to come out in a year.

Nowhere did I offer these two types of films as the only films to come out in a year. Only two examples of which.

Straw man...

I recall the is spirit coming out later this year.

Eh... what does the Spirit have to do with anything? That's a new franchise based on a very old comic.

And it's got Frank Miller attached to it... who, for the moment, can pretty much do whatever he ****ing wants. Until The Spirit crashes and burns, which most predict it will.

A recent report on The Phantom, a movie that did poorly in the ninties, is being given another chance,

And it'll be 15 years between when that hits theatres and the original film (in other words, irrelevant). If it happens. Still a good ways from a greenlight.

and both the Hulk and Punisher got new films, when each of those films bombed horribly at the box office (despite having actual marketing) only to do steady dvd business (much like the turtles).

Citing the Hulk isn't quite comparing apples to apples here. The Hulk is an example where a studio did their take on the Hulk, Marvel didn't like it, and then Marvel went and started doing their own movies with their own studio and one of the first things they wanted to do was do the Hulk "right." When Mirage Studios opens up their own movie studio, this would be a valid example.

You have a case with the Punisher... although, by this example you make, War Zone was made after the Tom Jane Punisher did only 54 milllion worldwide, right? War Zone is closing at only 7 million dollars... worldwide.

I think we can safely write War Zone off as a collosal failure. You can be certain the beancounters in Hollywood will, especially when it comes time to sign checks for TMNT Part 5. It won't be a thing soon forgotten.

LImited resources is a separate issue entirely, and really tends to effect the budget a project like turtles would get rather than it being picked up.

OK, fair enough. But TMNT, whether it's done with animatronics, CGI, cel animation, or what-have-you, has a certain mid-level budget requirement regardless.

It's a given. You can't lowball it, unless you're shooting for Roger Corman's TMNT.

Ignoring old properties like Turtles generally went by the wayside long before Transformers became a a success.

OK. But I'm not sure your point here.

At this point even Dark Crystal is getting a sequel

I heard positive things about that about 3 years ago, but very grim tidings about it over the past year. Do you have recent news about it?

while the Muppets (despite several flops at the box office) and Fraggles are getting theatrical films made. You seem to be the only one failing to remember that Hollywood likes bringing back old things.

Seriously? Muppets and Fraggles... these things, you can't compare to something like TMNT. Transformers, OK, you can to a certain extent. Muppets and Fraggles... to use a crude, probably not even 100% accurate example, that's like comparing The Tonight Show to Desperate Housewives. I mean, it fits a niche within pop culture's comfort food. It's just... it's just there.

Furthermore, new Toys are another issue when it comes to a property, and they are usually used as advertising for a film to the extent they release before it and the commercials double. The fact a toy line does not exist at the moment will effect mostly the royalty negotiations. While the cartoon show is a small issue, I feel the urge to remind you that the Transformers did not have a current cartoon show when their movie was released, but rather one that released shortly after it.

You're right. I shouldn't have even mentioned the toy line being canned. Just thought it was worth noting.

Ironically, you fail to address the parallel question of how you, as a producer, wouldn't take the opportunity to grab up a franchise that made steady money, even when it was given very little to no advertising.

I see that being said again and again, but that's simply not a matter of fact. I don't know if it's that the people saying that (generally people in their early to late twenties, thirties) just can't grasp that they weren't the target demographic of the last movie and of course wouldn't see commercials for it within CSI, Bones, Lost, etc., but they were there. With children's programming. Hell, when I first got my PS3 -- when it was hot and fresh -- I couldn't avoid ads for a TMNT preview download.

Most indications point to a 15 million dollar marketing budget for TMNT and I think that's about on the mark.

1. I should have specified. I was talking about their "Well, we could deliver it eventually...." response on the direct to DVD issue 1 film.

Oh. Well that's quite another matter entirely. That was a niche project that never made any bones about being a niche project that, yes, would have been badass, but is neither here nor there.

2. So you admit Laird is the issue with getting a film off the ground?

Insomuch as swatting down the horrible pitches being sent his way for approval, yes. I don't want a TMNT comedy that's going to put the final bullet in the brain in TMNT's stock as a serious property and apparently neither does he... I'm glad he's on the level.

And yet somehow your right about noone in their right mind wanting to make a turtle film out of profitability issues? Bwa?

I'm not seeing the connection there. But I'm certain you will illustrate it for me.

You say that after your last comment?

Yes.

The comment makes perfect sense. Your opinions are almost always snarky and mean spirited. it seems to define them. And on at least two major issues you fail to see the layers of issues, or even basic problems of the situation.

Mean spirited in what sense? In the mean spirited way you can open up the paper and the paper is mean-spirited for making your stocks in Starbucks drop 60 points? I'm just being real.

I would love to see TMNT Part 5, PG-13, badass, and if not as a reboot (which I'd prefer), then as a balls-out new jumping on point. But I have no illusions about it being a fairly large longshot at this point.

I think the ultimate point is that no matter how much Andrew continues to insist that TMNT 2 will never be made due to how TMNT "failed" at the box office, those numbers have absolutely nothing to do with why there has been no sequel announcement.

Well, that's not exactly true, is it? If TMNT Part 4 had made $300 million worldwide, I can guarantee you with no uncertainty that "those numbers" would absolutely have everything to do with a new sequel announcement. Because Imagi and WB would be running ragged trying to cut a deal, willing to bend over backwards much further than they would now on what was only a moderately successful last movie.

Really, the most prevalent reason for why there has been no sequel announcement, after Peter Laird was quoted as being "REALLY close" to making a deal, is because the TMNT franchise as a whole is in the midst of nose-diving and you'd have to be stupid to throw any money into it period.

You're very right. But I venture -- and I know no one here wants to hear it -- that it might be for the best, given the pitches thrown out there.

Better to just let things sit on ice for a while. I can read my old comics, you guys can watch your cartoons and play with your toys, and one day (and it probably won't be anytime in the next few years) -- in a perfect world -- someone will realize that behind TMNT's toddler-pandering visage lies a truly badass comic that deserves life on the big screen.

I don't think a studio would leap at it. It will take someone that is on the rise in Hollywood that has semi carte blanche to basically pick their next project (something very, very far from uncommon among many of the hitmakers of our generation -- and anyone that even wants to mention the names "Spielburg," "Lucas," or "Cameron" at this point really doesn't understand what I'm talking about here) that is either a Mirage TMNT fan or someone whose interest is piqued enough by the original stuff to do their homework for the project.

Worst case... it's someone on the rise that's only watched, like, the original cartoon who snags up TMNT and wants to bring that vision to the big screen. And then the vicious cycle repeats itself all over again.

Roseangelo
12-23-2008, 03:11 AM
You're very right. But I venture -- and I know no one here wants to hear it -- that it might be for the best, given the pitches thrown out there.

Better to just let things sit on ice for a while. I can read my old comics, you guys can watch your cartoons and play with your toys, and one day (and it probably won't be anytime in the next few years) -- in a perfect world -- someone will realize that behind TMNT's toddler-pandering visage lies a truly badass comic that deserves life on the big screen.

The problem lies with Mirage as much, if not more-so, as it does with any movie studio. They're the ones who continue to sell the kiddie Turtles and nothing else. Can't have a movie deal without a McDonald's deal and all that nonsense.

Until Mirage gets their **** together, we're better off with no new projects, movies or otherwise.

Andrew NDB
12-23-2008, 03:12 AM
The problem lies with Mirage as much, if not more-so, as it does with any movie studio. They're the one's who continue to sell the kiddie Turtles and nothing else. Can't have a movie deal without a McDonald's deal and all that nonsense.

Until Mirage gets their **** together, we're better off with no new projects, movies or otherwise.

I can't really disagree on any of this...

Dragon Turtle
12-23-2008, 03:31 PM
But for the sake of argument, forget that. Let's assume that, OK, somehow, some way, TMNT Part 5 is guaranteed to earn a small profit. Let's say... optomistically... it turns a 30 million dollar profit total over the production and marketing budgets. That's a tidy profit, right?

But putting such a thing into production requires an enormous amount of man hours, resources, and otherwise money(all of this being finite... studios have set budgets for a given year, you know) that could be put into other movies that are much less of a gamble, that would stand to make a great deal more. You know, Twilight, Hannah Montana numbers.


Every movie is a gamble there are no guarantees that any movie will turn a profit, so if the next turtle movie was guaranteed to turn a 30 million profit, then there would be no stopping the TMNT sequels, it's the movies that continually turn out small profits (Saw, Scary Movie) that grease the wheels of movie studios, not the super tent pole films that studios are lucky to get. And
man hours, resources, and money all fall under production budget.


What you're typing here pretty much flies in the face of everything we were told by Steve Murphy and Mirage over the past year or so. There was a deal in play... Imagi was on board, Warner Bros. was on board... they came to Laird and gave them their pitch for TMNT Part 5 as a comedy and Laird told them to go F themselves.

I give him props there.


I believe it would be naive to think that the only reason why the TMNT 2 sequel fell through was because Imagi and Mirage couldn't come together on a plot, Imagi was indeed going through production hell with Astroboy and Gatchaman (especially the latter), any CGI TMNT sequel would have been placed on the backburner, Murphy did indeed mention Imagi's problems on his blog. I also wouldn't be surprised if Mirage saw a better deal with another studio (CGI hybrid movies aren't cheap), and decided to wait out their contract.


I see that being said again and again, but that's simply not a matter of fact. I don't know if it's that the people saying that (generally people in their early to late twenties, thirties) just can't grasp that they weren't the target demographic of the last movie and of course wouldn't see commercials for it within CSI, Bones, Lost, etc., but they were there. With children's programming. Hell, when I first got my PS3 -- when it was hot and fresh -- I couldn't avoid ads for a TMNT preview download.

Most indications point to a 15 million dollar marketing budget for TMNT and I think that's about on the mark.


15 million is niche territory, considering other animated movies (even ones released in March) have marketing budgets in the 30 and 40 million range, and other better marketed kid movies like "The Last Mimzy" and "Meet the Robinsons" didn't have any problems showing commercials in primetime or putting up billboards and other print advertising. PS3 ads aren't that impressive given how many were sitting on store floors collecting dust back then, even if there was any type of prcedence of the effectiveness of such ads. Even as a strictly kids movie, TMNT wasn't marketed well.





Really, the most prevalent reason for why there has been no sequel announcement, after Peter Laird was quoted as being "REALLY close" to making a deal, is because the TMNT franchise as a whole is in the midst of nose-diving and you'd have to be stupid to throw any money into it period.


Well, again Murphy and Laird stated they would be the ones to first annouce any major movie sequel at a major event next year, not saying that one will be made, but that was the official statemnet given months ago.

And, Rose, Hollywood is filled with stupid people.:P

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/a/a1/Aceventurajrtp.jpg

CJStyles
12-28-2008, 01:16 AM
...really? AV3?

turkishproverb
12-28-2008, 01:31 AM
Yep. Without a Carey in sight.

CJStyles
12-29-2008, 01:00 AM
box office flop right up there with the Son of the Mask

Whitewolf89
12-29-2008, 02:45 PM
box office flop right up there with the Son of the Mask
Yeah, ESPECIALLY since Jim Carrey HIMSELF won't be in it. I mean, he IS Ace Ventura! Someone ELSE playing Ace is like a different actor BESIDES Burt Reynolds playing The Bandit (from the Smokey and the Bandit movies)! IMHO.

Spitfire
12-30-2008, 05:13 AM
Hollywood is filled with business men. A cheap ass movie that will fetch a hefty profit is worth it,even if it sounds retarded. One good opening weekend is all they need.

TMNT will cost to much and probably won't make it back. WB was surprised but they have bigger fish to fry right now. Batman 3 is no where in sight since Nolan said he's not even thinking about it and Bale said he won't do it if Nolan won't and Fox just won they're copyright case against WB over "Watchmen".

Drtooth
12-30-2008, 09:50 AM
... Uh... how come I still see Mirage being the main blame for this, and nowhere do I see Imagi's finger prints on this? Other than the fact Mirage was never happy with their scripts, of course... I mean, look what happened to the AstroBoy and Gatchaman films.

Spitfire
12-30-2008, 02:01 PM
... Uh... how come I still see Mirage being the main blame for this, and nowhere do I see Imagi's finger prints on this? Other than the fact Mirage was never happy with their scripts, of course... I mean, look what happened to the AstroBoy and Gatchaman films.

How is it Mirage's fault that WB has the rights to distribute the film and they don't want to? And Imagi is garbage anyways they need to dump them and get a new company to work with.

Candy Kappa
12-30-2008, 04:54 PM
wow this discussion have really gotten up.

I wish for a live TMNT in Del Toro style or Frank Miller thought Miller can be a bit too much. I want to see real looking humanoid turtles on the big screen.

Dragon Turtle
12-30-2008, 09:09 PM
How is it Mirage's fault that WB has the rights to distribute the film and they don't want to? And Imagi is garbage anyways they need to dump them and get a new company to work with.

WB does not have distribution rights to any future TMNT movie, they did have the rights to distribute the sequel to TMNT but those rights expired along with Imagi's contract last April.

Spitfire
12-30-2008, 09:48 PM
That I didn't know but I do remember reading Mirage was in talks with WB about the sequel and it was WB who gave the thumbs down, most likely because they have bigger things to worry about then a movie that barely fetched enough profit to pay for itself and be worthwhile. That's what you'd call a small success and for a starting out studio that's great but WB are big kids and don't have time for small fish. Once they saw the turtles hardly had the flair they did back in the 90's they said "F it".

And if WB is gonna say that then you can bet no one else is gonna touch it. I guess Lion's Gate could distribute it but if they did it would have to contain several abysmal lines of dialogue and more blood then a GTA game.

Dragon Turtle
12-31-2008, 12:22 AM
That I didn't know but I do remember reading Mirage was in talks with WB about the sequel and it was WB who gave the thumbs down

According to Murphy, everything with Warners was settled, and the only major hurdle left in order to go forward with a TMNT sequel was for Mirage and Imagi to come up with a plot.

Spitfire
12-31-2008, 04:44 AM
Wasn't Imagi out though? Laird was tossing around "Live action with CGI turtles" and all Imagi do is bad far from realistic animation. So unless I'm way behind, which I probably am, that's where I las left it. Laird wanted to do live action. He never said WB personally I don't think I just assumed they still held the rights cause in a case like that the company usually has the rights for several years.

Dragon Turtle
12-31-2008, 11:57 AM
Wasn't Imagi out though? Laird was tossing around "Live action with CGI turtles" and all Imagi do is bad far from realistic animation. So unless I'm way behind, which I probably am, that's where I las left it. Laird wanted to do live action. He never said WB personally I don't think I just assumed they still held the rights cause in a case like that the company usually has the rights for several years.

Laird himself wasn't really looking to make a CGI "hybrid" movie, but the new mystery studio that Mirage is negotiating with wanted to go in that direction, Imagi themselves still seemed to want to be involved with the project as they even made some new models to fit a CGI/live-action movie. But whether it was due to their lack of confidence in Imagi's ability to get the job done or finding a better deal elsewhere, Mirage decided it was best to move on. As to which studio Mirage is currently negotiating with, no one really knows.

CJStyles
12-31-2008, 02:47 PM
I don't care who takes the copyrights for making another film. I just want to see another TMNT movie... one that's PG-13 as everyone has said

Andrew NDB
12-31-2008, 10:12 PM
According to Murphy, everything with Warners was settled, and the only major hurdle left in order to go forward with a TMNT sequel was for Mirage and Imagi to come up with a plot.

Mirage and Imagi to agree on a plot, that is.

Daniel Orduna
01-02-2009, 06:03 AM
does the movie tmnt was a succsesfull movie on usa? good money and stuff?

maybe thats why we dont have a new movie sequel

Drtooth
01-02-2009, 10:10 AM
And Imagi is garbage anyways they need to dump them and get a new company to work with.

If Imagi is still in business within a year, it will be a shock to me... let me put it that way.

does the movie tmnt was a succsesfull movie on usa? good money and stuff?

maybe thats why we dont have a new movie sequel

It made back more than what it cost to make. It was a low budget film to begin with, and it did have some successful merchandise (which gave Playmates delusions of thinking that the overpriced movie figures were all that kids wanted... though it was also due to being ultra cheap and not wanting to pay for new sculpts). And I have seen movies not even half as successful have sequels (Garfield for one)... the problem was, as stated, they could never come to an agreement as to the plot of the next film, and then the license expired. Simple as that.

I don't care who takes the copyrights for making another film. I just want to see another TMNT movie... one that's PG-13 as everyone has said

I've said it a hundredy billion times, I at least want to see a PG movie that's a PG movie and not a G movie with a PG rating.

Andrew NDB
01-02-2009, 05:45 PM
TMNT isn't possible to do properly in even PG pushed to the brink. It was sort of possible in 1990, but certainly isn't anymore. And yes, the MPAA isn't always 100% consistent.

And don't forget, though Imagi and Kevin Munroe have nothing to do with whatever sequel (if any) comes out, Munroe did state right here on the board that, "I don't know how hard we can push for PG-13." I'm assuming this would be true of any director taking on TMNT Part 5 short of a reasonable Name director.

Which is asinine.

Arcade Joe
01-06-2009, 07:55 PM
I agree, the only way to see a PG-13 TMNT movie in my humble opinion is that it would either be a straight to video relesase or on a cable network like HBO or Cinemax. I can remember Spawn on HBO and that was pretty edgy.

Warhorse
02-01-2009, 10:59 AM
I'm taking from the long absence of any official word on a sequel, is that this thing is dead in the water now.:-?

It's a shame. Like, I don't understand how there can be so much focus on say, Wolverine, who is a complex character, and probably my second favorite in the X-Men universe, but yet, hollywood dismisses the Turtles, which are just as complex, and offer a flavor for everyone. Do you all think the franchise being so independent is what hurt it's mass appeal, or is it the independence what saved it's core character? It's like you're damned if you do and damned ifyou don't.

Vegita-San
02-01-2009, 11:16 AM
I'm taking from the long absence of any official word on a sequel, is that this thing is dead in the water now.:-?

It's a shame. Like, I don't understand how there can be so much focus on say, Wolverine, who is a complex character, and probably my second favorite in the X-Men universe, but yet, hollywood dismisses the Turtles, which are just as complex, and offer a flavor for everyone. Do you all think the franchise being so independent is what hurt it's mass appeal, or is it the independence what saved it's core character? It's like you're damned if you do and damned ifyou don't.

Keep in mind that the New York Comic Con is coming up next week, so if there is no movie news at the Mirage panel...THEN it's safe to say there might be cause to worry..

Canadian Turtle
02-01-2009, 12:20 PM
I don't know if anyone noticed but there is an official "new movie in development" on IMDB. That means its a little bit more for real. But it says 2011

CyberCubed
02-01-2009, 01:17 PM
Pete still hasn't finalized a deal though.

I actually wonder if the 5th one is going to keep continuity with the 4th, or if they're going to go with a clean slate altogether.

Given that its a different company, they may not want to use Imagi's CG characters and develop their own style.

Dragon Turtle
02-01-2009, 03:09 PM
Pete still hasn't finalized a deal though.


So he says.


Given that its a different company, they may not want to use Imagi's CG characters and develop their own style.

For a live-action/CGI movie, the cg models from the last movie were never going to be used, even Imagi tried to create new CG turtle models more suitable for a live-action movie.

Andrew NDB
02-02-2009, 12:54 AM
I don't know if anyone noticed but there is an official "new movie in development" on IMDB. That means its a little bit more for real.

Nowadays, a bit. But IMDB has always been just a hair more dignified than Wikipedia as far as movie news is concerned.

CyberCubed
03-08-2009, 08:51 PM
I can't believe its now March, almost a full 2 years after the 4th movie came out in 2007, and absolutely no news whatsoever.

At this rate they might as well wait another few years before they try to reboot the franchise again.

Andrew NDB
03-08-2009, 09:16 PM
At this rate they might as well wait another few years before they try to reboot the franchise again.

Again? There's been no reboot of the films before.

CyberCubed
03-09-2009, 12:06 AM
Again? There's been no reboot of the films before.

I meant the franchise in general. Like the cartoons, toys, comics, etc.

The current gen is winding down, with Vol. 4 ending, Tales ending in 2010, the cartoon ending, etc.

Most likely there will be a 3-5 year gap where the franchise rests and recharges before they try to start it all over again. By that point maybe we'll get a new movie.

Andrew NDB
03-09-2009, 12:17 AM
I meant the franchise in general. Like the cartoons, toys, comics, etc.

The current gen is winding down, with Vol. 4 ending, Tales ending in 2010, the cartoon ending, etc.

Most likely there will be a 3-5 year gap where the franchise rests and recharges before they try to start it all over again. By that point maybe we'll get a new movie.

Oh. Then you're probably right.

Dan
03-10-2009, 03:41 PM
TMNT isn't possible to do properly in even PG pushed to the brink. It was sort of possible in 1990, but certainly isn't anymore. And yes, the MPAA isn't always 100% consistent. So your saying the last movie and the 2003 cartoon weren't done properly?

Andrew NDB
03-10-2009, 09:42 PM
So your saying the last movie and the 2003 cartoon weren't done properly?

The 2003 cartoon was pushed about as far as a cartoon for little kids can go and I respect it on many levels... but I don't think it's profound of me to come out and say that it's still leaps and bounds beneath any kind of proper Mirage-faithful TMNT on the screen. I do see some people around here talking about, "It's absolutely faithful to the Mirage comics!" and I wonder where these individuals bought their beer goggles... because they might help me pretend my girlfriend looks just like Natalie Portman.

And yes, I'm saying the last movie wasn't done properly.

Spitfire
03-10-2009, 10:54 PM
The 2003 cartoon was pushed about as far as a cartoon for little kids can go and I respect it on many levels

I'm not so sure about that I think Justice League hit that mark more then turtles. It had blood and some more in depth content. Also it had some language and implied language. These things don't make a good series but they help something like turtles, that has these things in the source material, be closer to how it's supposed to be. It also opens more doors.

Dragon Turtle
03-11-2009, 12:08 AM
I'm not so sure about that I think Justice League hit that mark more then turtles. It had blood and some more in depth content. Also it had some language and implied language. These things don't make a good series but they help something like turtles, that has these things in the source material, be closer to how it's supposed to be. It also opens more doors.

The 2k3 show got away with as much as it could for an over-the-air broadcast Saturday mourning cartoon, Justice League was a cable show that usually aired at night.

Spitfire
03-11-2009, 02:32 AM
The 2k3 show got away with as much as it could for an over-the-air broadcast Saturday mourning cartoon, Justice League was a cable show that usually aired at night.

Turtles could have had more complex witting like JLU did. That didn't always encompass having more lewd content, though like I said in the turtles case it could help. A time slot is hardly an excuse for the half assed comic adaptions like the 2K3 series did. They cut out content that didn't need to be cut out of some stories that could have been included even with censorship issues.

If the people in charge were allowing them to do stuff as gruesome as some of the episodes that were produced for season 4, which were green lit and made before 4Kids staff changed, they could have done better comic adapts.

Dragon Turtle
03-11-2009, 08:55 AM
Turtles could have had more complex witting like JLU did. That didn't always encompass having more lewd content, though like I said in the turtles case it could help. A time slot is hardly an excuse for the half assed comic adaptions like the 2K3 series did. They cut out content that didn't need to be cut out of some stories that could have been included even with censorship issues.

If the people in charge were allowing them to do stuff as gruesome as some of the episodes that were produced for season 4, which were green lit and made before 4Kids staff changed, they could have done better comic adapts.

Some of the Turtles stories were just as complex some as some of the stories of JLU (not that I personally consider either show overly complex), and 2k3 was never meant to be solely about adapting the Mirage comics perfectly, if anything, having 4Kids put their own spin on adapted Mirage stories was encourage by Laird.

And you are also assuming Mirage would even want to have more gruesome content in a cartoon series aimed at kids, I know one person at Mirage who wasn't really happy that the more violent turtles (compared to the last cartoon) was being unleased on today's children.

Spitfire
03-11-2009, 01:34 PM
If your gonna do it, do it right. That sounds like a bunch of excuses to me. What other people at Mirage think and what Laird approves are two different things. With how Laird felt about the first series I doubt that was his feelings towards this series. Violence isn't even an issue they just cut out stuff from the stories that shouldn't have been. City at war went through a paper shredder*excuse my pun* and got chopped up to hell. All the intelligence behind the writing in that story was gone and we were left with the bare bones. The censors had nothing to do with why 4Kids screwed up some of the comic adapts. Here's a good example and a simple fix for one. In the HATE episode they changed the leader's race completely. Why was that necessary? They mix around the story and have Zog join them in a later episode instead of "Return To New York". I could go on but you get my point.

The comic adapt episodes are easily the worst episodes of the series. I'd take a newly written one any day over them.

CyberCubed
03-11-2009, 02:01 PM
It's because City at War came too early in the cartoons lifespan compared to the comics. April/Casey knew each other for years by that point in the comics, they only knew each other for about a year in the cartoon at that point.

Did you honestly expect the whole Gabrielle storyline to be done in the show? I sure as hell didn't, a woman dying at childbirth and Casey forced to father her child...in the cartoon?

Likewise Rat King wasn't even introduced in the show yet, so they couldn't have done that story. I figure if the show went on longer we might have seen that subplot adapted at some point.

As for the violence, of course you weren't going to see people pumped full of lead and Foot being killed on the streets. There's no way it would fly on Saturday mornings.

Dragon Turtle
03-11-2009, 02:39 PM
If your gonna do it, do it right. That sounds like a bunch of excuses to me. What other people at Mirage think and what Laird approves are two different things. With how Laird felt about the first series I doubt that was his feelings towards this series.


Laird was mostly satisfied in just having the show capture the "spirit and essence of the TMNT comics", something he felt the original series didn't do, at the same time create another TMNT universe which could stand on its own.

If he wanted to, Laird could have lorded over the 4Kids creative staff to make everything as close to the Mirage comics as possible, he was always in constant contact with them concerning designs for the show, but he was willing to let 4Kids do want they wanted.

Aztec General
03-11-2009, 06:06 PM
The first four seasons of the 2K3 series were about as good as you could ask for. Especially for us Mirage fans. I haven't really watched since then, Ninja Tribunal looked too mystical and non-TMNT for me, Fast Forward was utter garbage, and I haven't watched the new season (just lost interested).

But I really do think the first four seasons were well done!

Andrew NDB
03-11-2009, 10:33 PM
The first four seasons of the 2K3 series were about as good as you could ask for.

For a children's cartoon, I would tend to agree.

Spike Spiegel
03-16-2009, 05:57 PM
But I really do think the first four seasons were well done!

Definitely. The first four TMNT 2k3 seasons have been the one series to be on par with/better than Batman: TAS/the DCAU for me (at least, until The Spectacular Spider-Man came out).

Dan
03-16-2009, 06:35 PM
Here's a good example and a simple fix for one. In the HATE episode they changed the leader's race completely. Why was that necessary? They mix around the story and have Zog join them in a later episode instead of "Return To New York". I could go on but you get my point. I think Skonk was changed because they didn't want too many black bad guys. And I think the Zog thing doesn't matter I don't see how having him die in Shredder's tower would be any better than on his ship.

CyberCubed
03-21-2009, 06:21 PM
In that recent Murphy interview he says Mirage is still in negotiations with "several companies," so they seem to be still trying for another movie.

Perhaps they're just leaving the possibility open when the economy recovers? Although that'll be awhile yet.

Warhorse
03-29-2009, 01:12 AM
Any of you thinking that if another movie is eventually green lit, it's more than likely going to be another reboot?

Whitewolf89
03-29-2009, 01:33 PM
Any of you thinking that if another movie is eventually green lit, it's more than likely going to be another reboot?
Oh, dear Lord, I hope not! The reboot thing has been done to death!

Monte Williams
03-29-2009, 05:17 PM
Ya see that signature in the post above mine?

That's the approach I want for the next movie.

It remains the best take on Ninja Turtles on large or small screen, in my opinion.

Andrew NDB
03-29-2009, 05:33 PM
Any of you thinking that if another movie is eventually green lit, it's more than likely going to be another reboot?

Let's hope so.

Oh, dear Lord, I hope not! The reboot thing has been done to death!

What do you mean? There hasn't even been a single reboot of the TMNT on the big screen yet.

ToTheNines
03-29-2009, 05:45 PM
What do you mean? There hasn't even been a single reboot of the TMNT on the big screen yet.

TMNT 07 had zero returning cast/crew memebers from the 90's trilogy. As well as a different medium, different music style, different takes on alot of the characters and very loose references to it.

I call that a reboot.

Monte Williams
03-29-2009, 05:49 PM
TMNT 07 had zero returning cast/crew memebers from the 90's trilogy. As well as a different medium, different music style, different takes on alot of the characters and very loose references to it.

I call that a reboot.

The medium and music had more to do with how much time had passed than anything else; movies are different today.

Despite the new look and sound, it's very much a continuation of the trilogy.

And where the cast is concerned... it had been more than a decade; what are you gonna do?

Cipher
03-29-2009, 05:57 PM
Ugh. Guys, if you want TMNT to be taken seriously on the big screen, it needs a reboot.

If it's going to shift into a more serious/darker tone, it needs to be reintroduced to the public in a way that will allow them to swallow that change. Plus, people hate loose sequels.

Monte Williams
03-29-2009, 06:00 PM
Ugh. Guys, if you want TMNT to be taken seriously on the big screen...

I'm not sure that adults who are not already enamored with the property are ever going to take it as seriously as you would like. They have a preconceived notion of what Ninja Turtles is (and probably with good reason); any darker, drastically more earnest take is only going to provoke a response along the lines of, "Huh. Weird. Ninja Turtles is all dark and serious now."

I can't see that it would suddenly bring in a new crowd or anything.

Andrew NDB
03-29-2009, 06:12 PM
TMNT 07 had zero returning cast/crew memebers from the 90's trilogy. As well as a different medium, different music style, different takes on alot of the characters and very loose references to it.

I call that a reboot.

You seem confused about what a reboot is.

Monte Williams
03-29-2009, 06:16 PM
You seem confused about what a reboot is.

Agreed. 'Reboot' implies starting the story afresh; retelling the origin, usually.

If anything, TMNT, whatever your opinion of it, assumed quite a bit of prior knowledge on the part of the viewer.

ToTheNines
03-29-2009, 07:25 PM
If anything, TMNT, whatever your opinion of it, assumed quite a bit of prior knowledge on the part of the viewer.

Assumed knowledge about TMNT in general, not neccessarily the movies. In basically every universe they get mutated by ooze, get trained by Splinter and have beef with Shredder. I thought they made a good decision by not beating that dead horse again.

Candy Kappa
03-30-2009, 07:55 AM
TMNT 07 had zero returning cast/crew memebers from the 90's trilogy. As well as a different medium, different music style, different takes on alot of the characters and very loose references to it.

I call that a reboot.

jeez did you even see the movie? it was the forth continuation of the other films, it was mentioned that shredder where gone, you see shredder helmet and the time scepter in the movie as well.

it wasn't a reboot.

if you don't know what a reboot is look at "batman" and "batman begins"

Warhorse
03-30-2009, 09:25 AM
Maybe you guys should use the Batman movies to explain exactly what a reboot is.

ToTheNines
03-30-2009, 05:51 PM
jeez did you even see the movie? it was the forth continuation of the other films, it was mentioned that shredder where gone, you see shredder helmet and the time scepter in the movie as well.

No, actually I didn't... I just read the plot off of wikipedia. Jack ass.

The only thing you have is the fact that Shredder's dead, and he dies/gets defeated IN EVERY TMNT UNIVERSE. I'm not saying that this movie is in continuity with any other tmnt universe, but that's just common knowledge at this point.

Also, just because the helmet and scepter were there doesn't mean ****. There was also mouser parts, Triceraton/Utrom technology and other random **** from the comic book universe.

I can also think of like 15 characters from the 90's that weren't even mentioned in this one, plus April's change in career. You know damn well that Hoag's/Turco's version of April would not learn martial arts.

Lastly, take grammar lessons.

Jester
03-30-2009, 06:06 PM
April liked to do a little chucking now and then....

I got nothing.

CyberCubed
04-23-2009, 12:22 AM
I guess this thread can be closed now.

It's honestly shocking that all the naysayers were proven wrong. I have to say I'm shocked myself, I really didn't think TMNT would get another movie, especially so soon.

Krang
04-23-2009, 01:49 AM
I guess this thread can be closed now.
Yes, please use the new thread to discuss the upcoming movie.